无伴奏奏鸣曲
Unaccompanied sonata
Orson Scott Card · 初版 1992 年
5人推荐
7位读者提及
8次提及
这是一篇最初收录于《Maps in a Mirror》的短篇小说。《Maps in a Mirror: The Short Fiction of Orson Scott Card》（Tor，1990 年 10 月）；《Unaccompanied Sonata and Other Stories》（科幻短篇集，Dial，1980 年，美国已绝版，后收录于《Maps in a Mirror》）。
Hacker News 上怎么说
正在加载完整评论……
Orson Scott Card 写过一篇以这个为主题的短篇小说，叫《无伴奏奏鸣曲》（Unaccompanied Sonata）。你可以在这里读到：https://b-ok.cc/book/4395497/b2fb2e
There is a short story by Orson Scott Card which has that theme called 'Unaccompanied Sonata'. You can read it here: https://b-ok.cc/book/4395497/b2fb2e
> 同样地，你无法命令一个创作者不要去创作。不管你喜不喜欢，他们都会去搞创作。如果想看关于这个观点更黑暗的解读，可以看看奥森·斯科特·卡德的《无伴奏奏鸣曲》
> Equally you cannot tell a creator not to create. They will, whether you like it or not. for a much darker take on this, check out orson scott card's "unaccompanied sonata"
《无伴奏奏鸣曲》是 Orson Scott Card 在 1979 年写的一篇短篇小说，把这个概念推向了极致；自从我八十年代读过之后，它就一直萦绕在我心头挥之不去。
Unaccompanied Sonata is a 1979 short story by Orson Scott Card that takes this to an extreme, and has haunted me since I read it in the eighties.
我推荐 Orson Scott Card 那篇发人深省的短篇小说《无伴奏奏鸣曲》。这是一个关于音乐技艺的故事，但同时也是讲故事技巧的绝佳范例。音乐和写作都会发生变化。这两者的市场毫无疑问都已经变了。似乎音乐……
I recommend the thought-provoking short story, "Unaccompanied Sonata" by Orson Scott Card. It's a story about music craft but it's also a brilliant example of story-telling. Music and writing will change. The markets for both certainly have changed. It seems that music…
……关于 OSC 最令人抓狂的一点是，他小说中隐含的哲学观，和他自己在政治文章里鼓吹的那套完全背道而驰。比如，我最喜欢的短篇之一就是 OSC 的《无伴奏奏鸣曲》。这个故事传达的信息是：强迫某人否定自己真正的本质，是极其残忍且根本不可能做到的。http://janlowman.escuelacampoalegre.wikispaces.net/file/view... 但现实中，……
…thing that is most infuriating about OSC is that his stories imply a philosophy completely opposite those he espouses in his political writings. For example, one of my favorite short stories is OSC's Unaccompanied Sonata. The story has a message about the cruelty and ultimate impossibility of making someone deny their core self. http://janlowman.escuelacampoalegre.wikispaces.net/file/view... But then in real life,…
……但总有一个节点，你必须真正动笔去写。说真的，有些人甚至会说广泛涉猎只会污染你的思绪，导致你自己的独创减少、反刍拼凑增多。（你可能会体会出几分 Orson Scott Card《无伴奏奏鸣曲》的味道）。所以我打算暂时把阅读放一边，沉下心去写作。不过等我回来的时候，我很想看看大家在阅读之间是如何分配时间的……
…but there comes a point when you have to do the writing. Indeed, some might say that reading widely simply pollutes your thoughts, so you add less and regurgitate more. (You might catch a sense of "Unaccompanied Sonata" by Orson Scott Card). So I'm setting aside my reading for a while and getting down to writing. When I come back, though, I'd love to see people's experiences in how they split their time between reading…