观念的冲突
A conflict of visions
Thomas Sowell · 初版 1987 年
18人推荐
23位读者提及
34次提及
为什么值得读
- 提出对人性的不同预设导致观念冲突
- 解释了为何聪明人在政治上有根本分歧
- 思维清晰且逻辑论述深刻透彻
政治上的争议由诸多因素引发，但跨越数代甚至数百年的冲突却呈现出惊人一致的模式。本书认为，过去两个世纪以来旷日持久的政治争论反映了人们对人性本质截然不同的预设前提。在不同的人性愿景语境下，“自由”、“平等”、“权利”和“权力”等词汇的意义有着天壤之别。从刑事司法、收入分配到战争与和平等各类议题，反复表明持有某种愿景的人会站在这边，而持有
Hacker News 上怎么说
正在加载完整评论……
> 他在很多话题上确实采取了保守立场……颇具讽刺意味的是，索维尔的书《观念的冲突：政治斗争的意识形态根源》（A Conflict of Visions: Ideological Origins of Political Struggles）[1]是一个非常好的切入点，能帮人理解到底是什么让索维尔成了“保守派”（受限视野 Constrained Vision）而不是“进步派”（非受限…
> He does take a conservative approach to a lot of topics... Sowell's book A Conflict of Visions: Idealogical Origins of Political Struggles [1] is, ironically, a very good starting point in understanding what makes Sowell "conservative" (the Constrained Vision) vs "progressive" (the Unconstrained…
……但这仍然是一个一维变量（它其实没有很多人愿意相信的那么复杂）。关于它究竟是什么以及为什么在历史上反复出现，最好的解释出自托马斯·索维尔的《观念的冲突》（Conflict of Visions）。我在这里做个核心观点概括：红蓝阵营分歧归根结底是对人性跨度/可能性的分歧。所有人都会对人性产生直觉上的信念，仅仅…
…but it's still a single dimension variable (there is less complexity to it than lots of people like to believe). The best explanation for what it truly is and why it occurs throughout history is in "Conflict of Visions" by Thomas Sowell. I'll give a précis of the argument here: The red/blue divide is ultimately a disagreement over the span of human nature. All humans develop intuitive beliefs about human nature merely…
托马斯·索维尔的《观念的冲突》（A Conflict of Visions）。不管你怎么看索维尔的政治立场，这都是一本好书。
A Conflict of Visions, Thomas Sowell. A good book regardless of what you think of Sowell’s politics.
……人们在道德和智力潜能上的差异程度，在基本上任何民主社会中都是区分左右翼政治的决定性分水岭。去读读托马斯·索维尔的《观念的冲突》（A Conflict of Visions）吧，里面非常深刻地分析了为什么会这样。这绝非什么让人匪夷所思的事，不同的人对普通人的能力有不同的直觉认知，这完全在情理之中。
…extent to which people differ in their moral and intellectual potential is the defining difference that creates right wing vs left wing politics in basically any democratic society. Read Thomas Sowell's "A Conflict of Visions" to get a very insightful analysis of why this is so. Far from being mind boggling, it's entirely expected that different people have different intuitions about the capability of the average person.
……当我开始更深入地思考这些问题时，它们被认为是开创性的著作，在我看来，研究政治和经济理论问题时绝不应该错过。托马斯·索维尔的《观念的冲突》（A Conflict of Visions）进一步反思了这个议题，并就为什么聪明人最终会在如此根本的问题上产生分歧得出了一些结论。我觉得索维尔的思路和文笔非常清晰且…
…me when I started to think about these issues more deeply and they are considered seminal works that in my opinion shouldn't be skipped while studying the questions of political and economic theory. A Conflict of Visions by Thomas Sowell further reflects on this question and makes some conclusions about why smart people end up disagreeing in such fundamental ways. I find Sowell's thinking and writing to be clear and well…
托马斯·索维尔的《观念的冲突》（A Conflict of Visions）。http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/A_Conflict_of_Visions http://www.amazon.com/Conflict-Visions-Ideological-Political... 读起来真的很棒，虽然稍微有点长。但这可能是因为…
A Conflict of Visions by Thomas Sowell. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/A_Conflict_of_Visions http://www.amazon.com/Conflict-Visions-Ideological-Political... Really good read, though a bit longish. But that could be due to the…