骗局还是良药？
Trick or Treatment?
Simon Singh、Edzard Ernst · 初版 2008 年
1人推荐
3位读者提及
4次提及
对替代医学中最常用的三十多种疗法进行了审查与评估，例如针灸、顺势疗法、芳香疗法、反射疗法、脊骨神经医学和草药医学等。
Hacker News 上怎么说
正在加载完整评论……
Trick or Treatment?
Simon Singh、Edzard Ernst · 初版 2008 年
对替代医学中最常用的三十多种疗法进行了审查与评估，例如针灸、顺势疗法、芳香疗法、反射疗法、脊骨神经医学和草药医学等。
正在加载完整评论……
我更新了我的书架，把 Simon Singh 的《Trick or Treatment》加进去了，他在被脊医协会（Chiropractor's association）起诉后，正是这本书引发了他参与诽谤法改革。考虑到过去几年对他生活造成的影响，他理应得到补偿。况且他早期的作品就……
I've updated my bookshelf to include Simon Singh's "Trick or Treatment" which sparked his involvement in libel reform when he was sued by the Chiropractor's association. Given the impact on his life for the past few years he deserves recompense. Plus his earlier works were…
三本？你漏了哪本？《The Code Book》、《Fermat's Last Theorem》、《Big Bang》还是《Trick or Treatment》（与 Edzard Ernst 合著）？
Three? Which are you missing? The Code Book, Fermat's Last Theorem, Big Bang or Trick or Treatment (with Edzard Ernst)?
我承认那句话确实容易给人那种印象，但我认为这有点断章取义了。如果你读过 Simon Singh 的作品（尤其是《Trick or Treatment》，正是这本书引出了那篇文章，进而引发了诽谤官司），那真的不是他所倡导的——他主张的是说话得有扎实的证据基础。我觉得他当时是想……
I agree that that sentence could give that impression but I think it's a little out of context. If you read Simon Singh's stuff (particularly Trick or Treatment, the book which lead to the article which lead to the libel case) it's really not what he advocates - he advocates having a robust evidence base for what you're saying. I think what he was trying to…
……Francois Chollet 和 Matthew Watson。最近读了 Anthony Doerr 的书（Shell Collector, About Grace, Memory Wall, All the Light We Cannot See）和 Simon Singh 的书（Code Book, Fermat's Last Theorem, Trick or Treatment, The Simpsons and Their Mathematical Secrets）。
…Francois Chollet and Matthew Watson Recently read books by Anthony Doerr (Shell Collector, About Grace, Memory Wall, All the Light We Cannot See) and Simon Singh (Code Book, Fermat's Last Theorem, Trick or Treatment, The Simpsons and Their Mathematical Secrets).