透明社会
The transparent society
David Brin · 初版 1998 年
30人推荐
61位读者提及
82次提及
为什么值得读
- 指出绝对隐私已不可行，唯有互相监督可行
- 提倡通过彻底的公开与透明来解决监视问题
- 90年代写就却准确预见了当前的监控现实
The Transparent Society 呼吁实现一种“对等透明”。如果警用监控探头注视着我们，难道我们不该能接入警察局的画面吗？如果征信机构售卖我们的数据，难道我们不该知道买家是谁吗？鉴于人类起源于紧密联系的原始村落，匿名其实只是一种历史常态之外的特例，与其执念于匿名的幻觉，不如把精力放在捍卫最重要的隐私形式与维护相互问责上。Brin 警告称，对我们的自由最大的威胁，并不是监控技术被太多人使用，而是它掌握在极少数人手中。
Hacker News 上怎么说
正在加载完整评论……
……“仅供执法机构和部分选定的安全专家作为调查工具使用。”我非常赞同 David Brin 的观点，这完全是南辕北辙。在《The Transparent Society》中他指出，隐私已经不再是一种可选项；我们的抉择只在于：要么接受一个警察监视全员的社会，要么接受一个所有人相互监视的社会。他说只有后者才能与自由共存。……
…"available only for law enforcement agencies and select security professionals to use as an investigative tool." I'm fairly convinced by David Brin's argument that this is exactly the wrong approach. In The Transparent Society he argues that privacy is no longer an option; our choice is between a society where the police surveil us all, and one where we all surveil each other. He says only the latter is compatible with freedom.…
David Brin 的《The Transparent Society》探讨过这个。http://www.amazon.com/dp/B004P5O37W/?tag=dedasys-20 http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Transparent_Society 简而言之，核心思想是允许广泛的监控注视，因为这有助于减少……
David Brin's "The Transparent Society" talks about this. http://www.amazon.com/dp/B004P5O37W/?tag=dedasys-20 http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Transparent_Society In short, the idea is to allow lots of watching, because it'll help reduce…
关于隐私的仗早就打输了。David Brin 提出的方案是唯一的后路。《THE TRANSPARENT SOCIETY》（透明社会）。
The battle for privacy is already lost. David Brin's approach is what is remaining. THE TRANSPARENT SOCIETY.
……监控画面出现大段空白等等。枪声检测和定位相当容易，但这已经超出了摄像头系统的范畴。任何对这个话题感兴趣的人都必须读一本书：《The Transparent Society》http://www.amazon.com/Transparent-Society-Technology-Between...。解决办法不是倒退。系统已经摆在这儿了。真正的出路在于公开透明。政府几乎所有的 CCTV 监控画面都应该向公众开放……
…large gaps in footage, etc.. Gunshot detection and localization is pretty easy, but goes beyond the camera systems. There is a book everyone interested in the topic needs to read on the subject: The Transparent Society http://www.amazon.com/Transparent-Society-Technology-Between... The solution is not regressing. The systems are here. The solution is openness. Almost all government CCTV feeds should be open to public…
说到科幻感，我真希望大家早在 1998 年就读过 David Brin 的《The Transparent Society》。这书太有前瞻性了。https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Transparent_Society
Speaking of feeling like science fiction, I wish everyone had read David Brin's The Transparent Society in 1998. Such a prescient book. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Transparent_Society
……世界并放弃现代科技带来的便利。我觉得在某种程度上，我们只能接受隐私的流失，以此换取社区内部更好的和谐。我会向任何对此感兴趣的人推荐 David Brin 的《The Transparent Society》：https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Transparent_Society
…the world and abandoning the convenience of modern technology. I feel like at some point we just have to accept the loss of privacy to gain better harmony within our communities. I would recommend The Transparent Society by David Brin to anyone interested in this matter: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Transparent_Society