《锡安长老议定书》封面

锡安长老议定书

The Protocols of the Elders of Zion

Victor, E Marsden · 初版 1903 年

1人推荐
50位读者提及
53次提及

为什么值得读

  • 是阴谋论与制造对立宣传的典型代表
  • 展现制造敌意与虚假叙事的套路

Hacker News 上怎么说

  • ……2001年书店里把“graphic novel”(图像小说)列为一个门类。” https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Graphic_novel 我最近读了《与上帝有约》(A Contract with God)以及埃斯纳的其他一些作品,比如《阴谋:锡安长老会纪要秘史》(The Plot: The Secret Story of the Protocols of the Elders of Zion),还有《漫画与顺序艺术》(Comics and Sequential Art)里“生存还是毁灭”(To be, or not to be)那段独白的分镜版本——简直太棒了。

    …"graphic novel" as a category in book stores in 2001." https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Graphic_novel I read A Contract with God and some other of Eisner's stuff lately, e.g. The Plot: The Secret Story of the Protocols of the Elders of Zion, and the version of the "To be, or not to be" speech in Comics and Sequential Art - just awesome.

  • 你在曲解你回复的那位网友的话——你把“重度参与”(heavily involved)偷换成了“控制”(controlling)。至于《锡安长老会纪要》(The Protocols of the Elders of Zion),那本书的关键就在于它当年被包装成非虚构作品来招摇撞骗,是带着欺诈性质被当作真实文献呈现的。

    You're twisting the words of the person you replied to - you've changed 'heavily involved' to 'controlling'. And regarding The Protocols of the Elders of Zion. The whole point of that book is that it was passed off as not being fictional. It was fraudulently presented as a real text.

  • ……(https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ron_Unz),他目前经营着《Unz评论》(The Unz Review,https://www.unz.com/ )。《Unz评论》目前的头条文章是 Karl Haemers 写的《重访纪要》(The Protocols Revisited),这是对托马斯·道尔顿博士(Thomas Dalton PhD)编辑翻译的《锡安长老会纪要:权威英文版》(Protocols of the Elders of Zion: The Definitive English Edition)的书评:“托马斯·道尔顿博士完全对得起书名宣称的宏大定位——《锡安长老会纪要:权威英文版》……

    …(https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ron_Unz), who currently runs The Unz Review (https://www.unz.com/). The Unz Review currently has the following article at the top of its page: The Protocols Revisited by Karl Haemers, which is a review of Protocols of the Elders of Zion: The Definitive English Edition, Edited and Translated by Thomas Dalton PhD. "Thomas Dalton, PhD has achieved the high claim of his title, Protocols of the Elders of Zion: The Definitive English Edition.…

  • “这是假的!”——出自《深空九号》(Deep Space 9)的《月下幽光》(In the Pale Moonlight)。《锡安长老会纪要》就已经够恶劣了。想象一下要是我们还能伪造音频和视频会怎样。你看过《政界风云》(The Contender)吗?讲的是对一位潜在副总统人选(汉森)的背景审查。纽约时报对该片的影评提到:右翼……

    "It's a fake!" -- In the Pale Moonlight, Deep Space 9 The Protocols of the Elders of Zion is bad enough. Imagine if we could fabricate audio and video. Did you ever see The Contender? It's about the vetting of a potential Vice President (Hanson). From the NYT review of the film: The right-wing…

  • ……如今受到的待遇,深深根植于几个世纪以来围绕犹太人群体的文化偏见或欧洲渊源,尤其是从15世纪往后。一个很好的参照就是去研究一下《锡安长老会纪要》;无论作者最初的意图是什么(如今有相当确凿的证据表明它最初可能带有讽刺意味),你都无法忽视这样一个事实:当时大多数人都把它当成了“即使……也是真的”

    …receives today is rooted heavily in the cultural bias or European origin that surrounded the Jewish people for centuries especially since the 15th Century onwards. A good parallel would be to explore the "Protocols of the Elders of Zion"; regardless of what was the original intent of the author (there is quite strong evidence today that it was intended to be a parody) you can't ignore the fact that it was mostly accepted as "true even…

  • 确实是这样——但源头并非他们。1903年在俄罗斯出版的《锡安长老会纪要》挑起了这种特定的论调——而纳粹只不过是顺水推舟,利用了大众早已根深蒂固的想法。而且确实,往上说到我祖母,她就是个歇斯底里的反犹分子,……

    Yes it was - but it didn't start with them. The Protocols of the Elders of Zion, which was published in 1903 in Russia, kicked off that particular idea - and the nazis just ran with what popular thought already held. Also, true - going back to my grandmother, she's a raving anti-Semite,…

正在加载完整评论……

键盘快捷键

/
聚焦搜索框
j / k
下一本 / 上一本
Enter
打开选中的书
Esc
关闭 / 返回
g h
回到首页
g b
值得读精选
g t
历史总榜
g r
上升最快
g l
我的书架
?
显示本帮助