独自和解
A Separate Peace
John Knowles · 初版 1959 年
1人推荐
9位读者提及
9次提及
Gene Forrester回首十五年前的第二次世界大战时期，那时他和最好的朋友在New Hampshire的一所寄宿学校里同住一室。
Hacker News 上怎么说
正在加载完整评论……
A Separate Peace
John Knowles · 初版 1959 年
Gene Forrester回首十五年前的第二次世界大战时期，那时他和最好的朋友在New Hampshire的一所寄宿学校里同住一室。
正在加载完整评论……
你提到的《麦田里的守望者》让我想起了《独自和解》（A Separate Peace）。还有其他人不仅读过这部经典，而且曾经把它当成内向类文学里的“最爱”吗？
Your Catcher in the Rye reference reminds me of "A Separate Peace" Anyone else not only read this classic but had it as a "favorite" book once, in the introvert genre?
这里更大的问题是什么，是少数几位学生和老师可能具有代表性的反应，还是学校选拔阅读书目的整个流程？作为一个高中生，我当时真的很讨厌《独自和解》和《蝇王》。我纳闷，过去这一个世纪里写出了那么多伟大的文学作品，为什么偏偏强迫我们读这么致郁的书？为什么他们就不能选一些让更多学生享受……
What is more of an issue here, the possibly representative reactions of a few students and teachers, or the whole process by which school readings are chosen? As a high school student, I really hated A Separate Peace and Lord of the Flies. I wondered, with all the great literature written just in the past century, why were we forced to read such downers? Why couldn't they choose novels that made more students enjoy…
……讨论，所以被迅速 flag 是情理之中的。> 这只是两句讽刺的话而已不管讨论什么话题，讽刺几乎毫无例外都是毫无价值的噪音。我总是想到《独自和解》里的话：“正如我所说，那是我充满冷嘲热讽的一个夏天。直到很久以后我才意识到，讽刺不过是弱者的抗议。”
…discussion, so it makes sense it is flagged quckly. >it was only a sarcastic couple of sentences Sarcasm is almost invariably worthless clutter, regardless of the subject of discussion. I always refer to A Separate Peace, "As I said, this was my sarcastic summer. It was only long after that I recognized sarcasm as the protest of people who are weak."
……补充：总的来说，我觉得自己没读过，但菲茨杰拉德和海明威的书作为高中英语课的读物似乎都挺合理的。说实话，大概率比《麦田里的守望者》和《独自和解》这种书更好。
…ADDED: In general, I don't think I read any, but both Fitzgerald and Hemingway seem pretty reasonable for a high school English class. Probably better choices than the like of Catcher in the Rye and A Separate Peace to be honest.
《独自和解》。哎呀，我是拿救济金的穷小子，我不小心把你这个富家子弟从树上推下去了！然后你就残废了！然后你就死了！《沃特希普荒原》。三个字：诡异兔子鬼。《老黄狗》。《杀死……
A Separate Peace. Oops, I'm the charity case and I accidentally pushed you, Rich Boy, out of a tree! And then you were crippled! AND THEN YOU DIED! Watership Down. Three words: creepy rabbit ghosts. Old Yeller. To Kill…
我的思维发散过程：从霍顿 ——> 霍顿·考尔菲德（《麦田里的守望者》）——> 对青春期有影响的书 ——> 《独自和解》——> 吉恩·福雷斯特 ——> 菲尼亚斯 ——> 芬尼 ——> uspto.gov ——> 实时商标查询 ——> Finnie ——> domai.nr ——> "phinn.ie" ——> 回到 uspto.gov ——> "phinnie" 挺不错……
My train of thought: From Holden --> Holden Caulfield (Catcher in the Rye) --> Books influential to adolescence --> A Separate Peace --> Gene Forrester --> Phineas --> Finny --> uspto.gov --> Live trademark search --> Finnie --> domai.nr --> "phinn.ie" --> back to uspto.gov --> "phinnie" is good…