希特勒的自愿行刑者
Hitler's willing executioners
Daniel Jonah Goldhagen · 初版 1996 年
3人推荐
6位读者提及
7次提及
这本开创性的国际畅销书粉碎了关于大屠杀的诸多神话：诸如德国人对大规模屠杀犹太人不知情、凶手全都是党卫军成员，以及那些屠杀犹太人的人只是勉强为之。Hitler's Willing Executioners 提供了确凿的证据，表明对欧洲犹太人的灭绝投入了成千上万普通德国人的精力与狂热。Goldhagen 重构了那种让希特勒追求其种族灭绝目标成为可能的“消灭型反犹主义”氛围，以及 20 世纪 30 年代
Hacker News 上怎么说
正在加载完整评论……
先假设你的评论不是在阴阳怪气，那我建议你首先去读读 Daniel Goldhagen 的神作《Hitler’s Willing Executioners》，书里给出了很扎实的论证：要不是顺从的德国普通民众，大屠杀的很大一部分可能根本就不会发生。那你倒是说说看：是谁在运转中国的集中……
Assuming for a moment that your comment is not sarcasm, I point you to first the excellent book “Hitler’s Willing Executioners” by Daniel Goldhagen which makes a solid case that had it not been for a compliant German citizenry, much of the Holocaust might never have happened. So you tell me: Who operates the Chinese concentration…
要是你还没读过的话，真应该去读读 Daniel Goldhagen 的书《Hitler’s Willing Executioners》。
If you haven't already, you should read Daniel Goldhagen's book, "Hitler's Willing Executioners."
……地位。确实，希特勒的信徒——就像毛的信徒一样——也“像恶狗追松鼠一样乐在其中”。关于这种现象有一本相当火的书很值得一读，叫《Hitler’s Willing Executioners》。https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/784848.Hitler_s_Willing_... 不管怎样，每当有评论家在探讨“20世纪……时，只盯着法西斯的暴行或者只盯着共产主义的暴行看……
…status. Indeed, Hitler's acolytes - like Mao's - also 'went at it with the delight of dogs chasing squirrels.' A rather popular book was published about this phenomenon that's worth reading, called "Hitler's Willing Executioners." https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/784848.Hitler_s_Willing_... In any case, whenever a commentator chooses to exclusively focus on fascist atrocities or communist atrocities when examing '20th century…
我读过《Ordinary Men》，也读过《Hitler’s Willing Executioners》，我觉得它们恰恰证明了我的观点。> 如果他们不服从，到底会（以及不会）遭遇什么 这是关键所在。如果他们不服从命令会怎样？结果发现……几乎什么事都不会有。你可能会被……
I'm familiar with Ordinary Men and also with Hitler's Willing Executioners and I think they prove my point. > what does (and doesn't) happen to them if they don't This is key. What happens if they didn't follow orders? It turns out that... pretty much nothing. You could get…
Daniel Goldhagen 在他的书《Hitler's Willing Executioners》里，生动揭示了普通德国人参与大屠杀的程度。[0] 这本书虽然受到了历史学家的很多批评，但里面包含着大量引人入胜的史料。[0] - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hitler%27s_Willing_Executioner...
Daniel Goldhagen does a good job of illustrating the involvement of everyday Germans in the Holocaust in his book "Hitler's Willing Executioners."[0] This book has received a lot of criticism from historians but it contains a lot of fascinating information. [0] - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hitler%27s_Willing_Executioner...
“邪恶的不是人民，而是体制……”我不确定朝鲜的情况如何，但几年前有位作者在《Hitler's Willing Executioners》一书中提出，二战时期的大多数德国人都乐于并且自愿配合独裁者的种族灭绝和全面战争。《1984》的结尾，温斯顿·史密斯似乎被迫接受了“他深爱老大哥”的心态。我……
"It's not the people who are evil, but the regime ..." I'm not sure about the North Korean case, but an author argued a few years back in the book "Hitler's Willing Executioners" that most WWII-era Germans were happy and willing to go along with the despot's genocide and total war. "1984" ends with Smith Winston seemingly coerced into the attitude "[I] loved Big Brother". I'm…