…工党让迅速去殖民化变得不可避免）。>美苏原本会趋同于某种更接近西欧社会民主主义的模式
有一本挺有意思的书跟这个有点搭界，Terry Martin 写的《The Affirmative Action Empire》。从实际发生的情况来看，美苏之间有非常多相似之处。>要是没有车臣人，现在的沙皇身边可能就缺了哥萨克？乌克兰战争残酷的现实似乎…
…Labor rapid decolonization inevitable). >US and USSR would have converged on something closer to a western european social democratic model There is a very interesting book kind of related to this, The Affirmative Action Empire by Terry Martin. A lot of parallels between the US and USSR in terms of what actually happened. >current Tsar might lack for Cossacks without Chechens? The unfortunate reality of the Ukraine War seems…
你搞错了。我不怪你——这是恐俄宣传（Russophobic propaganda）里很常见的话术。我建议读读 Terry Martin 写的《The Affirmative Action Empire: Nations and Nationalism in the Soviet Union, 1923–1939》[0] “苏联是欧洲多民族国家中第一个通过系统性地…
You are mistaken. I don't blame you - it's a common narrative of Russophobic propaganda. I'd suggest reading "The Affirmative Action Empire: Nations and Nationalism in the Soviet Union, 1923–1939" by Terry Martin [0] "The Soviet Union was the first of Europe's multiethnic states to confront the rising tide of nationalism by systematically…
…俄罗斯人生活在明确的非俄罗斯族省份，尽管通常来说他们才是该省份的多数群体。有一本深入探讨这个话题的好书是 Terry Martin 的《Affirmative Action Empire》- https://www.amazon.com/Affirmative-Action-Empire-Nationalism... 与此同时，其他地区的马克思主义带有极其鲜明的民族主义色彩——例如在非洲、印尼、越南或其他国家…
…Russians were living in an explicitly non-Russian province, even though often times they were the majority population in that province. A good book that covers this topic in depth is Terry Martin's "Affirmative Action Empire" - https://www.amazon.com/Affirmative-Action-Empire-Nationalism... At the same time, Marxism in other areas had a decidedly nationalist tone - for example in Africa, Indonesia, Vietnam or other nations…
…Europe and implemented a similar ruling style for its Empire until WWII, giving more visibility to Manchu, Koreans... and representing itself as a multicultural Empire. A historian called the USSR the "Affirmative Action Empire"[0] because this was their preferred way to maintain control over minorities while giving them the sense that they could "make it" in the Soviet Union. I think affirmative action dates back to the 60's…
…工党让迅速去殖民化变得不可避免）。>美苏原本会趋同于某种更接近西欧社会民主主义的模式 有一本挺有意思的书跟这个有点搭界，Terry Martin 写的《The Affirmative Action Empire》。从实际发生的情况来看，美苏之间有非常多相似之处。>要是没有车臣人，现在的沙皇身边可能就缺了哥萨克？乌克兰战争残酷的现实似乎…
…Labor rapid decolonization inevitable). >US and USSR would have converged on something closer to a western european social democratic model There is a very interesting book kind of related to this, The Affirmative Action Empire by Terry Martin. A lot of parallels between the US and USSR in terms of what actually happened. >current Tsar might lack for Cossacks without Chechens? The unfortunate reality of the Ukraine War seems…
你搞错了。我不怪你——这是恐俄宣传（Russophobic propaganda）里很常见的话术。我建议读读 Terry Martin 写的《The Affirmative Action Empire: Nations and Nationalism in the Soviet Union, 1923–1939》[0] “苏联是欧洲多民族国家中第一个通过系统性地…
You are mistaken. I don't blame you - it's a common narrative of Russophobic propaganda. I'd suggest reading "The Affirmative Action Empire: Nations and Nationalism in the Soviet Union, 1923–1939" by Terry Martin [0] "The Soviet Union was the first of Europe's multiethnic states to confront the rising tide of nationalism by systematically…
…俄罗斯人生活在明确的非俄罗斯族省份，尽管通常来说他们才是该省份的多数群体。有一本深入探讨这个话题的好书是 Terry Martin 的《Affirmative Action Empire》- https://www.amazon.com/Affirmative-Action-Empire-Nationalism... 与此同时，其他地区的马克思主义带有极其鲜明的民族主义色彩——例如在非洲、印尼、越南或其他国家…
…Russians were living in an explicitly non-Russian province, even though often times they were the majority population in that province. A good book that covers this topic in depth is Terry Martin's "Affirmative Action Empire" - https://www.amazon.com/Affirmative-Action-Empire-Nationalism... At the same time, Marxism in other areas had a decidedly nationalist tone - for example in Africa, Indonesia, Vietnam or other nations…
…欧洲，直到二战前一直对其帝国采取类似的治理模式，给予满族、朝鲜族等更多的能见度……并将自身塑造成一个多元文化的帝国。有位历史学家称苏联为“Affirmative Action Empire”[0]，因为这是他们维持对少数民族掌控的首选方式，同时让他们觉得自己能在苏联“出人头地”（make it）。我觉得 affirmative action 最早可以追溯到 60 年代…
…Europe and implemented a similar ruling style for its Empire until WWII, giving more visibility to Manchu, Koreans... and representing itself as a multicultural Empire. A historian called the USSR the "Affirmative Action Empire"[0] because this was their preferred way to maintain control over minorities while giving them the sense that they could "make it" in the Soviet Union. I think affirmative action dates back to the 60's…