创伤与复原
Trauma and Recovery
Judith Lewis Herman · 初版 1992 年
4人推荐
5位读者提及
5次提及
Trauma and Recovery 于1992年首次出版时，被誉为一部开创性巨作。在随后的岁月里，Herman 的这部著作改变了我们思考和对待创伤事件及创伤受害者的方式。在新的后记中，Herman 记录了该书引发的强烈反响，并解释了围绕该议题的讨论在临床领域以及更广泛的文化语境中发生的转变。Trauma and Recovery 为一系列通常被单独看待的问题带来了全新层面的认知。Herman 汲取了自己在家庭暴力领域的前沿研究成果
Hacker News 上怎么说
正在加载完整评论……
说句难听的，考虑到可复现性危机（replication crisis），我们真不需要在这上面添更多凭空捏造的瞎猜了。如果你真感兴趣，不妨去读读 Judith Herman 写的《Trauma and Recovery》。专门讲这类东西的硬核科学书。
Sorry to be harsh, but given the replication crisis, we really don't need more made-up guesses on this. If you are truly interested, try reading Trauma and Recovery by Judith Herman. Dense scientific book on just this type of thing.
> 水刑（waterboarding）、体温过低、濒临溺毙、心理折磨等 行行好去读读 Judith Herman 的书《Trauma and Recovery》吧。你很快就会明白为什么你那反直觉的观察完全是错的。这些手段在特种部队训练里能起作用，但在监狱和医院里绝对起不到那种作用，以后也永远不可能。
> waterboarding, hypothermia, near-drowning, psychological torutre, etc Do yourself a favor and read Judith Herman's book "Trauma and Recovery." You'll quickly understand why your counter-intuitive observation is simply wrong. These things work in special forces training in a way they never could and never will in prisons and hospitals.
Judith Lewis Herman 写的《Trauma and Recovery》是理解 CPTSD 的学术心理学标准参考书。它一本能顶 5000 本自我提升/自助类书（self help books）。
Trauma and Recovery by Judith Lewis Herman is the standard academic psychology reference text for understanding CPTSD. It is worth 5000 self help books.
…宣泄地。我能解释别人对我做过什么，但由于根深蒂固、由来已久的羞耻与恐惧，我根本感受不到它。我可以推荐：- Complex PTSD, Pete Walker - The Tao of Fully Feeling, Pete Walker - Trauma and Recovery, Judith Herman - The Drama of the Gifted Child, Alice Miller
…cathartically. I can explain what has been done to me, but I don't feel it out of deep seated, ancient, shame and fear. I can recommend: - Complex PTSD, Pete Walker - The Tao of Fully Feeling, Pete Walker - Trauma and Recovery, Judith Herman - The Drama of the Gifted Child, Alice Miller
…几乎任何人在恐惧和无助状态下待得足够久，都会产生创伤。具体要多久、怎么产生的以及为什么——我们现在的了解比过去多了，你也能查得到。Judith Herman 1992 年的《Trauma and Recovery》是该领域的奠基之作，塑造了我们今天对它的大部分认识。我们确切知道具体是哪些大脑区域和神经递质引发了特定效应吗？并不知道。TBKTS 确实做了一些探索…
…almost any human in a state of fear and helplessness long enough and they will develop trauma. Exactly how long, and how, and why — we know more than we did, and you can look it up. Judith Herman’s 1992 “Trauma and Recovery” is groundwork in the field, and responsible for much of our modern thought about it. Do we know exactly which brain regions and neurotransmitters give rise to specific effects? No. TBKTS does make forays…