没有设计的秩序
Order without Design
Alain Bertaud · 初版 2018 年
6人推荐
10位读者提及
13次提及
为什么值得读
- 将城市规划概念与市场经济逻辑完美融合
- 指出城市实质是权衡地理约束的就业市场
- 为城市规划从业者提供正确履职的方法指南
“本书源自作者55年的城市规划职业生涯，并结合了其真实的实践经验。如果不了解市场如何运作，城市规划者很可能会设计出对城市运转产生负面影响的基础设施和法规。相比之下，城市经济学家往往在事后审视决策和结果，并将结论发表在未能对决策产生实际影响的专业期刊上。本书呼吁定性的城市规划者与定量的城市经济学家走到一起。具体而言，本书呼吁城市经……
Hacker News 上怎么说
正在加载完整评论……
关于这个话题最让人眼前一亮的书之一是 Alain Bertaud 的《Order without Design》。本质上，城市的存在完全就是一个个就业市场——个人在其中做权衡取舍以应对地理上的限制。看看居家办公（WFH）的转变会不会改变这一点，倒挺有意思的……
One of the most eye opening books on this topic was "Order without Design" by Alain Bertaud. Essentially, cities exist entirely as job markets - where individuals make tradeoffs to handle geographic constraints. It will be interesting to see if the WFH shift changes this…
太棒了！又碰上一位土地利用问题的同好！Alain Bertaud 写过一本叫《Order without Design》的书。他是一位城市经济学家，而且……城市规划师要把工作做好，读他这本书就够了。在书的结尾部分他谈到了印尼的甘榜（Kampung），在这次访谈里也略有提及……
Huzzah! Another aficionado of land use issues! Alain Bertaud wrote a book called "order without design". He's an urban economist, and... his book is all a city planner needs to do their job correctly. Towards the end of the book he talks about the indonesian Kampung, briefly touched upon in this interview…
手头正在啃 Alain Bertaud 的《Order Without Design: How Markets Shape Cities》[1]，事实证明，要想理解这类问题，并且在这个过程中把一堆城市规划概念融会贯通，这本书真是极好的资源……
Working my way through Alain Bertaud's Order Without Design: How Markets Shape Cities[1] at the moment and it's proving to be a really great resource for understanding this kind of thing and in the process marrying together a bunch of urban planning concepts and…
Devon Zuegel 在很多领域都是位很有见地的思考者 -> 城市规划方面：她的播客《Order without Design》[0]，里面采访了 Bertaud 夫妇；关于迈阿密的实地考察笔记 [1]（配图很美）；关于城市的 Metamuse 访谈 [2]，她的博客上还有更多。技术方面：她曾是 Github Sponsors 的 PM……
Devon Zuegel is a great thinker in a large breath of subjects -> On Urbanism: Her podcast Order without Design [0] where she interviews the Bertaud couple Fields note on Miami [1] (with beautiful pictures) Metamuse interview on cities [2] and a lot more on her blog On tech : She was the PM for Github sponsors…
……我们现在喜爱的老城区最初到底是怎么建起来的。以前是个人在相对较小的地块上建自己的房子，而不是像现在这样由开发商包揽整个街区。我推荐《Order Without Design》这本书以及/或者它的配套播客，里面有非常深刻的见解：https://mitpress.mit.edu/books/order-without-design
…parts of older cities that we now love were build in the first place. Individuals build their buildings on fairly small lots, we didn't have developers build entire neighborhoods. I recommend the book Order Without Design and/or its corresponding podcast for great insights: https://mitpress.mit.edu/books/order-without-design
……我们对城市的思考方式是错的。城市不像巨型建筑，反而更像有机体。如果我们允许它们在一定程度上自发生长，效果反而是最好的。我推荐《Order Without Design: How Markets Shape Cities》这本书，或者同名的短播客。
…we are thinking wrong about cities. Cities aren't like massive buildings, but more like organisms. Three best results are achieved if we allow them to grow somewhat organically. I recommend the book Order Without Design: How Markets Shape Cities or the short podcast of the same name.