如何聆听并理解伟大的音乐

Hacker News 上怎么说

• peruvian · 2017 年

  ……时间更少了。几个月前我想学着鉴赏和聆听古典音乐。于是我每天早上早起一个小时，读读书，听听音频课程（罗伯特·格林伯格的《如何聆听与理解伟大的音乐》How to Listen to and Understand Great Music），然后在当时以及一整天里都放着真正的音乐听。几个月下来，我已经能听出大多数乐曲的曲式结构，以及作曲家是否“打破了规则”（以及为什么打破）。我看不懂五线谱，也分不清……

  …have less time. A few months ago I wanted to learn to appreciate and listen to classical music. I woke up an hour earlier every morning and read a book, listened to an audio course (Robert Greenberg's How to Listen to and Understand Great Music), and listened to actual music then and throughout the day. A few months later I can recognize the structure of most pieces and if the composer "broke the rules" (and why). I can't read music or tell…

• p15 · 2018 年

  对于这个话题，一个极好的入门资源是罗伯特·格林伯格主讲的系列讲座，叫《如何聆听与理解伟大的音乐》（How to Listen to and Understand Great Music）。内容细节非常丰富，但格林伯格讲得深入浅出又趣味横生。Audible 和“The Great Courses”上都能很便宜买到。

  An excellent introduction to this topic is a lecture series called “How to Listen to and Understand Great Music” by Robert Greenberg. It’s very rich in detail but Greenberg also makes it accessible and fun. It’s available for cheap on audible and from “the great courses”.

• joshstaiger · 2023 年

  如果你对古典乐有一丁点儿兴趣，我强烈推荐罗伯特·格林伯格的《如何聆听与理解伟大的音乐》。Audible 上有：https://www.audible.com/pd/How-to-Listen-to-and-Understand-G... 课程很长（36小时，拆分成约45分钟一节的讲座），但非常引人入胜……

  I highly recommend Robert Greenberg's "How to Listen to and Understand Great Music" if you have any interest in Classical. Available on audible: https://www.audible.com/pd/How-to-Listen-to-and-Understand-G... It's long (36 hours, broken up into ~45min lectures), but very engaging…

• watermoose · 2016 年

  这篇很棒，不过我推荐罗伯特·格林伯格的《如何聆听与理解伟大的音乐》。他梳理西方音乐史的方式，能让人非常清楚为什么 Amin != Cmaj，以及楼主提到的其他疑问。没错，乐谱确实很操蛋，而且他还解释了乐谱是如何演变成今天这个……

  This is great, but I would recommend Robert Greenberg's "How to Listen to and Understand Great Music". He goes through the history of western music in a way that makes it clear why Amin != Cmaj, and other questions that the OP has. Yes, sheet music is crap, and he explains how it evolved to be the way…

• sotojuan · 2017 年

  如果你想上一门课，罗伯特·格林伯格的《如何聆听与理解伟大的音乐》——Audible 上就有。

  If you want a course, Robert Greenberg's How to Listen to and Understand Great Music - it's on Audible.

• dave84 · 2014 年

  要是有人想找个能“从头开始”理解音乐的途径，我真是怎么推荐《如何聆听与理解伟大的音乐》[1] 都不为过。整个讲座大概有35个小时，我才听到一半，但目前为止简直神作。Audible 上也有。[1] http://www.thegreatcourses.com/tgc/courses/course_detail.asp...

  If anyone is looking for a way to understand music "from the beginning" so to speak, I can't recommend "How to Listen to and Understand Great Music"[1] enough. It's around 35 hours worth of lectures, I'm only half way through but it's fantastic so far. It's also available on Audible. [1] http://www.thegreatcourses.com/tgc/courses/course_detail.asp...

正在加载完整评论……