反对惩罚的论证
The Case Against Punishment
Deirdre Golash · 初版 2005 年
2人推荐
2位读者提及
2次提及
“本书结合实证依据与哲学文献，论证了惩罚刑事犯罪者所造成的伤害在道德层面上是站不住脚的。Deirdre Golash 指出，刑罚给犯罪者带来了有意与无意的双重伤害；她认为，通过解决与高犯罪率相关的社会问题（如收入不均和社区社会失序），完全可以减少犯罪。惩罚或许能降低犯罪率，但在此过程中也对罪犯造成了同等程度的伤害。相反，Golash 认为，我们应该通过审判、定罪……来应对犯罪行为。
Hacker News 上怎么说
正在加载完整评论……
……不人道。在这里，我指的是普通大众的认知——我很好奇究竟有多少比例的美国人会认同“监狱系统是不道德的”。感谢你给的链接！推荐一本相关的书：《反驳惩罚》（The Case Against Punishment）http://www.amazon.com/The-Case-Against-Punishment-Retributio...
…inhumane. In this case, I was referring to the general public perception- I wonder what percentage of Americans would agree with "the prison system is unethical". Thanks for your link! A related book: "The Case Against Punishment" http://www.amazon.com/The-Case-Against-Punishment-Retributio...
这本极好的书探讨了很多你提到的问题——D. Golash 的《反驳惩罚》（The Case against Punishment）https://books.google.com/books/about/The_Case_Against_Punish...
This excellent book discusses a lot of what you touch on—D. Golash: The Case against Punishment https://books.google.com/books/about/The_Case_Against_Punish...