破碎之剑
Shattered sword
Jonathan Parshall · 初版 2005 年
11人推荐
14位读者提及
17次提及
为什么值得读
- 大量深挖日本档案文献，纠正诸多既成传言
- 从中方/日方视角详尽剖析日本海军组织文化
- 兼具扎实考据与极其详尽的战役复盘
“中途岛战役扭转了太平洋战争的局势。毫无疑问，它是历史上最著名的战役之一。如今，自 Gordon W. Prange 的《Miracle at Midway》出版以来，首次出现了一部打破既有神话、对这场伟大海战的颠覆性全新解读。”“Jonathan Parshall 和 Anthony Tully 广泛利用了此前未被开发的日本一手史料（包括西方学者从未引用过的日本帝国海军作战记录），重构了1942年6月4日关键事件的真实发生序列，重新审视了美日指挥官的决策，并将……
Hacker News 上怎么说
正在加载完整评论……
是的，确实如此。参考乔纳森·帕歇尔（Jonathan Parshall）和安东尼·塔利（Anthony Tully）写的《Shattered Sword》。（这个故事里经常出现的一个细节是裁判官把袭击中被“击沉”的两艘日本航母给“复活”了——那部分…
Yes, it did. See Shattered Sword by Jonathan Parshall and Anthony Tully. (One additional feature often seen in the story is the part where the umpire "resurrects" the two Japanese carriers which were "sunk" in the attack---that part…
你应该读读帕歇尔和塔利的《Shattered Sword》。这是我读过关于中途岛最详尽的记录之一，它深入挖掘日本档案资料的程度，是绝大多数中途岛战史…
You should read Shattered Sword, by Parshall and Tully. It is one of the most comprehensive accounts of Midway I've ever read, and dives deeply into Japanese archival sources in a way that the vast majority of histories of Midway do…
…团体（https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Round_Table_movement），据称出版过一份通讯。话虽如此，非专业历史学家也是能写出优秀历史作品的（比如看看乔纳森·帕歇尔和安东尼·塔利写的《Shattered Sword: The Untold Story of the Battle of Midway》）。我不会仅凭作者资质就全盘否定它。但从另一个、又一个角度来看，关于它的一切都在发出…
…group (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Round_Table_movement), which apparently published a newsletter. That being said, non-professional-historians are capable of producing good history (for example, see Shattered Sword: The Untold Story of the Battle of Midway, by Jonathan Parshall and Anthony Tully. I wouldn't discount it for the authors' qualifications alone. On the other, other hand, everything about it is setting…
《Shattered Sword》，安东尼·P·塔利和乔纳森·帕歇尔著。主要从日方视角对中途岛战役进行了深度剖析，涵盖了从日本帝国海军（IJN）的组织文化到其…
Shattered Sword, by Anthony P. Tully and Jonathan Parshall. An in-depth analysis of the battle of Midway, primarily from the Japanese perspective, covering everything from the organizational culture of the IJN and its…
推荐这两本，按这个顺序读：沃尔特·洛德（Walter Lord）的《Incredible Victory》[1]。讲中途岛的故事，相当客观平衡。乔纳森·帕歇尔和安东尼·塔利的《Shattered Sword》[2]。也是关于中途岛的，但对日方史料的研究更深入。更新了关于中途岛被视为“事实”的一些认知。神书一本。编辑…
These 2, in this order: Incredible Victory by Walter Lord[1]. The story of Midway, fairly balanced. Shattered Sword by Jonathan Parshall and Anthony Tully[2]. also about Midway, but more research on Japanese sources. Has updated information about some things that are taken as "truth" about Midway. Amazing book. EDITED…
…用货船船体改造的。警告，这可能会激发你去深入了解更多二战历史。还有两本书算是一套搭配：沃尔特·洛德的《Incredible Victory: The Battle of Midway》以及乔纳森·帕歇尔和安东尼·塔利的《Shattered Sword: The Untold Story of the Battle of Midway》。先读《Incredible Victory》，了解那些好运与厄运如何促成了太平洋战场上一场亟需的胜利。然后…
…made from cargo ship hulls. Warning, may inspire you to learn a whole bunch more about world war 2. And 2 books that sort of go together: Incredible Victory: The Battle of Midway by Walter Lord, and Shattered Sword: The Untold Story of the Battle of Midway by Jonathan Parshall and Anthony Tully. Read Incredible Victory first, learn about the luck, good and bad, that led to a much-needed victory in the Pacific. Then…