黑色红脖子与白人自由派
Black Rednecks And White Liberals
Thomas Sowell · 初版 2005 年
14人推荐
18位读者提及
22次提及
为什么值得读
- 跳出种族主义和先天基因差异来解释族群差距
- 批评白人自由派的过度干预反而恶化少数群体处境
- 结合跨文化历史事实深入探讨奴隶制演变
在一系列长篇随笔中，Black Rednecks and White Liberals 深入探讨了诸多长期普遍存在的关于黑人、犹太人、德国人、奴隶制以及教育的固有假设。全书文字质朴明晰，论证强劲有力，并有令人惊叹的大量文献事实佐证；Black Rednecks and White Liberals 不仅对当代炙手可热的知识分子发起论战，也直面了 Alexis de Tocqueville 和 Frederick Law Olmsted 等美国历史维度的解读大家。Black Rednecks and White Liberals 巧妙地挑战教条，打破了长期附着于
Hacker News 上怎么说
正在加载完整评论……
……“性别科学”，尤其是在高税收国家。压根没人敢去质疑它，而且这还是能名正言顺挪用工薪阶层收入的“崇高”事业。我偏唱个反调，推荐大家去读托马斯·索维尔的《黑人红脖子与白人自由派》。
…"gender-science", especially in tax-heavy countries. No one ever dares to question it, and it's "good" causes that could use some of the workers income. I'll be contrarian and recommend Thomas Sowell's "Black Rednecks and White Liberals" instead.
……从他们那些想当然、信息闭塞的同龄人那里道听途说，而且对历史其实也没多大兴趣。托马斯·索维尔作为一名黑人，在《黑人红脖子与白人自由派》中对这些人物给出了一些非常耐人寻味的历史视角，很值得一读。这不过是随便 Google 搜出的一小段摘录，光靠它本身肯定没法直接回应大家试图抹去的一切，但可以作为一个倾听更多声音、拓宽……的起点。
…learning from their assumptive misinformed peers and that there isn't necessarily an interest in the history. Thomas Sowell, a black man, had some interesting historical perspectives on these figures in Black Rednecks and White Liberals, which is worth a read. This is just a small excerpt from a google search, and in itself can't directly address everything people are trying to erase, but it's a starter for listening to more and broadening…
古往今来，几乎所有社会直到两三百年前都存在奴隶制，包括尼日利亚在内 https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Slavery_in_Nigeria 了解更多可以去看托马斯·索维尔写的《黑人红脖子与白人自由派》（顺便说一句，托马斯·索维尔是一位非裔美国经济学教授兼作家，写给在座那些按肤色或族裔来决定一本书值不值得读的……
Slavery has occurred in almost every society over the years, until the last two or three hundred years, including in Nigeria https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Slavery_in_Nigeria See "Black rednecks and white liberals" by thomas sowell for more info (Thomas sowell is a black american economics professor and writer, for any in the audience who decide what is worth reading based on the skin color or ethnicity of the…
……小军队的政府。> 以及把穷人和少数族裔压制在社会底层。左派总觉得自己才是拯救穷人和少数族裔的正义化身。我建议读读托马斯·索维尔在《黑人红脖子与白人自由派》里的第一篇文章。他极力主张，那些自诩为“白人救世主”的自由派，反而让少数族裔的处境比起他们从不插手时糟糕得多。正如索维尔经常强调的那样，结果才重要……
…government with a small military. > And keeping the poors and minorities in their places. The left wish they were the righteous ones helping the poor and minorities. I'd suggest reading the first essay in "Black Rednecks and White Liberals" by Thomas Sowell. He argues strongly that the "white saviours" that are liberals have made the plight of minorities far worse than had they never intervened. As Sowell often emphasizes, results matter…
……包装成意识形态的宗教信仰。> 难道我们能用先天差异来解释吗？你能找到十亿种不同的解释方式。问题在于：谁是对的，你又该如何证明？去读读索维尔的《黑人红脖子与白人自由派》，顺便把《知识分子与种族》也看了。你会发现大量跟种族主义或先天基因差异完全不沾边的解释。反而是 CRT 的支持者们……
…religious beliefs packaged into an ideology. > Can we explain it by intrinsic differences? You can explain it a billion different ways. The question is: who is right, and how do you prove it? Read "Black Rednecks and White Liberals" by Sowell, and "Intellectuals and Race" while you're at it. You'll find plenty of explanations that have nothing to do with either racism or of innate genetic differences. It is proponents of CRT who…
……特别是在南部铁锈地带，那里天主教后裔通常是中产阶级，而乡巴佬/红脖子则是以前的工厂工人。想了解详情的话，我推荐阅读《乡下人的悲歌》、托马斯·索维尔的《黑人红脖子与白人自由派》，当然还有《阿尔比恩的种子》。吉姆·韦布在当选国会议员前也写过一些关于这个主题的文章；他曾计划把乡巴佬和黑人群体联合成一个单一利益集团，……
…particularly in the southern Rust Belt, where it's common for Catholic ethnics to be the middle class and hillbillies/rednecks the former factory hands. I'd recommend reading _Hillbilly Elgy_, Thomas Sowell's _Black Rednecks and White Liberals_, and of course _Albion's Seed_ for details. Jim Webb also had some essays on this subject, before he was elected to Congress; he had plans to unite hillbillies and blacks as a single interest group,…