踢掉梯子
Kicking away the ladder
Ha-Joon Chang · 初版 2002 年
16人推荐
27位读者提及
42次提及
为什么值得读
- 采用大量扎实的历史数据进行实证分析
- 论证英美韩等国曾深度依赖贸易保护主义
- 反思新自由主义全球化对发展中国家的压制
Kicking Away the Ladder Kicking Away the Ladder: Development Strategy in Historical Perspective 是经济学家 Ha-Joon Chang 于2002年出版的著作。该书探讨了当今的发达国家如何通过干预主义政策实现繁荣，并指出当今的发展中国家往往被剥夺了使用类似工具的权利。该作品对国际发展经济学中正统的自由市场方案提出了挑战。关键信息 作者：Ha-Joon Chang 出版年份：2002 主题：经济发展与政策史 出版社：Anthem Press 获奖：2003年 Myrdal Prize（European Association for E...
Hacker News 上怎么说
正在加载完整评论……
……批评新古典理论过度数学化且不切实际，即便你认为这是非主流经济学，这种分类也很武断。他是面向大众读者写作的。你读过张夏准（Ha-Joon Chang）的《踢开梯子》（Kicking Away the Ladder）吗？如果你喜欢那种风格，那本要专业得多，里面有大量历史数据 >在这项发人深省的研究中，张夏准考察了发达世界对发展中国家施加的巨大压力，要求它们采纳某些……
…with critique of neoclassical theory as too mathematized and unrealistic the categorization is arbitary, even if you think it's heterodox. he's communicating to a general audience have you read chang's kicking away the ladder? much more specialized if that's you're thing, with historical data >In this provocative study, Ha-Joon Chang examines the great pressure on developing countries from the developed world to adopt certain…
……已知的因果力量，没有理由认为资本主义本身会带来更多的平等。（事实上，全球化已被证明会削弱国家的竞争力，比如可以参考韩国学者张夏准的《踢开梯子》一书。相比依赖外资和出口的国家，那些依靠国内供需的国家在缩小与发达国家经济差距方面往往表现要好得多……
…known causal force, there is no reason to think that capitalism itself causes more equality. (And in fact, globalization has been shown to counteract ability of countries to compete, see for example book Kicking Away the Ladder from Ha-Joon Chang, who is korean. Countries that depend on internal demand and supply rather than foreign investment and exports tend to fare much better in closing the economic gap with respect to developed…
……https://www.facebook.com/nntaleb/posts/10153658794008375 有充分的证据表明，许多国家是因为贸易保护主义而繁荣起来的：英国、美国、韩国……例如可以看看张夏准的书《踢开梯子》（Kicking Away the Ladder，这里有一份摘要：http://www.paecon.net/PAEtexts/Chang1.htm ）。平均数这种用法巧妙地掩盖了一个事实：大多数人沦为输家，而少数大款/肥猫卷走了所有收益。当一群……
…https://www.facebook.com/nntaleb/posts/10153658794008375 There is excellent evidence that many countries became prosperous because of protectionism: UK, USA, S. Korea... See for instance the book from Ha-Joon Chang, "Kicking Away the Ladder" (a digest can be found here: http://www.paecon.net/PAEtexts/Chang1.htm ) The use of averages conveniently masks the fact that most people lose while a few fat cats grab all the gains. When a group of…
……“华盛顿共识”式的贸易政策。恰恰相反，这两个国家根本没有实行这类政策；它们采用的是完全相反的做法——严格的贸易保护主义和国家统制资本主义。参见张夏准的《踢开梯子》（Kicking Away the Ladder）。
…“Washington Consensus”-style trade policies. On the contrary, these two countries didn't implement such policies at all; they used the opposite method, strict protectionism and state-managed capitalism. See "kicking away the ladder" by Ha-Joon Chang.
张夏准的《踢开梯子》（Kicking Away the Ladder），工业发展与政治经济学方面的必读书，哪怕只是对这个领域稍微有一点兴趣的人都应该读读，读完之后你还可以去看看琼·罗宾逊（Joan Robinson）对李嘉图经济学的批判……
Kicking away the ladder by Ha-Joon Chang Industrial development and political economy, it really is a must read for anyone even mildly interested on the field, then you could go to Joan Robinson's criticism of Ricardian economics,…
这适用的范围远不止环境因素，而且在当今的发达经济体中惊人地一致，参见张夏准的《踢开梯子》（Kicking Away the Ladder）。
This applies far more than for just environmental factors and is alarmingly consistent across developed economies today, see Ha Joon Chang's "Kicking Away the Ladder"