论杀戮
On Killing
Dave Grossman、Lt Grossman · 初版 1995 年
21人推荐
41位读者提及
50次提及
为什么值得读
- 探讨人克服杀戮天性时受到的心理条件反射
- 从急救护理提升角度解释凶杀死亡率变化
- 由西点军校心理学教授结合军旅视角分析
好消息是，大多数士兵都极度抗拒杀戮。但军队已经研发出精密的方法来克服这种本能的厌恶。而当代平民社会，尤其是大众媒体，复制了军队的这种条件反射训练技术，按照 Dave Grossman 中校的论点，这正是年轻群体谋杀率攀升的罪魁祸首。On Killing 初版问世时，便被誉为里程碑式的研究，深入剖析了军方用来克服强烈杀戮抗拒心理的技术、杀戮对士兵本人的影响，以及暴力升级对社会的深远影响
Hacker News 上怎么说
正在加载完整评论……
这是个很重要的观点。想要更详细的讨论，我推荐 Dave Grossman 的《On Killing》。他提出了一个非常有说服力的论点，即美国谋杀率的长期下降趋势，其实取决于送医速度变快（得益于更完善的急救第一响应规范）以及送达后更好的救治…
That's an important point. For a more detailed discussion of it, I recommend Dave Grossman's On Killing. He makes a convincing argument that the long-term downward trend in the U.S. murder rate is a function of faster trips to the hospital (due to better first responder protocols), and better care once…
Dave Grossman 的《On Killing》深入探讨了支持你朋友这一主张的研究。我强烈向所有被你的评论勾起兴趣的人推荐这本书。
On Killing by Dave Grossman explores the research backing up your friend's assertion in depth. I highly recommend that book to anyone whose interest is piqued by your comment.
实际上，发动战争最高明的手法就是说服人们去杀其他人，而这正是通过老一套的操作性条件反射（operant conditioning）来实现的：http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Operant_conditioning 读读《On Killing: The Psychological Cost of Learning to Kill in War and Society》。作者 Dave Grossman 曾是陆军游骑兵（Army Ranger），也是西点军校的心理学教授。他提出的论点是，大多数人天生都有一种…
Actually, the greatest trick of waging war is to convince people to kill other people, and that's done with plain ol' operant conditioning: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Operant_conditioning Read "On Killing: The Psychological Cost of Learning to Kill in War and Society." The author, Dave Grossman, is an Army Ranger and a Psychology professor at West Point. He lays down an argument that most people have a…
你可能会对 Dave Grossman 的《On Killing》感兴趣：http://www.amazon.com/On-Killing-Psychological-Learning-Soci... Grossman 是西点军校的心理学教授（或者写这本书时曾是），也是前陆军游骑兵，尽管他从未上过战场。…
You may be interested in Dave Grossman's "On Killing": http://www.amazon.com/On-Killing-Psychological-Learning-Soci... Grossman is a Psychology professor at West Point (or was when he wrote this), and a former Army Ranger, although he never saw combat.…
…似乎更多是在讲述他朋友们的经历，而不是他个人的想法和感受。关于参战人员我见过的最好分析，是 Grossman 中校（LCol. Grossman）的著作。《On Combat》和《On Killing》是非常出色的作品，里面的观点几乎与这里的 W 截然相反。
…seemed to be more about relating the experiences of his friends than his own personal thoughts and feelings. The best analysis I've seen about the combatant are the works of LCol. Grossman. On Combat and On Killing are outstanding pieces of work that say pretty much the exact opposite of W here.
…大多数人最渴望的其实是别人告诉他们，无论他们做什么都没问题。Don Draper：在 Google+ 上被封号了。:) 我很清楚地记得（《广告狂人》里的）那一幕，觉得很有洞察力。这让我想起了《On Killing》，一本关于战争心理影响的绝佳好书。解释 PTSD（创伤后应激障碍）愈发普遍的一种假说是士兵战后归来时受到的对待方式。战争从来都很残酷，…
…what most people crave is to be told that whatever they're doing is OK. Don Draper: banned on Google+. :) I remember that scene (in Mad Men) quite well and I think it's insightful. It reminds me of On Killing, an excellent book on the psychological effects of war. One proposed candidate for the increasing prevalence of PTSD is the way soldiers are treated when they return from war. War has always been terrible,…