哥白尼革命
The Copernican revolution
Thomas S. Kuhn · 初版 1957 年
7人推荐
11位读者提及
17次提及
为什么值得读
- 还原科学观念交替的真实历史，澄清常见误解
- 不依赖范式等抽象术语，叙述更为原创深刻
- 展现科学史学者独到且深入浅出的梳理功力
“作者将历史学家的深思熟虑、科学家的专业理解，以及优秀教师的技巧与经验汇聚于一体。任何细心的读者在阅读这本精心构思的著作时，都无不赞赏这些要素在全面阐释科学思想演进重大转折点时所展现的精妙平衡。对于从事科学史教学的人而言，本书对哥白尼革命所涉议题的探讨将证明是不可或缺的，堪称对革命剖析的绝佳分析……
Hacker News 上怎么说
正在加载完整评论……
你对当时物理学和天文学的思想史及其脉络的理解完全是乱七八糟的。我郑重建议你读读库恩的《哥白尼革命》。你那些关于人们并不蠢、教会动机等等的评论，如果算是在回复我的话，纯粹是在立稻草人。
Your version of the history and relationships among ideas at the time in physics and astronomy is hopelessly garbled. I respectfully suggest you read Kuhn's The Copernican Revolution. Your comments about people not being stupid, the Church's motivations, etc., if intended as a reply to me, are strawmen.
…http://www.amazon.com/Lives-Artists-Oxford-Worlds-Classics/d... http://www.amazon.com/Golden-Trade-Moors-Kingdoms-Fourteenth... http://www.amazon.com/Gallic-Wars-Caesars-Account-Conquest/d... http://www.amazon.com/Copernican-Revolution-Planetary-Astron... 注意这里面大概有一半都绝版了。
…http://www.amazon.com/Lives-Artists-Oxford-Worlds-Classics/d... http://www.amazon.com/Golden-Trade-Moors-Kingdoms-Fourteenth... http://www.amazon.com/Gallic-Wars-Caesars-Account-Conquest/d... http://www.amazon.com/Copernican-Revolution-Planetary-Astron... Note that about half of these are out of print.
…君士坦丁堡；奇波拉，《枪炮、帆船与帝国》；哈达斯，《罗马史》；阿曼，《中世纪战争艺术》；瓦萨里，《艺苑名人传》；博维尔，《摩尔人的黄金贸易》；恺撒，《高卢战记》；库恩，《哥白尼革命》
…Constantinople Cipolla, Guns, Sails and Empires Hadas, A History of Rome Oman, The Art of War in the Middle Ages Vasari, Lives of the Artists Bovill, The Golden Trade of the Moors Caesar, Gallic Wars Kuhn, The Copernican Revolution
库恩真正了不起的书是《哥白尼革命》。他是一位见解独到的科学史家。有意思的是，他从科学史中汲取了一些该领域学者早就熟知的经验教训，将其简化和提炼，以至于……
Kuhn's really great book is The Copernican Revolution. He was a uniquely insightful historian of science. It's amusing that he took some lessons from the history of science, well known to scholars in that field, simplified and distilled them to the point…
库恩关于这方面写得更好的一本书是《哥白尼革命》。这是一部极具独创性和深刻洞察力的科学史著作，而且不用每段都读到“范式（paradigm）”这个词。
A better book by Kuhn about this stuff is The Copernican Revolution. It's original and penetrating history of science without having to read "paradigm" in every paragraph.
……对于科学史家来说这是个老生常谈的观念。这是因为前者完全不懂科学是如何运作的，而后者对科学的实际发展历程了如指掌。库恩是一位出色的科学史家：他的《哥白尼革命》才是他真正的代表作。
…commonplace notion for historians of science. That’s because the former had no idea how science worked, but the latter were intimate with its actual development. Kuhn was an excellent historian of science: his Copernican Revolution is his real masterpiece.