坏撒玛利亚人
Bad Samaritans
Ha-Joon Chang · 初版 2007 年
22人推荐
34位读者提及
46次提及
为什么值得读
- 指出发达国家历史上普遍依赖保护主义与侵权
- 剖析日韩等国通过培育本土高生产力行业崛起
- 批判国际组织强加于发展中国家的贸易条件
一位顶尖经济学家对全球化相关问题的激进审视……鲜有一本书能以如此崭新的视角看待世界事务，但著名经济学家 Ha-Joon Chang 就全球化的未来提出了一些令人震惊的独到见解。他指出，理论上全球最富裕的国家以及 IMF、World Bank 和 WTO 等超国家机构希望看到所有国家都发展成为现代工业社会。然而在实践中，身居高位者却在“踢开梯子”，断绝他人攀登自己曾走过的财富之路。为什么？自身利益固然起到了
Hacker News 上怎么说
正在加载完整评论……
……所有国家在实现发展和富裕之后都是这副嘴脸。他们几乎全都是靠摆明了无视自由贸易才富起来的。十到十五年前张夏准写过一本相当不错的书叫《富国的伪善》（Bad Samaritans），探讨了全球化、自由贸易，特别是世贸组织、世界银行和发达国家如何把推行自由贸易作为贷款或协议的前提条件强加给发展中国家。他……
…every nation after they have achieved development and wealth. Pretty much all of whom got wealthy by pointedly ignoring free trade. There's a decent book from 10 or 15 years ago by Ha-Joon Chang called Bad Samaritans that explores globalisation, free trade and in particular the insistence of WTO, World Bank and developed nations forcing free trade on the developing world as a condition of loan, or agreements. He…
……国家、靠征税养兵打仗，而且还债的欲望助长了人类的许多残酷行径（比如埃尔南·科尔特斯、卡西米尔）。《资本主义的真相》（21 Things they don't tell you about Capitalism）、《富国的伪善》（Bad Samaritans，张夏准著）——让我明白了自由贸易对发展中国家通常是不利的，国家要想实现长远经济增长并避免贸易顺差/逆差失衡，就必须建立高生产力的工业体系……
…the state, taxing to feed soldiers for war, and that the drive to pay off one's debt fueled a lot of the cruelty of mankind (eg. Hernan Cortez, Casimir). 21 Things they don't tell you about Capitalism, Bad Samaritans (Ha Joon Chang) - Learned that free trade is generally bad for developing countries, countries need to build out high productivity industries to grow their economy in the long term and avoid a balance…
你被踩真挺冤的。我强烈推荐《富国的伪善》（Bad Samaritans）[1]这本书，它揭示了所有发达国家其实都走过相似的老路：盗用 IP（知识产权）外加贸易保护主义。1. https://www.amazon.com/Bad-Samaritans-Secret-History-Capital...
It's unfortunate you're being downvoted. I highly recommend the book, Bad Samaritans [1] as it shows that all developed countries followed a similar pattern of IP theft and protectionism. 1. https://www.amazon.com/Bad-Samaritans-Secret-History-Capital...
其实要证明这一点根本用不着看中国。去读读剑桥经济学家张夏准写的《富国的伪善》（Bad Samaritans）开头十几页，就能发现韩国就是一个颠覆（神话色彩浓厚的）官方叙事的当代反例；另外他的论文《踢开梯子》（Kicking…）也值得一读……
In fact you didn't really have to look up to China to show that. Reading up the first dozen or so pages of "Bad Samaritans" by Cambridge economist Ha-Joon Chang would reveal how South Korea is a fairly contemporary counterexample to the (largely mythical) official narrative; also worth taking a look at his paper "Kicking…
韩国经济学家张夏准在他的《富国的伪善》（Bad Samaritans）一书中提出了类似的观点。他认为韩国（三星、现代等）、日本、甚至15世纪英国的亨利七世都成功践行了这套模式——非常值得一读。
The Korean economist Ha-Joon Chang makes similar arguments in his book Bad samaritans. He argues that this model was successfully followed by Korea (Samsung, Hyundai, etc), Japan, and even Henry VII in 15th century England - well worth a read.
https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/1032019.Bad_Samaritans 这是一本好书，详述了经济体是如何发展的，以及国有/国家支持的企业在培育一国技术实力方面能起到怎样的帮助。作者以韩国为例……
https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/1032019.Bad_Samaritans This is a good book that goes through how economies develop and the role of State Owned/sponsored Enterprises are helpful in developing a nation's technology competencies. The author uses South Korea…