大教堂与市集
The Cathedral and the Bazaar
Eric S. Raymond · 初版 1997 年
72人推荐
270位读者提及
308次提及
为什么值得读
- 兼具技术规范、法律与历史视角的独到剖析
- 论述敏锐准确且具有通俗易懂的雄辩文风
- 篇幅短小精炼，阅读体验流畅而富有洞见
Open source 在 Internet 时代提供了竞争优势。根据8月份的 Forrester Report，在受访的 Global 2,500 强企业 IT 经理中，有56%已在基础设施中使用了某种类型的 open source 软件，另有6%将在未来两年内安装引入。从 Sun Microsystems 到 IBM 再到 Intel，高科技行业中许多最具影响力的巨头都在拥抱并研究这种革命性的协同软件开发模式。The Cathedral & the Bazaar 是所有关心计算机产业未来的人的必读之作
Hacker News 上怎么说
正在加载完整评论……
……Tracy Kidder 的书。这是我知道的写硬件设计最牛逼的故事。David Kushner 的《DOOM 启世录》（Masters of Doom），写早期游戏开发黄金时代最好的书，尤其是关于 Carmack 和 Romero 的故事。Eric Raymond 的任何作品，尤其是《大教堂与集市》（The Cathedral and the Bazaar）。
…Tracy Kidder. The best tale of hardware design I know. “Masters of Doom” by David Kushner. The best book on the early days of gaming, esp. about Carmack and Romero. Anything by Eric Raymond, esp. “The Cathedral and the Bazaar”.
……在把某种态度强加到别人的话里之前，先反思一下自己的偏见。> 这完全是错的。不，错的是你。无论从技术/法律角度还是历史角度来看，你都错了。推荐阅读：《大教堂与集市》。
…your own biases before reading an attitude into someone else's message. > This is completely wrong. Nope, you are. Both in the technical/legal sense and the historical sense. Recommended reading: The Cathedral and the Bazaar.
……Abelson 和 Sussman 著《计算机程序的构造和解释》（SICP），Graham 著《On Lisp》，Ullman 和 Widom 著《数据库系统基础教程》，Kernighan 和 Ritchie 著《C程序设计语言》（K&R），Raymond 著《大教堂与集市》
…Structure & Interpretation of Computer Programs, by Abelson and Sussman On Lisp, by Graham A First Course in Database Systems, by Ullman and Widom The C Programming Language, by Kernighan and Ritchie The Cathedral and the Bazaar, by Raymond
嗯，这有一份我很喜欢的书单： Frenck 著《C 和 C++ 中的内存编程概念》 McKusick / Neville-Neil 著《FreeBSD 操作系统的设计与实现》 Cameron 等著《学习 GNU Emacs》 Seibel 著《Practical Common Lisp》 K&R 著《C程序设计语言》 Stroustrup 著《C++程序设计语言》 Leviten 著《算法设计与分析》 汇编语言
Hmmm, here's a list of books I really like: Memory as a Programming Concept in C and C++ by Frenck The Design and Implementation of the FreeBSD Operating System by McKusick/Neville-Neil Learning GNU Emacs by Cameron, et al. Practical Common Lisp by Seibel The C Programming Language by K&R The C++ Programming Language Stroustrup The Design and Analysis of Algorithms by Leviten Assembly Lang
完全同意没有演讲配合的 slides 没多大价值。《大教堂与集市》最初是 Eric Raymond 写的一篇文章，而不是一本书。不管他还有别的什么毛病，他在那篇文章里说对了很多东西，而且表达得很有说服力、非常浅显易懂。读起来很棒……
Agree completely that slides without the presentation aren't worth much. The Cathedral and the Bazaar was originally an essay by Eric Raymond, not a book. Whatever other faults he may have, he got a lot of things right in that article, and in an eloquent, very comprehensible way. It was a great read…
……而且以高品质闻名；而那个烂烂的替代品 MySQL，在实际中表现出的完全就是你描述的那种特质，在它大部分历史里都是由单一公司掌控的项目。）去重读一下《大教堂与集市》（http://www.catb.org/~esr/writings/cathedral-bazaar/），注意它在实践中几乎被证明完全正确。（顺便说一句，敏捷开发（agile）做得最好的时候，本质上就是试图把这种成功的……移植过来）
…and is famous for quality; the crappy alternative, MySQL, which is in practice a product showing the sort of qualities you describe, was a one-company project for most of its history.) Go reread The Cathedral and the Bazaar http://www.catb.org/~esr/writings/cathedral-bazaar/ and note that it's been proven pretty much entirely correct in practice. (By the way, "agile" at its best is literally an attempt to port successful…