免费停车的昂贵代价
The High Cost of Free Parking
Donald C. Shoup · 初版 2005 年
45人推荐
61位读者提及
100次提及
为什么值得读
- 讲透免费停车实际上由时间而非金钱定价
- 收录翔实深入的计量经济学研究
- 充满洞见且适合随手翻阅研读
The High Cost of Free Parking 是 UCLA 教授 Donald Shoup 撰写的一部城市规划著作，探讨了免费停车对社会造成的代价。全书对停车规划与管制展开批判，并建议应按照公允市场价值来建设和分配停车位。书中还融入了 Shoup 的 Georgist 哲学理念。
Hacker News 上怎么说
正在加载完整评论……
如果你对这个话题感兴趣，Donald Shoup 的《免费停车的高昂代价》（The High Cost of Free Parking）和 Edward Glaeser 的《城市的胜利》（The Triumph of the City）都很值得一读。前者解释了“免费”停车为什么其实并不免费，以及它是如何扭曲诸多行为的；而后者则是关于城市……
If you're interested in this topic, Donald Shoup's The High Cost of Free Parking and Edward Glaeser's The Triumph of the City are both worth reading. The former explains how "free" parking isn't really free and how it distorts a lot of behavior, and the latter is about what cities…
……想要利用优质高效的都市主义来改善环境，唯一的办法就是多建，而且任何需求或价格上涨都做不到这点，因为正如我所说，这是违法的。如果你想了解更多，我推荐 Shoup 博士的《免费停车的高昂代价》和 Kunstler 的《无处之地》（The Geography of Nowhere）。
…The only way to use quality and efficient urbanism to improve the environment is to build more of it and no demand or price increase will do that because, as I mentioned, it's illegal. I recommend "The High Cost of Free Parking" by Dr. Shoup, and "The Geography of Nowhere" by Kunstler if you want to understand more.
……必须挖一个深坑来确保建筑地基稳固——打到基岩层，特别是在地震带。停车场建在地下还是地上倒是次要的。话虽如此——在停车和停车场这个问题上，《免费停车的高昂代价》（1）和《适宜步行的城市》（2）都是极佳的读物。第二本读起来更轻松。(1) http://www.amazon.com/High-Cost-Parking-Updated-Edition/dp/1... (2)……
…to dig a deep hole to ensure the foundations of the building are secure - get into the bedrock, especially in earthquake zones. Whether the car parks are below or above ground is moot. That said - The High Cost of Free Parking (1) and The Walkable City (2) are both excellent reads on the matter of parking and car parks. The second is the more readable. (1) http://www.amazon.com/High-Cost-Parking-Updated-Edition/dp/1... (2)…
……规划。我学过城市规划和城市形态学。在帮助我理解美国城市及其运作逻辑方面，没有什么比 Shoup 博士 90 年代的研究（收录在《免费停车的高昂代价》中）更有用了。其中有些是硬核又专业的计量经济学研究，但很多内容极具创意和洞察力。它不是单线叙事，但很适合闲暇时翻到哪读到哪，如果你……
…planning. I have studied urban planning and urban form. Nothing helped me to understand American cities and why they work the way they do more than Dr. Shoup's work in the 1990s that is collected in The High Cost Of Free Parking. Some of it is gritty and technical econometric research, but a lot of it is creative and insightful. It's not a single narrative, but a fun book to dip into in various places from time to time if you…
停车并不是被低估了。人们只是用时间而不是金钱在买单。更准确地说是定价机制无效率。关于这一点，Shoup 的《免费停车的高昂代价》堪称圣经：http://www.amazon.com/High-Cost-Parking-Updated-Edition/dp/1...
Parking isn't undervalued. People just pay in time, not money. Better to say that it's inefficiently priced. Shoup's "The High Cost of Free Parking" is the bible on that: http://www.amazon.com/High-Cost-Parking-Updated-Edition/dp/1...
……穷人。论点是：* 强制配建车位是由城市规划者强加的 * 强制配建车位推高了所有人的成本 * 穷人承受成本上涨的能力更弱。Shoup 的《免费停车的高昂代价》讲得非常详尽，并且是从规划理论的角度切入的。很棒的一本书，强烈推荐。
…poor people. The argument is: * mandatory parking is imposed by urban planners * mandatory parking raises costs for all people * poor people are less able to absorb the increased costs Shoup's The High Cost of Free Parking goes into a lot of detail and approaches it from the point of view of planning theory. It's a good read, I recommend it.