性别麻烦
Gender Trouble
Judith Butler · 初版 1989 年
6人推荐
11位读者提及
13次提及
为什么值得读
- 全面解构性别角色，提供审视自我的新视角
- 了解现代女性主义与性别议题不可绕过的专著
- 理论冲击力强，促使读者反思社会规范的约束
作为过去五十年里最受热议的学术著作之一，Judith Butler的Gender Trouble名满天下，也备受争议。Butler认为传统女性主义诉诸女性的天然、“本质”观念乃至对性或性别的本质认知是错误的，她从质疑“女人”这一范畴入手，继而对“男性气质”与“女性气质”展开考察。然而，Butler最为著名、却也最常被误解的，是她将性别视为一种反复重申的社会表演，而非先验现实的表达。这部激动人心且极富挑衅意味的
Hacker News 上怎么说
正在加载完整评论……
如果你想挑战一下自己，读点对性别和性别角色极其晦涩硬核的学术解构，我推荐朱迪斯·巴特勒，尤其是《性别麻烦》和《消解性别》。真心希望哪天可汗学院（Kahn Academy）能出一套科普视频，用大白话讲讲她的理论。:) 编辑：没法直接回，就在这回一下楼下的评论吧：Symmetry：……
If you want a challenge, and want to read some really dense academic deconstruction of gender and gender roles, I recommend Judith Butler, specifically "Gender Trouble" and "Undoing Gender". And hopefully someday Kahn Academy will do a video series explaining her work in laymans terms. :) EDIT: Can't reply, so I'm responding to the comment below here: Symmetry:…
……以我非常粗浅的了解，用大白话来解释大概就是这样——但就像任何值得研究的课题一样，它非常复杂。在很多人眼里，该领域的奠基之作是朱迪斯·巴特勒的《性别麻烦》——如果你真的想深入了解这方面的知识，建议去翻翻看。
…that's how I've understood it in layman's terms and with my very basic knowledge--it's very complex, as with anything worth studying. The seminal text on the issue in the eyes of many is Judith Butler's Gender Trouble--If you truly are serious about wanting to learn about this stuff I suggest you check it out.
J. 巴特勒的《性别麻烦》和《脆弱的生命》。这两本书让我不仅对性别，而且对整个人生与自由都有了全新的视角。而且文风绝佳！
Gender Trouble by J. Butler and Precarious Life by J. Butler These two allowed me to adopt a whole new perspective on not just gender but life and liberty in general. Also, great writing style!
……试图构建一种存在主义伦理学，短小精悍，很赞。说句大实话，《第二性》对现代人的胃口来说略显枯燥——尽管它地位举足轻重。如果你想更好地把握现代女权主义脉搏，我建议读读朱迪斯·巴特勒的《性别麻烦》之类的作品。
…attempt to form an existentialist ethics, and is short, and good. Tbqh "The Second Sex" is a bit dry for modern tastes - even though it is important. I'd recommend reading something like Judith Butler's "Gender Trouble" if you want a better feel for modern feminism.
……归结到底就是你太懦弱了，不敢做自己。这话可能不好听，但如果你因为性别角色限制而不敢享受某种事物，那你就是个懦夫。我真诚地建议读一读性别理论。朱迪斯·巴特勒的《性别麻烦》出人意料地是一部很适合入门的作品，虽然它最初写出来并不是为了做入门书的。
…to is that you're too weak to be yourself. This might hurt to hear, but you're a coward if you let gender roles stop you from enjoying something. I sincerely recommend reading some theory on gender. Gender Trouble by Judith Butler is a surprisingly approachable introduction to the subject, despite not being written as such.
……无法接受词语的含义其实取决于讨论双方的理解，这是心智不成熟的表现。如果你想进一步阅读关于生理性别（sex）和社会性别（gender）是如何运作的，我推荐朱迪斯·巴特勒的《性别麻烦》。
…unable to accept that the meanings of words is as they are understood by the parties in the discussion is a sign of emotional immaturity If you'd like further reading on how sex and gender work, I suggest Gender Trouble by Judith Butler.