智商与国民财富

Hacker News 上怎么说

• jensen123 · 2015 年

  ……当然也有白人。这意味着像种族隔离这种解决手段不仅简单粗暴，而且对这些高智商的黑人来说完全不公平。关于智商与种族这方面的更多信息，我推荐理查德·林恩和塔图·范哈宁合著的《智商与国民财富》（IQ and the Wealth of Nations）。

  …white individuals, of course. Which means that solutions like segregation/apartheid are ham-fisted and totally unfair to these high IQ blacks. For more info on the IQ and race thing, I recommend the book IQ and the Wealth of Nations by Richard Lynn and Tatu Vanhanen.

• rubashov · 2012 年

  ……以及在被评论的那本书里，很大程度上是为了反驳那些极具说服力且有数据支撑的优生学理论。基于优生学和智商的理论在政治上是不可接受的。《告别施舍》（A Farewell to Alms）和《智商与国民财富》（IQ and the Wealth of Nations）给出了非常令人信服且有扎实研究的案例，极好地解释了不同国家的经济状况。只是这些解释不够 PC 罢了。

  …and in the reviewed book, exist in large part to counter the highly convincing and data driven eugenic theories. The eugenic and IQ based theories are politically unacceptable. "A Farewell to Alms" and "IQ and the Wealth of Nations" lay out very convincing and heavily researched cases that explain different national economies very well. The explanations are just not PC.

• moldbug · 2012 年

  奥卡姆黄油刀（Occam's butterknife）又在野外现身了。理查德·林恩，快给你的办公室回个电话吧：http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/IQ_and_the_Wealth_of_Nations

  Once again Occam's butterknife is spotted in the wild. Richard Lynn, call your office: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/IQ_and_the_Wealth_of_Nations

• bjourne · 2018 年

  ……总是拿那个彻底被打脸的“智商地图”（https://iq-research.info/en/page/average-iq-by-country）当消息源。它是基于林恩和范哈宁随手捏造并写在他们《智商与国民财富》（IQ and the Wealth of Nations）一书里的数据。> 那黑人统治了大多数体育项目又怎么说？就算我们假设这是真的（其实并不是——2016年夏季奥运会共颁发了972枚奖牌，其中只有一小部分归属于（真的）……

  …always use the thoroughly debunked "IQ Map" (https://iq-research.info/en/page/average-iq-by-country) as their source. It is based on data fabricated by Lynn and Vanhanen and jotted down in their book IQ and the Wealth of Nations. > What about black people's domination of most sports? Even if we assume that is true (which it isn't -- 972 medals were awarded at the 2016 Summer Olympics and only a fraction of them went to (really)…

• jensen123 · 2016 年

  ……说“没有证据支持最顶尖的 1% 人群主要由‘天赋异禀’的人组成这一观点”。实际上，这方面是有一些证据的。不久前我读了理查德·林恩和塔图·范哈宁合著的《智商与国民财富》（IQ and the Wealth of Nations）。书中提到了几项关于智商与收入相关性的研究。如果我没记错的话，所有这些研究显示的相关性都在 0.3 到 0.4 之间。

  …says that "There is no evidence to support the idea that the top 1 percent consists mostly of people of "exceptional talent."" Actually, there is some evidence for this. A while ago, I read the book IQ and the Wealth of Nations by Richard Lynn and Tatu Vanhanen. It mentions a few studies looking at the correlation between IQ and income. If I remember correctly, the correlation was 0.3 to 0.4 in all of the studies.

• tptacek · 2026 年

  ……按纬度的智商调查。看 HN 的人里极少有人被要求做过智商测试，更别说被强制做了。把“智商”按国家来归纳的数据基本都是造假的（比如理查德·林恩在《智商与国民财富》里的那些数据）。除了那一点，我没做其他任何断言：根本不存在所谓的“国民平均智商”。如果你声称有某种非“国家”维度的“平均智商”，那你……

  …latitudinal IQ surveys. Very few people reading HN have ever been asked to take an IQ test, let alone compelled to do so. Numbers attributing "IQ" to countries are generally fraudulent (i.e., Richard Lynn's "IQ And The Wealth Of Nations" numbers). I'm not making any other claim than that specific one: there is no such thing as "national IQ averages". If you claim there's some other kind of "IQ average" that isn't "national", you're…

正在加载完整评论……