宿命三角
The fateful triangle
Noam Chomsky · 初版 1983 年
6人推荐
6位读者提及
8次提及
Noam Chomsky 论述中东政治的开创性巨著已成为政治学与中东事务领域的经典。为了第十次印刷，Chomsky 增补了全新章节使全书内容与时俱进，包括由 Chomsky 新撰的前言、巴勒斯坦作家兼活动家 Edward W. Said 撰写的新序言，以及关于巴勒斯坦大起义（Intifada）、仍在进行的以色列与巴解组织“和平进程”（包括《奥斯陆协议》和《怀伊协议》）和以色列对黎巴嫩战争的全新素材。对于任何想要了解当今中东及美国外交政策的人来说，本书都极具价值。
Hacker News 上怎么说
正在加载完整评论……
……给巴勒斯坦人，主要好处全让腐败的高层捞走了。在文章里我看到有人把阿拉法特和本-古里安相提并论。关于巴以冲突最好的书之一，是诺姆·乔姆斯基写的《命运的三角：以色列、美国与巴勒斯坦》（The Fateful Triangle: Israel, the USA and the Palestinians，爱德华·萨义德作序）。书里有一处他把巴勒斯坦人争取建国的斗争，与早期犹太复国主义者争取建国的斗争作了对比，并指出……
…for the Palestinians, benefiting mainly the corrupt leadership. In the article I see Arafat compared to Ben-Gurion. One of the best books on the Israel/Palestine conflict is Noam Chomsky's book "The Fateful Triangle: Israel, the USA and the Palestinians. (Intro by Edward Said)". At one point he compares the struggle of the Palestinians for their state to the struggle of the early Zionists for their state, and notes…
《命运的三角》（Fateful Triangle）是另一本引人入胜的好书。强烈推荐，尤其是在眼下这种时候。乔姆斯基写得太神了。
Fateful Triangle is another fascinating book. Highly recommended, especially in times like these. Chomsky is marvellous.
……镇压巴勒斯坦起义。好吧我住在南非比勒陀利亚，你住哪？斯代罗特？乔姆斯基是以色列研究领域非常顶尖的学者，堪称泰斗之一。极其值得一读，特别是《命运的三角》（The Fateful Triangle）。他曾经是个犹太复国主义者，还在那儿生活过。
…down a Palestianian revolt. Ok I live in Pretoria, South Africa, where do you stay? Sderot? Chomsky is a very fine scholar on Israel, one of the greatest. Very much worth reading, particularly "The Fateful Triangle" He was a Zionist, lived there.
……对这种叙事不够狂热。当机构和平民平台向那些企图压制言论自由、要求盲目效忠的极端分子妥协时，简直就是道德上的懦弱。顺便说一句：我推荐读读《命运的三角》（1999年版），极有先见之明。
…narrative enthusiastically enough. It's moral cowardice when institutions and platforms fold to the demands of extremists who don't want free expression or demand blind allegiance. PS: I recommend The Fateful Triangle (1999 edition) as prescient reading.
毫无疑问。《制造共识》（Manufacturing Consent）和《命运的三角》（The Fateful Triangle）* 应该被列为全美高中生的必读书目。* 今天的处境跟40年前大体上没什么两样。拉尔夫·纳德现在90岁了，也依然活跃在一线定期产出内容。https://www.youtube.com/@RalphNaderRadioHour
Without a doubt. Manufacturing Consent and The Fateful Triangle* should be assigned reading to US high school students. * Today is in more-or-less the same predicament as 40 years ago Ralph Nader is also still out there at 90 producing content regularly. https://www.youtube.com/@RalphNaderRadioHour
> 你们赶紧别刷那些傻逼 TikTok 了，多读几本书吧。我这儿就有一本比“傻逼 TikTok”早得多的书推荐给你。那就是诺姆·乔姆斯基写的《命运的三角》（The Fateful Triangle）。他刻画了80年代初以色列内部的思潮和政治派系，40多年过去了，这些东西基本没怎么变。特别是所谓的“鸽派”与……之间的对立。
> Y’all have gotta give up the TikTok bullshit and read some books. I have a book for you that predates the "TikTok bullshit." It's called "The Fateful Triangle" by Noam Chomsky. He portrays internal Isreali thought and political currents in the early '80s, which are more or less unchanged 40+ years later. In particular, the dichotomy between the "doves" of the…