男子气概的形成
Manhood in the Making
David D. Gilmore · 初版 1990 年
3人推荐
3位读者提及
4次提及
探讨“在世界各地不同文化中，‘成为一个男人’意味着什么？”这一问题。一项将男子气概视为一种后天获得地位的跨文化研究。
Hacker News 上怎么说
正在加载完整评论……
Manhood in the Making
David D. Gilmore · 初版 1990 年
探讨“在世界各地不同文化中，‘成为一个男人’意味着什么？”这一问题。一项将男子气概视为一种后天获得地位的跨文化研究。
正在加载完整评论……
感谢反馈！3Ps 模型出自 Gilmore 1991 年的书《Manhood in the Making: Cultural Concepts of Masculinity》。这本书读起来挺硬核，而且研究非常扎实。3Ps 来自于对男性荣誉及其文化的研究，以及它们是如何交织在一起的。极少数社会……
Thanks for the feedback! The 3Ps model comes from Gilmore's 1991 book Manhood in the Making: Cultural Concepts of Masculinity. It's a dense read and very well researched. The 3Ps comes out of the studies on male honor and that culture and how they are all linked together. Very few societies…
……数量的男性，Reeves 也做不到。部分原因是他想让男人变得更像女人，普通大老爷们对这种设想永远不会买账。他引用了 David Gilmore 那本非常有意思的书《Manhood in the Making》，该书是一项人类学调查，探讨了全球各地的多元文化是如何将男子气概定义为一种立足于发挥男性长处、而非贬低其特质的独特身份认同。……
…number of men, and neither will Reeves. In part, this is because he wants men to become more like women, a project that will never appeal to ordinary guys. He cites David Gilmore’s very interesting book Manhood in the Making, which is an anthropological survey of how a diverse set of cultures around the world have defined manhood as a distinctive identity that builds on men’s strengths rather than seeks to minimize them.…
David D. Gilmore 的《Manhood in the Making: Cultural Concepts of Masculinity》深入探讨了跨文化的男子气概概念。它非常通俗易懂，又深度剖析了究竟是什么跨越文化和时代定义了男子气概。……
Manhood in the Making: Cultural Concepts of Masculinity by David D. Gilmore goes into the pan-cultural concepts of masculinity. It's a very approachable and deep dive into what defines masculinity across cultures and times.…
……回答你的疑问并回应你的评论：——简而言之：可能永远不会。3Ps 理论在学术界男性主义研究中已经非常成熟了。如果你想深入了解，Gilmore 1991 年的书《Manhood in the Making: Cultural Concepts of Masculinity》对 3Ps 做了很好的概述。简单概括就是，所有男性都顺从这些 P 才能参与到男性荣誉体系中。没错，很多男性并不遵守，但他们就会失去荣誉，因此……
…answer your ?s and speak to your comment: - Short answer: Probably never. The 3Ps theory is well established in academic masculinist studies. A good overview of the 3Ps comes from Gilmore's 1991 book Manhood in the Making: Cultural Concepts of Masculinity if you want to learn more. Very briefly, all males conform to these Ps to participate in male honor. Yes, many males do not, but they are then without honor, and therefore…