与敌赛跑
Racing the enemy
Tsuyoshi Hasegawa · 初版 2005 年
1人推荐
4位读者提及
6次提及
作为第一部关于太平洋二战终局的跨国史著作——也是唯一一部全面整合了美国、苏联和日本角色的书籍——Tsuyoshi Hasegawa 追溯了错综复杂的外交与军事残局，打破了关于日本投降的传统定论。——封底折页。
Hacker News 上怎么说
正在加载完整评论……
Racing the enemy
Tsuyoshi Hasegawa · 初版 2005 年
作为第一部关于太平洋二战终局的跨国史著作——也是唯一一部全面整合了美国、苏联和日本角色的书籍——Tsuyoshi Hasegawa 追溯了错综复杂的外交与军事残局，打破了关于日本投降的传统定论。——封底折页。
正在加载完整评论……
……苏联进攻满洲（就在长崎原子弹投下的同一天清晨）才迫使他们意识到这一点。有两本非常详尽的好参考书：Gar Alperovitz 的《The Decision to Use the Atomic Bomb》和长谷川毅（Tsuyoshi Hasegawa）的《Racing the Enemy》。> 他们还做出了几项大幅减少死亡人数的决定——比如，没有选择相对较小的军事目标并分批投放，……
…forced to realize it by the Soviet invasion of Manchuria (the same morning that the Nagasaki bomb was dropped). Two good detailed references are The Decision to Use the Atomic Bomb by Gar Alperovitz and Racing the Enemy by Tsuyoshi Hasegawa. > they also made several decisions that massively limited the amount of death - for instance, instead of picking relatively small military targets and staggering their delivery,…
……当时找出的诸多借口，而你给出的这个并不在其中）。文章中提到的 Gar Alperovitz 的书也值得一读，长谷川毅的另一部历史研究《Racing the Enemy》[1] 同样如此。后一本书不仅仅是关于使用原子弹的决定，更广泛地探讨了对日战争结束的整个过程，但那个决定以及产生它的过程……
…number of justifications that were made at the time, and the one you give is not one of them). The Gar Alperovitz book referenced in the article is also worth reading, as is another historical study, Racing the Enemy [1] by Hasegawa. The latter book is not solely about the decision to use the bomb, but more generally about the process by which the war with Japan ended, but that decision and the process that produced…
……对天皇来说是一种保全面子的方式，免得不得不承认真正促成决定的，是日本极其渴望向美国而非苏联投降。欲看详尽而透彻的阐述，请参阅长谷川毅的力作《Racing the Enemy》：https://www.amazon.com/Racing-Enemy-Stalin-Truman-Surrender/...
…way for the Emperor to save face and not have to admit that it was really the strong desire of the Japanese to surrender to the US and not to the USSR that drove the decision. See the excellent book Racing the Enemy by Hasegawa for a detailed and thorough exposition: https://www.amazon.com/Racing-Enemy-Stalin-Truman-Surrender/...
……长谷川毅（Tsuyoshi Hasegawa）表示：“在促使日本投降方面，它起到的作用比原子弹更大，因为它彻底粉碎了日本通过莫斯科斡旋结束战争的任何希望。”他最近出版的《Racing the Enemy》审视了太平洋战争的收尾阶段，该书基于最新解密的苏联档案以及美日文献……“天皇和（政府内部的）主和派加快了……
…greater role than the atomic bombs in inducing Japan to surrender because it dashed any hope that Japan could terminate the war through Moscow's mediation," said Tsuyoshi Hasegawa, whose recently published "Racing the Enemy" examines the conclusion of the Pacific war and is based on recently declassified Soviet archives as well as U.S. and Japanese documents.. "The emperor and the peace party (within the government) hastened…
……日本人美军储备充足。[1] [0] Frank, Richard B. (1999). 《Downfall: the End of the Imperial Japanese Empire》. New York: Penguin. ISBN 978-0-14-100146-3 [1] Hasegawa, Tsuyoshi (2005). 《Racing the Enemy: Stalin, Truman, and the Surrender of Japan》. Cambridge, Massachusetts: Harvard University Press. ISBN 978-0-674-01693-4 -- > AGI 你个人是一个通用智能（General Intelligence）；我们有的是人工智能（Artificial Intelligence）。……
…Japanese that the U.S. had a large supply.[1] [0] Frank, Richard B. (1999). Downfall: the End of the Imperial Japanese Empire. New York: Penguin. ISBN 978-0-14-100146-3 [1] Hasegawa, Tsuyoshi (2005). Racing the Enemy: Stalin, Truman, and the Surrender of Japan. Cambridge, Massachusetts: Harvard University Press. ISBN 978-0-674-01693-4 -- > AGI You personally are a General Intelligence; we have Artificial Intelligence.…
……原子弹袭击才是导致日本投降的原因。你这有出处吗？我刚搜了 10 分钟，没找到任何有说服力的依据。我能找到最接近的也就是《Racing the Enemy》，它认为正是苏联计划中的进攻迫使日本投降。但除此之外，整件事情显然要复杂得多，而且绝对远谈不上被“推翻”到……
…that the atom bomb attack is what caused the Japanese to surrender Do you have a source for this? I just spent 10 minutes searching, and I could find nothing compelling. The closest I could find was Racing the Enemy, which argues that it was the planned Soviet invasion that pushed the Japanese to surrender. But otherwise, the story seems a lot more complex than that, and is certainly nowhere near "discredited" to…