斯大林格勒
Stalingrad
Antony Beevor · 初版 1998 年
10人推荐
14位读者提及
16次提及
为什么值得读
- 信息密度远超纪录片能带来全方位的理解
- 直击灵魂深处并改变读者对社会与人性的看法
- 文字极具沉浸感且促使读者多次反复研读
这部扣人心弦的历史著作是对那场扭转二战战局的战役的权威记载，生动再现了双方士兵在非人道环境下浴血搏杀的真实经历，以及身陷城市战场中的平民的苦难惨状。
Hacker News 上怎么说
正在加载完整评论……
Stalingrad
Antony Beevor · 初版 1998 年
这部扣人心弦的历史著作是对那场扭转二战战局的战役的权威记载，生动再现了双方士兵在非人道环境下浴血搏杀的真实经历，以及身陷城市战场中的平民的苦难惨状。
正在加载完整评论……
是的，我睡前至少花一个小时看书。我一本虚构、一本非虚构交替着读。其实我刚看完最新的《飓光志》（Stormlight）那本，非常喜欢。目前正在重温 Anthony Beevor 的《斯大林格勒》（Stalingrad）。
Yes, I spend at least the last hour before bed reading. I alternate every other book fiction and non-fiction. I actually just finished the latest Stormlight book and loved it. Currently re-reading Stalingrad by Anthony Beevor.
……不受干扰地深入你感兴趣的领域，而网上的内容都是专门针对短暂的注意力和打广告做优化的。比如，你可以花一个小时看一部关于斯大林格勒战役的纪录片；或者，你可以花一个小时读 Beevor 的《斯大林格勒》，能学到50倍的内容，而且理解深度完全不可同日而语。如果你还想了解得更多，可以去啃 Glantz 的三部曲……
…subject your interested in without distractions, while online content is optimized for short attention span and serving ads. For example, you can spend an hour watching a documentary on the battle of Stalingrad. Or, you can spend an hour reading Beevor's "Stalingrad" and learn 50 times as much, and you'll gain a far greater understanding of it. If you want to learn even more, you can dive into Glantz's trilogy…
赞同，好书。如果你还没读过 Anthony Beevor 的《斯大林格勒》，作为一部“非虚构”视角的书，我也强烈推荐。我估计他肯定深受格罗斯曼（Grossman）的影响。
Agreed, great book. If you haven't read Anthony Beevor's Stalingrad as a 'non-fiction' take I can also highly recommend. I presume he must have been heavily influenced by Grossman.
给 Beevor 的《斯大林格勒》+1。一本直击灵魂的书。它改变了我对官僚体系、社会以及人性的看法。
+1 for Stalingrad by Beevor A soul shaking book. It changed my outlook on bureaucracy/society/humanity.
Stephen Bungay 的《最危险的敌人》（Most Dangerous Enemy）：对不列颠空战极佳的修正主义视角记述。Anthony Beevor 的《斯大林格勒》。Anthony Beevor 的《柏林沦陷一九四五》（Downfall: Berlin 1945）。T.N. DuPuy 的《作战天才》（A Genius for War）：解释了德军为什么更出色以及如何做到。冯·曼施坦因的《失去的胜利》（Lost Victories）：挥镰行动（sickleschnitt）策划者的内部回忆录，……
Stephen Bungay, Most Dangerous Enemy: excellent revisionist account of the Battle of Britain. Anthony Beevor, Stalingrad Anthony Beevor, Downfall: Berlin 1945 TN DuPuy, A Genius for War: explains how and why the German army was better Von Manstein, Lost Victories: inside account by the author of the sickleschnitt, the…
……《纽约书评》。一部小经典。我算不上什么狂热军事迷，但我很推荐 Antony Beevor。虽然他的书有时候会沦为坦克和部队调动那种让人疲惫、没完没了的细节复盘，但《斯大林格勒》和《柏林沦陷》[3] 两本都非常引人入胜，单凭他重现那个时代和场景的能力就值了。《第三帝国内幕》也同样有意思，尽管大家都知道它的叙事带有粉饰色彩。我还……
…NYRB. A minor classic. I'm not a war buff by any stretch, but I can recommend Antony Beevor. Sometimes his books devolve into exhausting, never-ending play-by-plays of tank and troop movements, but both Stalingrad and The Fall of Berlin [3] and were fascinating just for his ability to conjure up the time and place. Inside the Third Reich was similarly interesting, even it's known to be a flawed narrative. I also…