警察的终结
The End of Policing
Alex S. Vitale、Alex Vitale · 初版 2017 年
8人推荐
10位读者提及
13次提及
为什么值得读
- 论证社会救助相比惩罚机制成本更低更有效
- 剖析社会底线缺失如何导致对暴力的依赖
- 提供了审视执法机构的左翼批判性视角
警察如何危及我们的安全，以及为什么我们需要寻找替代方案。近年来，抗议警察暴行和镇压的呼声与关注呈爆发式增长——特别是在迈克尔·布朗遭警察枪杀后，密苏里州弗格森市积压已久的不满爆发为长达数月的暴力抗议。许多讨论都集中在呼吁加强警察问责制、提高警察多元化、改进警察培训以及强调社区警务上。遗憾的是，这些措施都不太可能取得成效，因为它们未能触及问题的核心。这
Hacker News 上怎么说
正在加载完整评论……
……已经觉得它是个败笔了）。这本书让我彻底相信，对整个社会来说，花钱去帮人，绝对比养着现在这套惩罚性的体制要划算得多。[0]《The End of Policing》，Alex S. Vitale 著，第 97 页 ^^ 这本书棒极了。我已经买了三本送给身边的亲近之人，我觉得他们应该能听得进书里的观点。
…already think it's a failure). The book has me convinced that it's cheaper for society, overall, to just pay to help people rather than funding the punitive system that's currently in place. [0] The End of Policing, by Alex S. Vitale pg 97 ^^ This book is excellent. I've already bought copies for three people who are close to me who I think will be open to its message.
Verso 同时也把 Alex Vitale 的神作《The End of Policing》电子书放免费了：https://www.versobooks.com/books/2426-the-end-of-policing 一句话总结（TLDR）：任何拒绝给民众提供社会民主托底保障的社会，都会越来越依赖暴力来维持其社会……
Verso has also made the ebook edition of Alex Vitale’s excellent “The End of Policing” free: https://www.versobooks.com/books/2426-the-end-of-policing TLDR: any society which refuses to provide social democratic floors to people will increasingly rely on violence to maintain its social…
顺便跑个题：Alex S. Vitale 的书《The End of Policing》目前在 Verso 可以免费领电子版：https://www.versobooks.com/books/2817-the-end-of-policing 值得一读，可以用来了解左翼对警察制度的看法。大概会有一些让人大开眼界的……
Tangentially related: Alex S. Vitale's book "The End of Policing" is currently free in e-book from Verso: https://www.versobooks.com/books/2817-the-end-of-policing Worth reading to familiarize oneself with leftist views on institution of Policing. Likely some eye-opening…
我推荐一本很赞的书，叫《The End of Policing》，作者是 Alex Vitale。我从头到尾读过好多次了，里面有些独到见解你应该会喜欢。
I’d suggest a wonderful book called The End of Policing by Alex Vitale. I’ve read it cover to cover many times and it may include some insight that you’d enjoy.
现在读 Vitale 的《End of Policing》一点也不算过时，乔治·弗洛伊德事件那会儿它可是大热门，而且到现在依然切中要害。
It's not too soon to read Vitale's "End of Policing," which was a hot read during George Floyd, and has not grown less relevant.
……同样担忧监控国家。不过我并不觉得你真懂这种担忧，因为把哪怕是自发秩序下警察带来的系统性压迫轻描淡写成“过度执法”，根本就是隔靴搔痒。你看过《The End of Policing》或者《The New Jim Crow》没有，或者哪怕看过纪录片《13th》吗？> 讨论中的这项技术能够挽救某些东西 也许可以，但别的东西说不定也行啊。而且成本更低，也没那么多束缚。……
…share the fears of a surveillance state. I'm not convinced you do, as "over-enforcement" is a totally inadequate term for the extant systemic oppression even organic policing imposes. Have you read The End of Policing, yet, or The New Jim Crow, or even watched the documentary 13th? > the technology in question can save something Maybe it can, but maybe so can something else. Something less costly, less constricting.…