心我论
The Mind's I
Douglas R. Hofstadter、Daniel C. Dennett · 初版 1981 年
36人推荐
57位读者提及
73次提及
为什么值得读
- 收录多位名家关于心智与灵魂的经典随笔
- 以生动有趣的方式探讨感受质等前沿哲学难题
- 相比GEB更为轻松易读
汇聚了 Jorge Luis Borges、Richard Dawkins、John Searle 和 Robert Nozick 等人的真知灼见，The Mind's I 从文学、artificial intelligence、心理学及其他学科的视角探讨了自我与意识的真谛。在涵盖虚构小说到关于思维机器、artificial intelligence 以及大脑本质的科学思辨等选篇中，Hofstadter 和 Dennett 通过 20 世纪部分最著名思想家的著述，呈现了关于自我与灵魂的诸多碰撞交锋的观点。
Hacker News 上怎么说
正在加载完整评论……
……很有说服力：即意识和清醒体验具有某种主观特质——做一只蝙蝠、做一个人，或者做任何东西，总该有某种独特的主观感受吧？霍夫施塔特（Hofstadter）和丹尼特（Dennett）合著的书《心我论》（The Mind's I，http://www.amazon.com/Minds-Fantasies-Reflections-Self-Soul/...）是了解这类话题的一本有趣入门书，作者们把 qualia（感受质）结结实实调侃了一番。
…persuasive: that there is a certain subjective quality to consciousness & conscious experience— it must feel like something to be a bat, or a person, or whatever? Hofstadter's and Dennett's book, The Mind's I (http://www.amazon.com/Minds-Fantasies-Reflections-Self-Soul/...) is an interesting introduction to this kind of stuff, the authors have a lot of fun @ qualia's expense.
如果你喜欢内格尔（Nagel），那就找《心我论》来看看吧，这是由道格拉斯·霍夫施塔特编选的文集，收录了内格尔的几篇随笔以及许多其他有价值的文章。如果你对犯罪与惩罚这类问题感兴趣，利奥·卡茨（Leo Katz）写过几本非常……
If you enjoyed Nagel, pick up 'The Mind's I', an anthology edited by Douglas Hofstadter, which includes a few of Nagel's essays and many others of value. If you're interested in things like crime and punishment, Leo Katz has written several highly…
……（基于硅片的电逻辑）。你提出的论点有很多迹象表明是在诉诸“机器中的幽灵”。对于任何有兴趣探索（自我）意识和心灵相关概念的人来说，道格拉斯·霍夫施塔特和丹尼尔·C·丹尼特的《心我论》都是一本好书。
…(electrical-based logic on silicon). The argument you pose have many signs of being an appeal to the ghost in the machine. For anyone interested in exploring ideas around (self)consciousness and the mind, The Mind's I by Douglas Hofstadter and Daniel C. Dennett is a good read.
它也改变了我的人生——顺便说一句，他写的其他好书也很棒：和丹尼尔·丹尼特合作的《心我论》，读起来比《集异璧》（Gödel, Escher, Bach）更轻松，同样也探讨了意识、涌现和认知。《元魔法主题》（Metamagical Themas）则是一部精彩的文章合集……
It changed my life as well -- along with other great books he wrote: "The Mind's I", a collaboration with Daniel Dennett, is a more light read than Gödel Escher Bach which also talks about consciousness, emergence and cognition. "Metamagical Themas" is a collection of fascinating articles…
彭罗斯的《皇帝新脑》。霍夫施塔特和丹尼特的《心我论：对自我与灵魂的幻想和反思》。明斯基的《心智社会》。马丁·加德纳。http://www.amazon.com/Martin-Gardner/e/B000AP8X8G/ref=sr_ntt... 高德纳（Donald Knuth）。http://www.amazon.com/Martin-Gardner/e/B000AP8X8G/ref=sr_ntt...……
The Emperor’s New Mind, Penrose. The Mind's I: Fantasies And Reflections On Self & Soul, Hofstadter and Dennet. The Society of Mind, Minsky. Martin Gardner. http://www.amazon.com/Martin-Gardner/e/B000AP8X8G/ref=sr_ntt... Donald Knuth. http://www.amazon.com/Martin-Gardner/e/B000AP8X8G/ref=sr_ntt...…
作者（道格拉斯·R·霍夫施塔特）的另外两本书（它们有点像构成了三部曲）也是绝佳的伴读读物：《心我论：对自我与灵魂的幻想和反思》和《我是个怪圈》……没错，它们读起来都非常硬核。从“计算机科学”的角度来看，如果你处于……绝对值得一读。
The author's (Douglas R. Hofstadter) other two books (which kinda form a trilogy) are also great companions: The Mind's I: Fantasies And Reflections On Self & Soul I Am a Strange Loop ...and yes, they are all very challenging reads. On the "computer science" perspective, they are definitely worth reading if you are at…