资本论

Hacker News 上怎么说

• hef19898 · 2022 年

  我知道你为什么会被 downvote。人们往往忘了，马克思其实是一位相当不错且受人尊敬的经济学家。当他写出《Das Kapital》时，那是对工业革命初期野蛮生长的资本主义的一种解读方式。可惜他被列宁或托洛茨基这样的人给借用了。倒不是针对这两人本身或他们的所作所为，而更多是…

  I know why you get downvoted. People tend to forget, so, that Marx actually was a pretty good, and respected, economist. And when he came up with "Das Kapital" it was one way of interpreting the nascent, unlimited capitalism of the industrial revolution. It's a pitty he was co-opted by people like Lenin or Trotzky. Less for what these two were or did, but more…

• bmmayer1 · 2019 年

  经济学：-《国富论》，亚当·斯密 -《Das Kapital》，卡尔·马克思 -《看得见的与看不见的》，弗雷德里克·巴斯夏 哲学 / 政治：-《理想国》，柏拉图 -《政府论下篇》，约翰·洛克 -《法律》，弗雷德里克·巴斯夏…

  Economics: - The Wealth of Nations, Adam Smith - Das Kapital, Karl Marx - That Which Is Seen, and That Which Is Not Seen, Frederic Bastiat Philosophy / Politics: - The Republic, Plato - Second Treatise on Government, John Locke - The Law, Frederic Bastiat…

• cutler · 2022 年

  大学学经济学时，真正让我大开眼界的是马克思在《Das Kapital》里阐述的剩余价值理论。读了他的劳动价值论之后，我才意识到自己以前从利普西的《实证经济学》里被填鸭灌输的那些教科书经济学…

  Marx's theory of surplus value, as expounded in Das Kapital, was what really opened my eyes when studying Economics at university. After reading about his labour theory of value I realised all the textbook economics I'd been spoon-fed from Lipsey's "Positive Economics"…

• nimbius · 2026 年

  …完全当作民事纠纷处理，同时又通过私有财产至上来确保盗窃商家的行为在任何情况下都是刑事案件。想要深入了解的话，我推荐读读马克思的《Das Kapital》，虽然比较偏学术。恩格斯的《雇佣劳动》也是一本好书，能帮人理解为什么住房一直这么让人负担不起，也有助于理解为什么其他任何商品或服务都会慢慢变得如此…

  …maintains as exclusively as civil matters while ensuring theft itself from a merchant in turn is always a criminal matter through the primacy of private property. to learn more i recommend reading Marx's "Das Kapital," albeit its rather academic. Engels "wage labor" is also a good read to understand why housing is so persistently unaffortable but helps to understand why any other good or service slowly becomes so…

• eli_gottlieb · 2012 年

  …任何人都可以呼吸空气或上公立学校，但总得有人保持空气清洁并提供公立学校。除此以外，我推荐读读亨利·乔治的《进步与贫困》，以及卡尔·马克思的《Das Kapital》。但说到底，在资本与劳动的伟大斗争中，或者说资产与劳动力的博弈中，资本本质上具有很强的排他性，而劳动（在缺乏工会组织的情况下…

  …Anyone can breathe the air or attend public schools, but someone has to keep the air clean and provide public schools. Beyond this, I recommend reading Henry George's Progress and Poverty, as well as Das Kapital by Karl Marx. But what it comes to is that in the great struggle between Capital and Labor, or Property and Energy, capital is by nature very excludable, while Labor (lacking organization into a guild…

• cubano · 2015 年

  …精准地描述了那种促使“工人们”想要脱离资本主义生产方式、去探索类似 libcom.org 这种理念的焦虑感。对此感兴趣的人真应该读读《Das Kapital》……马克思是真正的思想巨擘，功底既深厚又广博。在我看来，理论上听着都很美好，但落地 implementation 起来似乎总是翻车，就像一个烂尾的软件项目一样，…

  …accurately describes the angst that motivates the "workers" to want to move away from the Capitalist system of production and explore ideas such as libcom.org. For those with an interest, you should read Das Kapital...Marx was a true intellectual powerhouse and his chops were both deep and wide. IMO, It all sounds very good in theory, but always seems to always fail during implementation, like a bad software project,…

正在加载完整评论……