…patronising or racist to say that India needs to follow a different model of development than the western one. In fact, that idea was central to the Gandhian independence struggle - just read the great man's Hind Swaraj! There are many reasons for doing so. For one, we don't have colonies we can screw over - i.e., India's India - while enriching ourselves. Assuming we would want to do that at all. We also don't have…
This piece reminded me, of all things, of Gandhi's essay "Hind Swaraj." He was pretty anti-technological-driven change. He was anti: - Machinery replacing handicraft (skill disappeared and poverty followed) - Labor-saving machines replacing human workers (workers became…
……我理解我刚才提到的那些东西在 1908 年甘地写那篇随笔时还不存在，但谁知道现代 AI 又会带来什么我们现在无法想象的进步呢？https://www.mkgandhi.org/ebks/hind_swaraj.pdf 这是甘地那本书的 PDF。在“解释说明”（A Word of Explanation）一节中，你会发现甘地竟然表示乐见医院和铁路自然消亡。
…understand the things I mentioned just now weren’t around in 1908 when Gandhi wrote that essay but who knows what advancements modern AI could bring that we can’t imagine now? https://www.mkgandhi.org/ebks/hind_swaraj.pdf This is a PDF of that Gandhi book. Under the “A Word of Explanation” you find Gandhi saying he would welcome the natural destruction of hospitals and railways.
I disagree his arguments are timeless. https://www.mkgandhi.org/ebks/hind_swaraj.pdf I posted more in another comment on this thread but here’s a PDF of his book. Gandhi says in the “A Word of Explanation” section that he would welcome the natural destruction of hospitals. How is…
…starved if I am excluded from the Editorship of the Daily Mail," or words to that effect."[0] On reading this, Gandhi "immediately translated it into Gujarati, and on the basis of it he wrote his book Hind Swaraj, his own first formulation of a specifically "Indian" solution to his country’s problems. Thus you might argue, not quite absurdly, that India owed its independence, or at least the manner in which it…
……说印度需要走一条不同于西方的自身发展道路，既非居高临下，也谈不上种族主义。事实上，这种思想正是甘地独立斗争的核心——去读读这位伟人的《印度自治》（Hind Swaraj）就明白了！这么做有太多理由。首先，我们没有可以在自肥的同时去肆意盘剥的殖民地——也就是“印度的印度”。退一步讲，就算有我们也不见得想这么干。其次我们也没有……
…patronising or racist to say that India needs to follow a different model of development than the western one. In fact, that idea was central to the Gandhian independence struggle - just read the great man's Hind Swaraj! There are many reasons for doing so. For one, we don't have colonies we can screw over - i.e., India's India - while enriching ourselves. Assuming we would want to do that at all. We also don't have…
写得挺用心。不过我怀疑现实中的甘地未必像这个角色。在《印度自治》里，甘地甚至主张取缔铁路和疫苗……
Good effort. I doubt if real life Gandhi would be like this character though. In Hind Swaraj, Gandhi talks about banning railways and vaccines..
这篇内容让我想起了甘地的随笔《印度自治》，真是绝了。他本质上是相当反感技术驱动的变革的。他反对：- 机械替代手工艺（手艺失传，贫困随之而来）- 节省人力的机器替代人工（工人沦为……
This piece reminded me, of all things, of Gandhi's essay "Hind Swaraj." He was pretty anti-technological-driven change. He was anti: - Machinery replacing handicraft (skill disappeared and poverty followed) - Labor-saving machines replacing human workers (workers became…
……我理解我刚才提到的那些东西在 1908 年甘地写那篇随笔时还不存在，但谁知道现代 AI 又会带来什么我们现在无法想象的进步呢？https://www.mkgandhi.org/ebks/hind_swaraj.pdf 这是甘地那本书的 PDF。在“解释说明”（A Word of Explanation）一节中，你会发现甘地竟然表示乐见医院和铁路自然消亡。
…understand the things I mentioned just now weren’t around in 1908 when Gandhi wrote that essay but who knows what advancements modern AI could bring that we can’t imagine now? https://www.mkgandhi.org/ebks/hind_swaraj.pdf This is a PDF of that Gandhi book. Under the “A Word of Explanation” you find Gandhi saying he would welcome the natural destruction of hospitals and railways.
我不同意他的论点是颠扑不破的。https://www.mkgandhi.org/ebks/hind_swaraj.pdf 我在这个帖子的另一条评论里说了更多，不过这是他那本书的 PDF。甘地在“解释说明”部分说，他乐见医院自然毁灭。这怎么就……
I disagree his arguments are timeless. https://www.mkgandhi.org/ebks/hind_swaraj.pdf I posted more in another comment on this thread but here’s a PDF of his book. Gandhi says in the “A Word of Explanation” section that he would welcome the natural destruction of hospitals. How is…
……‘如果我被免去《每日邮报》主编一职，就会挨饿’，或者大意如此。”[0] 读到这里，甘地“立即将其翻译成古吉拉特语，并以此为基础写出了他的《印度自治》一书，这是他自己首次构想出的、专门针对本国问题的‘印度式’解决方案。因此你完全可以说（且并非无稽之谈），印度的独立，或者至少是它实现的……
…starved if I am excluded from the Editorship of the Daily Mail," or words to that effect."[0] On reading this, Gandhi "immediately translated it into Gujarati, and on the basis of it he wrote his book Hind Swaraj, his own first formulation of a specifically "Indian" solution to his country’s problems. Thus you might argue, not quite absurdly, that India owed its independence, or at least the manner in which it…