While some may analyze beautiful literature into oblivion and I feel your pain, I can’t agree with you on Huck Finn. My interpretation of the intro you quoted is very different from yours. Mark Twain went out of his way to highlight barbaric racism on rubber plantations in the Congo by writing a satirical pamphlet…
The author already explained that the issue is that he is planning on quoting offensive language from Mark Twain's Huck Finn. If you aren't familiar, the text contains gratuitous use of the n-word. I can totally understand the worry about getting picked up by automated moderation and not being able to appeal successfully.…
…that language isn't ever intrinsically hateful; what's hateful is the intent with which humans sometimes use it. "Nigger" isn't hateful when Chris Rock uses it; arguably not when Mark Twain put it in Huck Finn either. That's one of the fascinating things about language: the minute you try to pin it down, new usages appear that escape your grasp. Often to comedic effect.
My experience with religion came via Mark Twain. "In high school or at some point in my high school years, I read Huck Finn. There was a part in the book where Huck has to save Jim and if he saves Jim, he knows the church has taught him that he will go Hell. Huck denies the teaching of the church and saves his friend." The…
People who are exposed to Mark Twain only through Tom Sawyer/Huck Finn/A Connecticut Yankee/etc. works usually think of him as a "fun" author. But he had one of the most incisive and intellectual minds of his times, which was biting in its criticisms/satire of American…
…racist, and if so that needs to be called out explicitly and discussed in the classroom. Here's a good essay on it: https://www.vqronline.org/essay/jim-and-mark-twain-what-do-d... > In the middle of Huck Finn, Mark Twain let Jim step out from behind the racist stereotype that has proven a lot harder to destroy than slavery. The effect of the ending, though, is to put him back in blackface so the whites of…
虽然有些人会把优美的文学作品过度分析到索然无味,我也理解你的痛苦,但在《哈克历险记》(Huck Finn)上我没法同意你的看法。我对你引用的那段开头的解读和你的截然不同。马克·吐温曾专门写过一本讽刺小册子来揭露刚果橡胶种植园里野蛮的种族主义……
While some may analyze beautiful literature into oblivion and I feel your pain, I can’t agree with you on Huck Finn. My interpretation of the intro you quoted is very different from yours. Mark Twain went out of his way to highlight barbaric racism on rubber plantations in the Congo by writing a satirical pamphlet…
作者已经解释过了,问题在于他打算引用马克·吐温《哈克历险记》(Huck Finn)里的冒犯性词汇。如果你不熟悉的话,原文里大量且毫无避讳地使用了 n-word。我完全能理解那种担心被自动化审核抓到而且申诉无门的顾虑。……
The author already explained that the issue is that he is planning on quoting offensive language from Mark Twain's Huck Finn. If you aren't familiar, the text contains gratuitous use of the n-word. I can totally understand the worry about getting picked up by automated moderation and not being able to appeal successfully.…
……语言本身从来就不是天生带恶意的;带恶意的是人类有时使用它时的意图。克里斯·洛克(Chris Rock)用“Nigger”这个词时并没有恶意;马克·吐温在《哈克历险记》(Huck Finn)里用它时,可以说同样也没有恶意。这也是语言的迷人之处之一:你一旦想把它框死,就会冒出脱离你掌控的新用法,往往还会产生喜剧效果。
…that language isn't ever intrinsically hateful; what's hateful is the intent with which humans sometimes use it. "Nigger" isn't hateful when Chris Rock uses it; arguably not when Mark Twain put it in Huck Finn either. That's one of the fascinating things about language: the minute you try to pin it down, new usages appear that escape your grasp. Often to comedic effect.
我对宗教的认知始于马克·吐温。“在高中或者高中前后的某个时候,我读了《哈克历险记》(Huck Finn)。书里有一段是哈克必须去救吉姆,而他知道教会教导过他,如果救了吉姆就会下地狱。哈克违背了教会的教条,救了他的朋友。”那……
My experience with religion came via Mark Twain. "In high school or at some point in my high school years, I read Huck Finn. There was a part in the book where Huck has to save Jim and if he saves Jim, he knows the church has taught him that he will go Hell. Huck denies the teaching of the church and saves his friend." The…
那些只通过《汤姆·索亚历险记》、《哈克历险记》(Huck Finn)、《康州美国佬》等作品了解马克·吐温的人,通常以为他就是个“风趣”的作家。但他其实拥有所处时代最敏锐、最深刻的头脑之一,对美国的批评和讽刺极为尖锐……
People who are exposed to Mark Twain only through Tom Sawyer/Huck Finn/A Connecticut Yankee/etc. works usually think of him as a "fun" author. But he had one of the most incisive and intellectual minds of his times, which was biting in its criticisms/satire of American…
……带有种族歧视,如果是这样,就需要在课堂上明确指出来并加以讨论。这里有一篇关于这个话题的好文章:https://www.vqronline.org/essay/jim-and-mark-twain-what-do-d... > 在《哈克历险记》(Huck Finn)中段,马克·吐温让吉姆走出了种族主义刻板印象的阴影,而事实证明这种刻板印象比奴隶制本身更难消除。然而结尾的效果,却是让他重新沦为了涂黑脸的滑稽角色,以便让白人……
…racist, and if so that needs to be called out explicitly and discussed in the classroom. Here's a good essay on it: https://www.vqronline.org/essay/jim-and-mark-twain-what-do-d... > In the middle of Huck Finn, Mark Twain let Jim step out from behind the racist stereotype that has proven a lot harder to destroy than slavery. The effect of the ending, though, is to put him back in blackface so the whites of…