……理清相关文献的脉络，因为归根结底并不存在人人都认可的单一框架，甚至连一套通用框架都没有。专门针对这个问题，另一本不错的入门书是 Boehm 的《Hierarchy in the Forest》。它虽然也不全面，但算得上该领域的一部里程碑式著作。[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/%C7%83Kung_people#Social_struc...
…sense of the literature because there ultimately isn't a single framework or even a single set of frameworks that everyone uses. Another good introduction to this question more specifically is Boehm's "Hierarchy in the forest". It's not comprehensive either, but it's sort of a landmark work on the topic. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/%C7%83Kung_people#Social_struc...
……在我看来，这纯粹就是在把 19 世纪对人类原生状态“险恶、残酷、短暂”的想象加以延伸罢了。=) 几本有趣的读物：* The Harmless People（经典作）* Hierarchy in the Forest * Hunter-Gatherers of the Congo Basin * The Foraging Spectrum
…all seems to me like a mere extrapolation of the 19th century imagination of the default human condition as being "nasty, brutish, short." =) Some interesting texts: * The Harmless People (a classic) * Hierarchy in the Forest * Hunter-Gatherers of the Congo Basin * The Foraging Spectrum
我也读过这篇博文里提到的民族志《Never in Anger》，我是通过读 Christopher Boehm 写的关于平等主义社会的综述书《Hierarchy in the Forest》发现它的。作者似乎认为具有东亚表型特征的人群所独有的许多性格特质，实际上在高度平等的社会中相当普遍。……
I too have read Never in Anger, the ethnography mentioned in this blog post, and the way I found it was by reading a survey of egalitarian societies called Hierarchy in the Forest, by Christopher Boehm. Many of the personality traits that the author seems to think are special about people who share the East Asian phenotype are actually common amongst fiercely egalitarian societies.…
……理清相关文献的脉络，因为归根结底并不存在人人都认可的单一框架，甚至连一套通用框架都没有。专门针对这个问题，另一本不错的入门书是 Boehm 的《Hierarchy in the Forest》。它虽然也不全面，但算得上该领域的一部里程碑式著作。[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/%C7%83Kung_people#Social_struc...
…sense of the literature because there ultimately isn't a single framework or even a single set of frameworks that everyone uses. Another good introduction to this question more specifically is Boehm's "Hierarchy in the forest". It's not comprehensive either, but it's sort of a landmark work on the topic. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/%C7%83Kung_people#Social_struc...
……在我看来，这纯粹就是在把 19 世纪对人类原生状态“险恶、残酷、短暂”的想象加以延伸罢了。=) 几本有趣的读物：* The Harmless People（经典作）* Hierarchy in the Forest * Hunter-Gatherers of the Congo Basin * The Foraging Spectrum
…all seems to me like a mere extrapolation of the 19th century imagination of the default human condition as being "nasty, brutish, short." =) Some interesting texts: * The Harmless People (a classic) * Hierarchy in the Forest * Hunter-Gatherers of the Congo Basin * The Foraging Spectrum
我也读过这篇博文里提到的民族志《Never in Anger》，我是通过读 Christopher Boehm 写的关于平等主义社会的综述书《Hierarchy in the Forest》发现它的。作者似乎认为具有东亚表型特征的人群所独有的许多性格特质，实际上在高度平等的社会中相当普遍。……
I too have read Never in Anger, the ethnography mentioned in this blog post, and the way I found it was by reading a survey of egalitarian societies called Hierarchy in the Forest, by Christopher Boehm. Many of the personality traits that the author seems to think are special about people who share the East Asian phenotype are actually common amongst fiercely egalitarian societies.…