与老兵同在
With the Old Breed
E.B. Sledge · 初版 1981 年
13人推荐
13位读者提及
17次提及
为什么值得读
- 一线士兵不加修饰的线性真实记录
- 还原太平洋战场的残酷与战争本质
- 带来深刻的谦逊感与第一手历史视角
在《华尔街日报》中，Victor Davis Hanson 将 With the Old Breed 评为描写二十世纪史诗战役的五佳书籍之一。Studs Terkel 曾就其权威口述史著作 The Good War 采访过本书作者。如今，E. B. Sledge 广受赞誉的贝里琉岛与冲绳岛作战第一人称实录再度归来，给新一代读者带来震撼、教益与启发。Eugene B. Sledge 是一个深受美国历史熏陶、崇拜 George Washington 和 Daniel Boone 等英雄的阿拉巴马男孩，后来成为了战时著名的海军陆战队第一师第5团第3营的一员。即便经历了严苛的训练，他依然
Hacker News 上怎么说
正在加载完整评论……
……听到了很多有趣的故事，我经常想以程序员的视角把这些写成一本书，纯粹就是把想法付诸文字。有一本书叫《同老兵在一起》（With the Old Breed）https://www.amazon.com/Old-Breed-At-Peleliu-Okinawa/dp/08914... 它是以一名二战士兵的视角写的，只是单纯按顺序记录一件件发生的事，几乎没有任何个人煽情修饰。就是一个很平铺直叙的……
…to a lot of interesting stories, and I have often thought of writing a book collecting these into a single work from the perspective of a programmer, simply putting thoughts to paper. There is a book, With the Old Breed https://www.amazon.com/Old-Breed-At-Peleliu-Okinawa/dp/08914... It's the perspective of a WW2 solider, and simply chronicles events one after another with very little personal flair. Simply a linear…
……战况。然而，如果在中途岛战败，美国可能就无法在太平洋发起任何攻势了。> a.) 它们似乎更能代表大多数战争的真实面貌。是的，确实如此。我强烈推荐《同老兵在一起》（With The Old Breed）。它某种程度上算是《百大战役》（100 Decisive Battles）的反面：一个普通士兵提笔记录下了他对冲绳战役从头到尾记得的所有细节。亚马逊链接：https://www.amazon.com/Old-Breed-At-Peleliu-Okinawa/dp/08914...……
…locations. A U.S. loss at Midway, however, may have precluded any U.S. offensive into the Pacific. > a.) they seem more representative of what most war is like Yes, that's true. I'd highly recommend With The Old Breed. It's sort of the inverse of 100 Decisive Battles: a single soldier put his pen to paper and recorded everything he remembered about the Okinawa conflict, from start to finish. Amazon: https://www.amazon.com/Old-Breed-At-Peleliu-Okinawa/dp/08914...…
我会去搜个摘要看看，要是看着不错就读一读。我 Google 了一下感觉这书有点历史修正主义的味道，不过我还是会看看的。既然我们要办读书会，不妨试试 Eugene Sledge 的《同老兵在一起》（With the Old Breed）和/或 James Bradley 的《父辈的旗帜》（Flyboys），去看看日本军队在整个太平洋扩散的人间地狱。读到《同老兵在一起》的最后，我整个人在精神上其实都快虚脱了……
I will check out a summary and if it looks good I will give it a read. My googling makes it look a bit revisionist but I will check it out. Since we are starting a book club try 'With the Old Breed' by Eugene Sledge and/or 'Flyboys' by James Bradley to see the hell on earth the Japanese military had exported all over the Pacific. I was actually somewhat mentally exhausted by the end of 'With the…
《同老兵在一起》（With the Old Breed）是一本真正伟大的书。
With the Old Breed is a truly great book.
题外话：想要获得看问题的视角、谦卑之心和深刻的历史洞察，一个极好的来源是 E. B. Sledge 关于二战冲绳和佩莱利乌战役的亲历回忆录。《同老兵在一起》（With The Old Breed），http://www.amazon.com/With-Old-Breed-Peleliu-Okinawa/dp/0891...
Tangential: a great source of perspective, humility and historical insight is E. B. Sledge's first hand account of the WWII battles at Okinawa and Peleliu. With The Old Breed, http://www.amazon.com/With-Old-Breed-Peleliu-Okinawa/dp/0891...
E. B. Sledge 的自传《同老兵在一起》（With the Old Breed）描述了他作为一名海军陆战队员在太平洋的作战经历，如果你对那段历史感兴趣的话非常值得一读。http://www.amazon.com/gp/aw/d/0891419195/ref=redir_mdp_mobil... 我祖父曾服役于……
E. B. Sledge's autobiography, With the Old Breed describes his combat experiences as a Marine in the Pacific and is worth reading if your interested in that history. http://www.amazon.com/gp/aw/d/0891419195/ref=redir_mdp_mobil... My grandfather served…