…proper ebook - let me know if you want a copy; I can't locate it at this moment... And, in my opinion, the finest science fiction short story ever written (apologies to Asimov's Nightfall and Godwin's The Cold Equations): Nine Minutes, by Genrikh Altov https://www.altshuller.ru/world/eng/science-fiction4.asp
Not a "book", but a short story: The Cold Equations by Tom Godwin. I read that story when I was pretty young, and it's shaped my opinion on cold, uncaring bureaucracies in a way that I'm not sure anything else could.
…barring some miracle like practical, cheap fusion power appearing in the next decade. If I were to make a comparison to a work of fiction, it wouldn't be to Mad Max or The Day After Tomorrow; but to The Cold Equations, by Tom Godwin.
……对《深渊上的火》(A Fire Upon the Deep)也是这种感觉。我把它列为我读过的最软的科幻之一。故事是不错,但重度陷入了“科学即魔法”的套路里。相比之下,比如《冷酷的方程式》(The Cold Equations),我记得里面除了超光速(FTL),其他全是烂大街的标准物理学,可即便如此还是从工程角度被吐槽不切实际。但你没法用这种标准去喷《深渊上的火》……
…that way about A Fire Upon the Deep. I rank it as some of the softest science fiction I have ever read. It’s a decent story, but falls heavily into the science as magic trap. Contrast it with say The Cold Equations which as I recall has FTL and everything else is bog standard physics and yet it was still criticized as unrealistic from an engendering standpoint. You can’t make that kind of criticism of A Fire Upon…
…disposal? Ender spends the rest of the series struggling with that very question. Ultimately, he comes to realize that, yes, he would do it all over again if he had to. Thank you for the recommendation on "Cold Equations". Haven't read it, will happily take a look. Hopefully my local library has a copy.
/The Cold Equations/ is lambasted for being a story that's set up to make a point in ways that completely contradict any sort of good engineering practice. Given the situation as described, the simplest ordinary precautions…
……正规电子书——要是你想要一份跟我说一声;我现在手头一时找不着……而且在我看来,这是有史以来最牛的科幻短篇(阿西莫夫的《夜幕低垂》和戈德温的《冷酷的方程式》先道个歉哈):根里奇·阿尔托夫的《九分钟》https://www.altshuller.ru/world/eng/science-fiction4.asp
…proper ebook - let me know if you want a copy; I can't locate it at this moment... And, in my opinion, the finest science fiction short story ever written (apologies to Asimov's Nightfall and Godwin's The Cold Equations): Nine Minutes, by Genrikh Altov https://www.altshuller.ru/world/eng/science-fiction4.asp
算不上“一本书”,而是一篇短篇小说:汤姆·戈德温的《冷酷的方程式》(The Cold Equations)。我很小的时候读的,它对我关于冷血无情的官僚体系的看法塑造极深,换成别的作品可能都做不到这点。
Not a "book", but a short story: The Cold Equations by Tom Godwin. I read that story when I was pretty young, and it's shaped my opinion on cold, uncaring bureaucracies in a way that I'm not sure anything else could.
……除非未来十年出现奇迹,比如廉价实用的聚变能源问世。如果非要用一部虚构作品来打比方,我不会选《疯狂的麦克斯》或《后天》,而是会选汤姆·戈德温的《冷酷的方程式》(The Cold Equations)。
…barring some miracle like practical, cheap fusion power appearing in the next decade. If I were to make a comparison to a work of fiction, it wouldn't be to Mad Max or The Day After Tomorrow; but to The Cold Equations, by Tom Godwin.
……对《深渊上的火》(A Fire Upon the Deep)也是这种感觉。我把它列为我读过的最软的科幻之一。故事是不错,但重度陷入了“科学即魔法”的套路里。相比之下,比如《冷酷的方程式》(The Cold Equations),我记得里面除了超光速(FTL),其他全是烂大街的标准物理学,可即便如此还是从工程角度被吐槽不切实际。但你没法用这种标准去喷《深渊上的火》……
…that way about A Fire Upon the Deep. I rank it as some of the softest science fiction I have ever read. It’s a decent story, but falls heavily into the science as magic trap. Contrast it with say The Cold Equations which as I recall has FTL and everything else is bog standard physics and yet it was still criticized as unrealistic from an engendering standpoint. You can’t make that kind of criticism of A Fire Upon…
……处置?安德在系列剩下的故事里一直在为这同一个问题痛苦挣扎。最终他意识到,没错,如果有必要,他还会再做一次。谢谢推荐《冷酷的方程式》(Cold Equations)。我还没读过,会很乐意去瞅一眼。希望我们当地的图书馆有藏书。
…disposal? Ender spends the rest of the series struggling with that very question. Ultimately, he comes to realize that, yes, he would do it all over again if he had to. Thank you for the recommendation on "Cold Equations". Haven't read it, will happily take a look. Hopefully my local library has a copy.
《冷酷的方程式》(The Cold Equations)被喷是因为它为了说明一个道理,强行安排的剧情完全违背了任何合理的工程实践。按照文中所描述的情况,最起码的常规防范措施……
/The Cold Equations/ is lambasted for being a story that's set up to make a point in ways that completely contradict any sort of good engineering practice. Given the situation as described, the simplest ordinary precautions…