计算机仍然不能做什么

Hacker News 上怎么说

• cratermoon · 2021 年

  ……思考 AI 极限的黄金标准当属 Herbert Dreyfus 的著作，特别是 1972 年出版的《What Computers Can't Do: The Limits of Artificial Intelligence》，以及 1992 年出版的修订版《What Computers Still Can't Do: A Critique of Artificial Reason》，还有 1986 年的《Mind over Machine》。

  …gold standard for thinking about the limits of AI is the work of Herbert Dreyfus, specifically the books What Computers Can't Do: The Limits of Artificial Intelligence published in 1972, and the revised What Computers Still Can't Do: A Critique of Artificial Reason, published in 1992, and Mind over Machine, from 1986.

• max_ · 2024 年

  我最想推荐的好书有：——Pedro Domingos 的《The Master Algorithm》——Judea Pearl 的《The Book of Why》——Hubert L. Dreyfus 的《What Computers Still Can't Do》——Marvin Minsky 的《Society of Mind》和《The Emotion Machine》——Antonio Damasio 的《The Feeling Of What Happens》——Noam Chomsky 的《Language & Mind》——另外一门很棒的 mooc 是“Learning……

  The best books I would recommend are; — The Master Algorithm by Pedro Domingos — The Book of Why by Judea Pearl — What Computers Still Can't Do by Hubert L. Dreyfus — Society of Mind & The Emotion Machine by Marvin Minsky — The Feeling Of What Happens by Antonio Damasio — Language & Mind by Noam Chomsky — A great mooc is also, the "Learning…

• f_klem · 2026 年

  你可以先读读 Hubert Dreyfus 的《What Computers still can't do》。抱歉容我老调重弹：这本书解释了 AI 研究项目所基于的底层假设，以及为什么这些假设是有问题的。书里还引用了证据。它也引述了各种主张……

  You can start by reading What Computers still can't do, by Hubert Dreyfus. Sorry to repeat myself: this books explains the assumptions the AI research programme is based on, and why they are problematic. It also references evidence. It also references claims…

• AndrewOMartin · 2016 年

  ……Hubert Dreyfus 对 AI 的批判经受住了时间的考验，想直接理解或挑战这些观点的人可以去读读《What Computers Can't Do》（1972, 1979），或者更好的是看更新后的再版《What Computers Still Can't Do》（1992）。他是个海德格尔主义哲学家，但你只需要知道：现代 AI 对 20 世纪关于人类心智和存在状态的大量探索完全视而不见。因此，我认为……

  …critiques of AI from Hubert Dreyfus have stood the test of time, those who want to understand or challenge them directly can read What Computers Can't Do (1972, 1979), or even better the updated reprint What Computers Still Can't Do (1992). He's a Heideggarian Philosopher but all you need to know is that modern AI is ignorant of vast swathes of 20th Century investigation into the human mind, and state of being. Hence, I think the…

• AndrewOMartin · 2017 年

  显然我在评论里提到《What Computers Still Can't Do》的次数还不够多，没能让它上榜，这实在很遗憾，因为我很喜欢《What Computers Still Can't Do》，而且《What Computers Still Can't Do》跟咱们这个社区极其契合……

  I've clearly not mentioned What Computers Still Can't Do in comments enough to make What Computers Still Can't Do appear on this list, which is a shame as I love What Computers Still Can't Do, and What Computers Still Can't Do is very relevant to this community…

• swyx · 2017 年

  太强了，多给我讲讲《What Computers Still Can't Do》呗！

  that's amazing, tell me more about What Computers Still Can't Do!

正在加载完整评论……