精神疾病的神话

The Myth of Mental Illness

Thomas Stephen Szasz、Thomas S. Szasz、Thomas Szasz、Szasz, Thomas, S.; Thomas S. Szasz · 初版 1961 年

5人推荐

13位读者提及

13次提及

为什么值得读

质疑部分所谓精神疾病并非真正的器质性病变
深刻反思心理学与精神医学背后的权力与控制
为看待精神障碍与异常行为提供另类批判视角

作者认为，如今被公认为精神疾病的，不过是精神科医生口中所定义的东西——而且精神病学正愈发狂热地将越来越多的行为定义为精神疾病。所谓精神疾病，实际上只是说话者所不认可的行为。

Hacker News 上怎么说

elbasti · 2019 年
Szasz 的《The Myth of Mental Illness》（精神疾病的迷思）就是那种纯粹因为书名就被完完全全误解了的作品。我现在手头没有这本书，但他引言里说的意思大概是……
Szasz's "The Myth of Mental Illness" is one of those works which is completely and utterly misinterpreted simply because of the title. I don't have the book available at the moment, but in the introduction he says something to the effect…
jeffreyrogers · 2018 年
有本叫《The Myth of Mental Illness》（精神疾病的迷思）[0] 的书详细探讨了这个问题。作者认为，我们所谓的“精神疾病”，很多形式根本不是真正的疾病，而是极端的偏好，让人无法顺利……
There's a book called The Myth of Mental Illness[0] that deals with this issue at length. The author argues that many forms of what we call "mental illness" are not real illnesses at all, but extreme preferences that prevent people from successfully…
peter_d_sherman · 2019 年
……要是某种方式给出的行动情报模棱两可，或者反过来连根本原因都解释不清……那可就是个巨大的危险信号（BIG RED FLAG）！！！另外……想看关于精神疾病的不同视角，你可以读读医学博士 Thomas Szasz 写的《The Myth Of Mental Illness》：https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Myth_of_Mental_Illness “发疯就是重复做同一件事，却期待不同的结果”——阿尔伯特·爱因斯坦
…way as to provide actionable intelligence one way, or the exact reason WHY on the other... that's a BIG RED FLAG!!! Also... for an alternative viewpoint on Mental Illness, you might wish to read "The Myth Of Mental Illness" by Dr. Thomas Szasz, M.D. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Myth_of_Mental_Illness "Insanity is doing the same thing over and over and expecting different results" -Albert Einstein
CWuestefeld · 2009 年
关于利用心理学作为控制手段的更深入思考，可以参考 Thomas Szasz，尤其是《The Myth of Mental Illness》：http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Myth_of_Mental_Illness 尽管确实存在一些根源于大脑生理缺陷的障碍，但精神疾病往往沦为强迫人们……的手段。
For deeper thoughts on the use of psychology as a means of control, see Thomas Szasz, especially The Myth of Mental Illness . http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Myth_of_Mental_Illness While there surely exist some disorders rooted in physical defects of the brain, mental illnesses too often become a means of forcing people…
Kourovsky · 2024 年
“精神疾病的迷思” Thomas Szasz https://depts.washington.edu/psychres/wordpress/wp-content/u...
“The Myth of Mental illness” Thomas Szasz https://depts.washington.edu/psychres/wordpress/wp-content/u...
phaus · 2019 年
>另外……想看关于精神疾病的不同视角，你可以读读医学博士 Thomas Szasz 写的《The Myth Of Mental Illness》。我可能会去看看那本书，听起来挺有意思，但维基百科那篇词条把他写得像个白痴一样。具体来说，我觉得这观点简直蠢透了：……
>Also... for an alternative viewpoint on Mental Illness, you might wish to read "The Myth Of Mental Illness" by Dr. Thomas Szasz, M.D. I might check that book out because it sounds interesting, but the Wikipedia article makes him sound like an idiot. More specifically, this strikes me as absolutely stupid:…

正在加载完整评论……