谋杀历史
The killing of history
Keith Windschuttle · 初版 1994 年
2位读者提及
5次提及
两千五百年来，自 Herodotus 和 Thucydides 时代起，历史学家就一直致力于记录过去的真相。然而在今天，这一学科正遭受着来自一系列受法国思潮启发的文学与社会理论崛起的致命冲击，这些理论无一不在否定探寻过去的真相与知识的可能性。这些理论声称，历史赖以建立的核心支柱已不复存在：历史与神话、历史与虚构之间根本不存在本质区别。从伯克利到巴黎的课堂里，历史学家们纷纷接纳了这
Hacker News 上怎么说
正在加载完整评论……
多引用点福柯的《规训与惩罚》（Discipline & Punishment）吧。福柯的文风（可能是有意为之的）晦涩难懂，而且按照基思·温舒特尔（Keith Windschuttle）在《历史的谋杀》（The Killing of History，http://www.amazon.com/The-Killing-History-Theorists-Murderin... ）一书中的说法，福柯的历史知识充其量也就是半吊子水平。问题在于为什么我们大家都不加抵抗地由着这种事发生？因为这很轻松，因为大多数时候它并不影响……
quote more Foucault's Discipline & Punishment Foucault's style is (possibly deliberately) obtuse, and his knowledge of history dubious at best, per Keith Windschuttle's book The Killing of History: http://www.amazon.com/The-Killing-History-Theorists-Murderin... . It's the question of why we all let this happen without any resistance Because it's easy, because most of the time it doesn't affect…
……美国文化散论（American Culture: Essays）。第 1 版。纽约：Vintage，1992。福克，科林（Falck, Colin）。《神话、真理与文学：走向真正的后现代主义》（Myth, Truth and Literature: Towards a True Post-modernism）。第 2 版。纽约：剑桥大学出版社，1994。温舒特尔，基思（Windschuttle, Keith）。《历史的谋杀：文学评论家与社会理论家如何残杀我们的过去》（The Killing of History: How Literary Critics and Social Theorists are Murdering Our Past）。第 1 版 Free Press 版，1997 版。纽约：Free Press，1997。斯塔尔，亚历山大（Star, Alexander）。《快速研究：Lingua Franca 精选》（Quick Studies: The Best of Lingua Franca）。第 1 版。Farrar，……
…American Culture: Essays. 1 ed. New York: Vintage, 1992. Falck, Colin. Myth, Truth and Literature: Towards a True Post-modernism. 2 ed. New York: Cambridge University Press, 1994. Windschuttle, Keith. The Killing of History: How Literary Critics and Social Theorists are Murdering Our Past. 1st Free Press Ed., 1997 ed. New York: Free Press, 1997. Star, Alexander. Quick Studies: The Best of Lingua Franca. 1st ed. Farrar,…
>按照基思·温舒特尔在《历史的谋杀》一书中的说法，福柯的文风（可能是有意为之的）晦涩难懂，而且他的历史知识充其量也就是半吊子水平。这种批评根本不值一驳——基本上就是保守派在那儿哀嚎“哎呀，这帮新潮的左翼理论家把我们的领域全给毁了”。
>Foucault's style is (possibly deliberately) obtuse, and his knowledge of history dubious at best, per Keith Windschuttle's book The Killing of History That critique is not even worthy of an answer -- it's basically a conservative "oh, all these new fangled lefty theorists have ruined our field" cry.
……为了彰显现实意义而呼吁纯粹思辨是一回事，促成历史与哲学的全新结合又是另一回事。像基思·温舒特尔这样的作家早在《历史的谋杀》（The Killing of History）时期（甚至更早）就在讨论这些问题了，而卡米拉·帕格利亚（Camille Paglia）从 1990 年代起就在随笔里探讨它们了。最后，人文学科就业岗位的匮乏，不仅成了逆向智商测试，也成了顺从度测试，导致……
…thing to call for speculation for the sake of relevance, and another to bring about a new marriage of history and philosophy. writers like Keith Windschuttle have been discussing these problems since The Killing of History, if not earlier, and Camille Paglia has been discussing them in essays since the 1990s. Finally, the lack of jobs in the humanities has been acting as both a negative IQ test and a conformity test for…
……拜托了。这条评论真是笑死人了，福柯的《性史》里几乎连一条引用都没有！如果你想知道为什么福柯理应成为笑柄，去看看温舒特尔的《历史的谋杀》（The Killing of History，https://www.amazon.com/Killing-History-Literary-Theorists-Mu... ）或者卡米拉·帕格利亚写他的大量随笔吧。她的最新著作里就重印了《书评：垃圾债券与企业袭击者：学术界的……》（Review: Junk Bonds and Corporate Raiders: Academe in…）
…please This is a hilarious comment, given that Foucault's History of Sexuality contains almost no citations! If you are interested in why Foucault ought to be a laughingstock, see Windshuttle's The Killing of History: https://www.amazon.com/Killing-History-Literary-Theorists-Mu... or the many essays Camille Paglia wrote on him. Her latest book has a reprint of "Review: Junk Bonds and Corporate Raiders: Academe in…