活动的余地
Elbow room
Daniel C. Dennett · 初版 1984 年
3人推荐
4位读者提及
7次提及
在 Elbow Room 一书中，Dennett 展示了哲学中对该问题的经典表述是如何依赖于想象力的滥用，并将真正具有哲学探讨价值的问题从与其纠缠不清的“焦虑家族”中解脱出来——包括那些看似威胁到我们自由的虚构行动主体、假想敌和可怕前景。
Hacker News 上怎么说
正在加载完整评论……
Elbow room
Daniel C. Dennett · 初版 1984 年
在 Elbow Room 一书中，Dennett 展示了哲学中对该问题的经典表述是如何依赖于想象力的滥用，并将真正具有哲学探讨价值的问题从与其纠缠不清的“焦虑家族”中解脱出来——包括那些看似威胁到我们自由的虚构行动主体、假想敌和可怕前景。
正在加载完整评论……
如果有谁给我推荐 Harris 的书，我就会把 Dennett 对他那本书的书评甩回去：https://www.richardcarrier.info/archives/13814 另外还有《Elbow Room》，或者更好一些的《Freedom Evolves》。
I recommend Dennett's review of Harris's book to people who recommend it: https://www.richardcarrier.info/archives/13814 Also Elbow Room, or, better, Freedom Evolves.
…预判他人的行动，以及用我们巧妙的言语去操控其他主体的自由。Dan Dennett 对这一点的论证比我高明得多，请一定要去读读他在这个主题上的神作。Daniel Dennett：——《Elbow Room》——《Freedom Evolves》
…anticipate others' actions, the freedom to manipulate other agents with our clever words. Dan Dennett makes a better case for this than I, please look into his wonderful books on the topic. Daniel Dennett: --Elbow Room --Freedom Evolves
我推荐读读 Daniel Dennett 的《Elbow Room: the varieties of free will worth wanting》，这样能更好地把握“自由意志”到底可能意味着什么。
I recommend reading "Elbow Room: the varieties of free will worth wanting" by Daniel Dennett to get a better handle on what the term "free will" might actually mean.
在我看来，Dennett 在《Elbow Room: the varieties of free will worth wanting》里讲得更出色。
Dennett did better, IMO, in "Elbow Room: the varieties of free will worth wanting"
> 接下来的问题是：[ ... ] Dennett 在这方面也全给你考虑到了。他那本《Elbow Room: the varieties of free will worth wanting》是这个领域绝对的必读之作。
> The next question is: [ ... ] Dennett has you covered there too. His book "Elbow Room: the varieties of free will worth wanting" is a must-read on this topic.
我知道这里大多数人都觉得这些实验很荒谬，但像 Daniel Dennett（在《Elbow Room》里，不过我觉得他后来为了相容论/Compatibilist 观点撤回了这一说法）和 Richard Dawkins 这些人，普遍把该结果解读为决定论宇宙的“证据”。确实，一个决定论的宇宙（或者至少是…
I know most people here find these experiments absurd, but folks like Daniel Dennett (in Elbow Room, which I think he later retracts for a Compatibilist view) and Richard Dawkins have widely construed the result as "proof" of a deterministic universe. Indeed, a deterministic universe (or at least one…