当哈利变成莎莉
When Harry Became Sally
Ryan T. Anderson · 初版 2018 年
8位读者提及
8次提及
一个男孩会被“困”在女孩的身体里吗？现代医学能够“重新指定”性别吗？我们的性别在一开始就是被“指定”的吗？对于经历性别认知冲突的人，最具关爱的回应是什么？我们的法律在“性别认同”问题上应该作何规定？When Harry Became Sally 为我们这个跨性别时代所引发的种种问题提供了深思熟虑的解答。Ryan Anderson 汲取了生物学、心理学和哲学领域的深刻见解，对人类的具身性提出了细致入微的看法，针对性别认同提出了平衡的公共政策方法，并冷静审视了这些问题背后的代价
Hacker News 上怎么说
正在加载完整评论……
……在接受更多元的性取向（比如同性恋）方面存在挣扎。这表明社会需要继续进步，以减轻对医疗系统的影响。- 这篇文章围绕 Ryan Anderson 写的一本名为《When Harry Became Sally》的书展开，他显然是宗教和保守派的声音（https://www.amazon.com/Ryan-T-Anderson/e/B00A0P0MR6?ref=sr_n...）
…struggle with accepting more diverse sexuality (being gay). This points to a need for continued societal growth in order to impact the medical system less. - The article centers around a book called When Harry Became Sally written by Ryan Anderson who is clearly a religious and conservative voice (https://www.amazon.com/Ryan-T-Anderson/e/B00A0P0MR6?ref=sr_n...)
确实。比起学校图书馆下架了什么书，Amazon 内部的禁书名单能更准确地反映出美国到底在压制哪些思想。最近一个著名的例子就是《When Harry Became Sally》。
Exactly. Amazon’s internal list of banned books gives a much more accurate idea of what ideas are suppressed in America than what gets taken off a school library shelf. A recent well-known example being When Harry Became Sally.
那绝对是来自政府施压的审查，但随着政府更迭，这种压力也就消失了。https://www.amazon.com/When-Harry-Became-Sally-Transgender/d... Wikipedia：> 2021 年 2 月，该书成为该公司实施新的仇恨言论政策后从 Amazon.com 商店下架的第一本书。这一举动受到了全国反审查联盟（National Coalition…）的批评……
That was definitely censorship through government pressure, but as governments change, the pressure goes away. https://www.amazon.com/When-Harry-Became-Sally-Transgender/d... Wikipedia: > In February 2021 the book was the first removed from Amazon.com's store under a new hate speech policy enacted by the company. The move was criticized by the National Coalition…
……那些原本就接触不到这些书的儿童和青少年依然接触不到。> 建议你查查你当地高中的图书馆里是否有《When Harry Became Sally》、《The Bell Curve》甚至《The Blank Slate》的实体书。这三本里有两本都有[1][2]。你得重新评估一下你的预设了。（顺便说一句：我长大的那个学区，学生们同时能借阅到……
…that children and young adults who otherwise wouldn't have access to these books continue to not have access. > I invite you to check if the library of your local high school has a physical copy of say "When Harry Became Sally", "The Bell Curve", or even "The Blank Slate" It has two of the three[1][2]. You need to reevaluate your assumptions here. (And note: I grew up in a district where students simultaneously have access…
……这个，而这很可能只是个版权问题或其他良性原因。但我倒挺想看到一个 Amazon Streisand 服务，专门通报被 Amazon “被消失”的东西，比如这个以及《When Harry Became Sally》。也许背后有某种意识形态规律，谁知道呢。https://humanevents.com/2021/02/23/amazon-sneakily-removes-b...
…this, when it could easily be a licensing issue or something else benign. But I would be interested in an Amazon Streisand service that simply reports things that Amazon has disappeared, such as this and When Harry Became Sally. Maybe there is an ideological pattern, dunno. https://humanevents.com/2021/02/23/amazon-sneakily-removes-b...
……被误导了？是否存在/曾经存在过 shadowban，但并不是 Amazon 自己的打手干的，而是第三方操纵了 Amazon 的排名信号？也许吧，我也不清楚。不过，你试着搜一下《When Harry Became Sally》就知道了。当你发现根本搜不到它时，你可能会好奇为什么 Amazon 决定审查它，而且不是通过在搜索或推荐中降权，而是直接彻底拒绝销售……
…misinformed? Is/was there a shadowban, but one caused by third parties manipulating Amazon's ranking signals rather than by Amazon's own minions? Maybe. I have no idea. However, just try to search for "When Harry Became Sally". When you discover that you can't find it, you might be curious to know why Amazon decided to censor it, not by deranking it in searches or recommendations, but by outright refusing to sell it at all…