异端
Heretics
Gilbert Keith Chesterton · 初版 1905 年
5人推荐
10位读者提及
24次提及
为什么值得读
- 论证严密巧妙，能有力撼动读者的固有观点
- 虽成书已久但文中论题依然切中现实
- 擅长运用生动耐人寻味的扩展示喻
Gilbert Keith Chesterton 于 1874 年 5 月 29 日出生于英国伦敦。尽管他自诩不过是一名快乐奔忙的新闻记者，但他实际上是一位在文学各个领域都著作等身、才华横溢的作家。他立场坚定，且极擅长为自己的观点辩护，然而其开朗热情的性格仍让他与许多人保持了深厚的友谊——例如 George Bernard Shaw 和 H.
Hacker News 上怎么说
正在加载完整评论……
……娱乐业以及行政管理国家——在被这种灌输洗脑、进而变得厌恶西方和基督教之后，我真心觉得以下这些书堪称终极颠覆认知、让人脑洞大开的神作：- G·K·切斯特顿的《异教徒》（Heretics）- G·K·切斯特顿的《正统》（Orthodoxy）- 玛丽·格拉巴的《揭穿霍华德·津恩：曝光让一代人反美的伪历史》- 托马斯·索维尔的《视觉的冲突》（A Conflict of Visions）- ……
…entertainment, and the administrative state — and after coming to hate the west and Christianity as a consequence of this indoctrination, I really found the following books to be the ultimate mindfucks: - Heretics by GK Chesterton - Orthodoxy by GK Chesterton - Debunking Howard Zinn: Exposing the Fake History That Turned a Generation against America by Mary Grabar - A Conflict of Visions by Thomas Sowell -…
……极具争议但写得极其巧妙的随笔。我就喜欢有人用深思熟虑的论据来挑战我自己的观点。那就试试切斯特顿吧。虽然有点年代了，但依然不过时。比如可以试试《异教徒》。
…controversial but cleverly put together essays. I like it when someone challenges my own views with a well thought through argument, Try Chesterton then. A little old but still relevant. E.g. could try Heretics.
……G·K·切斯特顿、哈兹里特、爱默生、罗伯特·路易斯·史蒂文森、桑塔亚纳、伯特兰·罗素、H·L·门肯、奥斯卡·王尔德、威廉·詹姆斯。他们写的几乎所有东西都很棒，不过这里有几个不错的切入点：切斯特顿——《异教徒》、《多样的类型》；哈兹里特——《坦率的演说者》、《桌谈录》；爱默生——《随笔集：第一集与第二集》；史蒂文森——《处女与玩伴》、《横跨平原》；桑塔亚纳——洛根·皮尔索尔·史密斯编选的《短篇随笔集》……
…GK Chesterton, Hazlitt, Emerson, Robert Louis Stevenson, Santayana, Bertrand Russell, HL Mencken, Oscar Wilde, William James Almost everything they wrote, but some good starting points: Chesterton - Heretics, Varied Types Hazlitt - The Plain Speaker, Table-Talk Emerson - Essays: First and Second Series Stevenson - Virginibus Puerisque, Across the Plains Santayana - Little Essays ed. Logan Pearsall Smith…
G·K·切斯特顿在这个话题上讲得很精辟，出自《异教徒》（1905）中的《科学与野蛮人》：某些野蛮部落为何崇拜猴子或月亮的秘密，就算你深入这群野蛮人中间、并在笔记本上记录下他们的回答，也是找不到答案的……这个谜团的答案……
GK Chesterton is great on this subject, in Science and the Savages from Heretics (1905): The secret of why some savage tribe worships monkeys or the moon is not to be found even by travelling among those savages and taking down their answers in a note-book... The answer to the riddle…
……史蒂文森只写小说，或者尼采最好的作品是《查拉图斯特拉》，或者切斯特顿最好的作品是《The Man Who Was Thursday》！（我只读了他大量作品中的一小部分……但）我最喜欢的他的书也许是《Heretics》，讲的是当代的一些思潮和思想错误——萧伯纳、尼采、托尔斯泰、虚无主义等等。它非常精彩，而且非常有趣，像他的大多数作品一样，但更甚。百读不厌。还有《What's……
…Stevenson only wrote fiction, or Nietzsche's best is Zarathustra, or Chesterton's best The Man Who Was Thursday! (I've only read a small part of his huge output.. but) My favourite of his books maybe is Heretics, on some contemporary trends and errors of thought—Shaw, Nietzsche, Tolstoy, nihilism etc. It's just brilliant, and very funny, like most of his stuff, though more so. Endlessly re-readable. Also What's…
切斯特顿在多篇著作中反复表达过类似的观点。我挺喜欢他在《异教徒》一书里用的这个延伸隐喻：“假设街上因为某件事引起了轩然大波，比方说是一根路灯柱吧，许多有影响力的人都想把它拆掉。一位灰衣修士走了过来，他是中世纪精神的化身，……
Chesterton reiterated similar ideas to this in several of his writings. I like this expanded metaphor, from the book Heretics: 'Suppose that a great commotion arises in the street about something, let us say a lamp-post, which many influential persons desire to pull down. A grey-clad monk, who is the spirit of the Middle Ages,…