达尔文的黑匣子
Darwin's Black Box
Michael J. Behe · 初版 1996 年
3位读者提及
4次提及
几乎所有严肃的科学家都认同 Darwin 进化论的真实性。尽管争取被世人接受的过程漫长而艰难，但在一个世纪之后，这场争论已经平息。生物学家们现在坚信，他们剩下的疑问，例如地球生命是如何起源的，或者 Cambrian 爆发如何在如此短的时间内产生如此多的新物种，都将找到符合 Darwin 理论的答案。他们和我们大多数人一样，认为 Darwin 的理论是正确的。但我们真的该如此吗？如果我们发现了能够彻底挑战当下公认定论的证据，又会发生什么？正如 Behe
Hacker News 上怎么说
正在加载完整评论……
Michael Behe 的《Darwin's Black Box》中的例子：血液的凝血机制是一个由 30 多个部分组成的 cascading 系统。拿掉其中任何一个环节对个体来说都是致命的。这样一个系统怎么可能随时间逐步演化出来？他列举了相当多…
Examples from Michael Behe's book Darwin's Black Box: Blood's ability to coagulate is a cascading system with over 30 parts. Remove one part and it's fatal for the individual. How could a system like that evolve gradually over time? He lists quite a few…
你推荐了 Behe 的书；我前阵子读过他早期的那本《Darwin's Black Box》。我觉得写得挺有意思、文笔不错，表面上看也很有说服力，但根本上漏洞百出，归根结底是在浪费时间。
You recommend Behe's book; I read his earlier book "Darwin's Black Box"a while back. I found it interesting, well-written, and superficially convincing but fundamentally flawed and ultimately a waste of time.
…生物学。DNA 复制、转录和翻译都是由多种蛋白质和酶促进的复杂过程，而这些酶和蛋白本身也是进化而来的。关于 Michael Behe 教授在《Darwin's Black Box》中的论点，虽然引人深思，但在科学界已经遭到了广泛的批评和驳斥。Behe 提出的“irreducible complexity”（不可化约的复杂性）已被证明并不能排除进化起源，因为大量的…
…biology. DNA replication, transcription, and translation are complex processes facilitated by a variety of proteins and enzymes, which themselves evolved. Regarding Prof. Michael Behe's arguments in "Darwin's Black Box," while thought-provoking, they have been widely critiqued and refuted in the scientific community. Behe's concept of "irreducible complexity" has been shown not to preclude evolutionary origins, as numerous…
我读《Darwin's Black Box》是20多年前的事了，所以细节记不太清。他的核心观点是“irreducible complexity”（不可化约的复杂性），也就是像捕鼠夹一样，拿掉任何一个部件整个系统就无法运转。他声称有许多…
I read "Darwin's Black Box" over 20 years ago so I can't give a lot of details. His fundamental idea was "irreducible complexity", a system that won't work if you take away any piece, such as a mousetrap. He claimed that a lot…