哈里森·伯杰龙
Harrison Bergeron
Kurt Vonnegut · 初版 1961 年
27人推荐
117位读者提及
126次提及
为什么值得读
- 篇幅短小精悍且发人深省
- 揭示强求结果平等反致压抑卓越的荒诞
- 是探讨社会公平与平均主义的必读科幻
故事发生在 2053 年。第二次美国革命取得了胜利，平等终于得以实现——方式是让全体国民都变得平庸！每个人都是普通人——唯独 Harrison Bergeron 例外。这位无可救药地聪颖的年轻人注定要接受脑部手术以纠正他超凡的智力——直到他策划了一项通过第三次美国革命解放人民的计划。但是改变世界总会面临一个问题……世界本身可能并不想被改变。
Hacker News 上怎么说
正在加载完整评论……
……类型以及出生顺序，平均而言都不会带来完全相同的结果。而这些结果上的差异本身并非不公，只是单纯的相关性，因此并不需要去强行纠正。直接去读冯内古特的《Harrison Bergeron》吧，篇幅不长。
…types, and sibling orders on average don't have identical outcomes. And these differences in outcome by themselves are not unjust, are mere correlations, and therefore do not require fixing. Just read Harrison Bergeron by Vonnegut; it's not long.
……聪明人因为在学校里受到的关注较少就受委屈了吗？我觉得并没有。结合你整篇帖子的内容，你可能会想读读已故伟大作家 Kurt Vonnegut 写的这版乌托邦，篇名叫《Harrison Bergeron》：http://www.nationalreview.com/nroriginals/?q=MDllNmVmNGU1NDV...
…smart person slighted by getting less attention in school? I would argue no. Taking your whole post into account, you might like to read this version of utopia by the late great Kurt Vonnegut titled "Harrison Bergeron": http://www.nationalreview.com/nroriginals/?q=MDllNmVmNGU1NDV...
……公平只能通过把所有人拉低、而不是鼓励他们发挥所长来实现。任何想在生活方方面面追求普世公平和绝对结果平等的人，都应该把 Kurt Vonnegut 的《Harrison Bergeron》读上几遍，直到转变这种心态为止。http://www.tnellen.com/cybereng/harrison.html “那是一年2081年，所有人终于平等了。他们不仅在上帝和法律面前人人平等。他们……
…fairness can only work by lowering people rather than by promoting them doing what they are best at. Anyone seeking universal fairness & equal outcomes in all aspects of life should read Kurt Vonnegut's Harrison Bergeron as many times as required to change that mindset. http://www.tnellen.com/cybereng/harrison.html "THE YEAR WAS 2081, and everybody was finally equal. They weren't only equal before God and the law. They…
注意到这一点的绝不止你一个人。我想你会对 Kurt Vonnegut 写的《Harrison Bergeron》[1] 感兴趣，这是一篇与该话题相关的非常棒的短篇小说。[1]: https://www.cvccworks.edu/Downloads/HarrisonBergeronByKurtVo...
You’re not the only one who notices this. I think you would be interested in Harrison Bergeron by Kurt Vonnegut [1], a great short story related to this topic. [1]: https://www.cvccworks.edu/Downloads/HarrisonBergeronByKurtVo...
聊到这些话题必读的经典科幻：Henry Slesar 的《Examination Day》http://www.thebostonbachelor.com/2008/examination-day-by-hen...，Kurt Vonnegut 的《Harrison Bergeron》http://www.tnellen.com/cybereng/harrison.html
Obligatory canonical SciFi on these matters: 'Examination Day', Henry Slesar http://www.thebostonbachelor.com/2008/examination-day-by-hen... 'Harrison Bergeron', Kurt Vonnegut http://www.tnellen.com/cybereng/harrison.html
完全赞同。我也是大概在那个年纪读到这个故事的，至今依然记忆犹新、感触颇深。另一篇让我终生难忘的科幻短篇是 Kurt Vonnegut Jr. 的《Harrison Bergeron》。主题虽不相同，但同样用极精练的文字带来了直击人心的力量。
Completely agree. I too, discovered this story around that age, and I have always remembered it with clarity and passion. The other scifi short story I will never forget is Harrison Bergeron by Kurt Vonnegut Jr. Not the same topic, but the same sort of punch in very few words.