是引擎，不是相机

Hacker News 上怎么说

• jfager · 2012 年

  ……把对迈隆·斯科尔斯（Myron Scholes）和伊恩·斯图尔特（Ian Stewart）的采访摘录穿插在一起，写成了一篇虽然过度简化但也不算太烂的 Black-Scholes 模型及其影响的综述。如果你对这个问题感兴趣，我推荐唐纳德·麦肯齐（Donald MacKenzie）写的《不是相机，而是引擎》（An Engine, Not a Camera）。书中非常详尽地探讨了 Black-Scholes 的历史、它在期权交易中的应用，以及它（或者说整个金融建模）是如何与 1987 年股灾联系在一起的，还有……

  …excerpts from interviews with Myron Scholes and Ian Stewart woven into an oversimplified but not completely awful overview of Black-Scholes and its impact. If the question interests you, I recommend An Engine, Not a Camera by Donald MacKenzie. It goes into great detail about the history of Black-Scholes, its application in options trading, and how it (or, rather, financial modeling in general) tied into the 1987 crash and…

• muggermuch · 2022 年

  1. 我强烈推荐读一下唐纳德·麦肯齐的《不是相机，而是引擎》（An Engine, Not A Camera）。从体裁上讲，它读起来像是一部关于金融实践的社会学研究——探讨金融市场是如何重塑社会，而不仅仅是反映社会大众的需求和欲望。更重要的是，……

  1. I would fiercely recommend reading “An Engine, Not A Camera” (Donald MacKenzie). Formally, it reads as a sociological study of the practice of finance - how financial markets shape society instead of simply capturing its needs and desires at large. More importantly,…

• pash · 2026 年

  ……重塑了金融从业者的行为模式，以至于现在的金融市场比起以前，更加符合模型所描述的样子。唐纳德·麦肯齐的书《不是相机，而是引擎》（An Engine, Not a Camera）对这一现象做了极佳的研究：https://mitpress.mit.edu/9780262633673/an-engine-not-a-camer...

  …reshaped the ways financial practitioners behave to such an extent that financial markets now conform much more closely to what the models describe than was formerly the case. Donald MacKenzie’s book An Engine, Not a Camera is an excellent study of this phenomenon: https://mitpress.mit.edu/9780262633673/an-engine-not-a-camer...

• bchjam · 2021 年

  《不是相机，而是引擎》（An engine, not a camera）是一本关于金融市场中这种效应的绝佳好书。https://mitpress.mit.edu/books/engine-not-camera

  "An engine, not a camera" is a great book about this effect in financial markets. https://mitpress.mit.edu/books/engine-not-camera

• ctkrohn · 2012 年

  我也给《不是相机，而是引擎》（An Engine, Not A Camera）点个赞。这是一本关于金融建模哲学、以及模型如何影响市场（即“引擎”作用），而非仅仅提供静态信息快照（即“相机”作用）的好书。

  Another thumbs up for "An Engine, Not A Camera." A great book on the philosophy of financial modeling and how models influence the markets (the "engine"), rather than providing static snapshots of information (the "camera").

• viburnum · 2019 年

  有本非常棒的书叫《不是相机，而是引擎：金融模型如何塑造市场》（An Engine, Not a Camera: How Financial Models Shape Markets），绝对名副其实。

  There’s an excellent book called “An Engine, Not a Camera: How Financial Models Shape Markets” that lives up to its title.

正在加载完整评论……