文明及其不满
Civilization and Its Discontents
Sigmund Freud、Coralie Bickford-Smith · 初版 1930 年
8人推荐
24位读者提及
28次提及
为什么值得读
- 悲观且深刻地解释人类本能冲动与文明的冲突
- 揭示彻底破坏社会规则体系后带来的悲惨结果
- 提供理解后世诸多哲学与社会批判理论的基础
Hacker News 上怎么说
正在加载完整评论……
Civilization and Its Discontents
Sigmund Freud、Coralie Bickford-Smith · 初版 1930 年
正在加载完整评论……
…什么都不用付。我算不上富人，但我很乐意纳税。我固然希望能少交点，这也是我投票的原因。如果你想把这一切全砸烂，那我觉得弗洛伊德的《文明及其不满》（Civilization and Its Discontents）就是最好的反驳。在那种世界里我个人甚至可能获利，但从系统层面来看，生活在那种世界里总体是极其悲惨的。还是老老实实交税好。
…without paying anything. I am hardly rich but I gladly pay taxes. I would prefer to pay less but that is the reason I vote. If you want to blow it all up then I think the counter to that is Freud's Civilization and Its Discontents. I even might gain personally in that world but overall it is a miserable world to live at the systems level. It is better to just pay taxes.
…做的是读了尼采的《论道德的谱系》。然后是福柯的《规训与惩罚》。再然后是德勒兹。如果要真正读懂《反俄狄浦斯》，我对弗洛伊德的阅读量还远远不够，但《文明及其不满》（Civilization and Its Discontents）很值得一读。马克思也是如此，很多人都不同意他，但大家又都默认你对他有一定了解。其实，你最好的做法正如马苏米谈到《千高原》时所说，“把它当成唱片来听”：…
…did was read On the Genealogy of Morals by Nietzsche. Then Discipline and Punish by Foucault. Then the Deleuze. I am less well read with Freud than I should be to truly engage with Anti-Oedipus, but Civilization and its Discontents is worthwhile. Same with Marx, many many disagree, but all assume some level of familiarity. Really, the best you can do is exactly what Massumi says about A Thousand Plateaus and "read it like a record":…
米歇尔·福柯的《性史：第一卷》、米歇尔·福柯的《规训与惩罚》、乔治·莱考夫的《肉身哲学》、乔治·莱考夫的《我们赖以生存的隐喻》、西格蒙德·弗洛伊德的《文明及其不满》。这些书彻底改变了我看待现实的视角。
"History of Sexuality: Volume I" -Michel Foucault "Discipline and Punish" -Michel Foucault "Philosophy in the Flesh" -George Lakoff "Metaphors We Live By" -George Lakoff "Civilization and its Discontents" -Sigmund Freud These books allowed me to look at reality in a completely different manner.
…生理驱动力或本能。这就是为什么女权主义者说我们存在“强奸文化”，并且认为只要纠正了文化，所有的强奸和暴力就会消失。弗洛伊德要悲观得多。《文明及其不满》（Civilization and Its Discontents）很好地总结了其中的缘由。
…biological drives or instincts. This is why feminists say we have a "Rape Culture," and that all we have to do is fix culture, then all rape and violence will disappear. Freud was much more pessimistic. "Civilization and Its Discontents" is a good summary of why.
《分裂的自我》+《经验的政治与天堂之鸟》+《家庭的政治》——全都是 R·D·莱茵的作品；《文明及其不满》——弗洛伊德；《资本主义现实主义》——马克·费舍尔；《无门关》——无门？一部非常古老的中国神秘主义典籍，不知怎的让我深有共鸣.. 《神经漫游者》（Neuromancer）——威廉·吉布森；《雪崩》（Snow Crash）——尼尔·斯蒂芬森…
The Divided Self + The Politics of Experience and the Bird of Paradise + The Politics of the Family - all by RD Laing Civilization and its Discontents - Freud Capitalist Realism - Mark Fisher Gateless Gate - Mu-men? Very old Chinese mystical text that somehow resonated w me considerably.. Neuromancer - William Gibson Snowcrash - Neal Stephenson…
弗洛伊德的《文明及其不满》、玛丽·雪莱的《科学怪人》、奥斯卡·王尔德的《道林·格雷的画像》
“Civilization and its Discontents” by Freud “Frankenstein” by Mary Shelly “Picture of Dorian Gray” by Oscar Wilde