贝伦与露西恩
Beren and Lúthien
J.R.R. Tolkien、Christopher Tolkien、ʻImanuʼel Loṭem · 初版 2017 年
3人推荐
16位读者提及
17次提及
为什么值得读
- 源于作者真实夫妻情感的经典奇幻爱情故事
- 呈现不同创作阶段的稿件演变与被删改角色
《纽约时报》畅销书 J.R.R. Tolkien 的 Beren And Lúthien 是远古时期的三大“伟大小说”之一。Beren 与 Lúthien 的史诗故事成为了 Tolkien 的世界第一纪元神话传说 The Silmarillion 演进中不可或缺的元素。笼罩着他们爱情的命运始终是故事的核心：Beren 是凡人，而 Lúthien 是不朽的精灵。她的父亲，一位伟大的精灵领主，在 Beren 得以迎娶 Lúthien 之前给他出了一个不可能完成的任务：从最邪恶的造物 Melkor 那里夺得一颗精灵宝钻。本书根据 Tolkien 的手稿精心还原
Hacker News 上怎么说
正在加载完整评论……
我很喜欢读《精灵宝钻》（Silmarillion）里的这个故事。 这是一个关于爱情的奇幻故事，但它深受托尔金对他妻子感情的启发。我读的时候还不知道这一点，他们（贝伦与露西安）相爱的方式可能有点不可思议，但他们的整场冒险以及他们彼此相处的方式让人感觉真实而可信。
I loved to read this story on Silmarillion. It is a fantasy story about love but still being deeply inspired by Tolkien feelings from his wife. I did not knew about it when was reading and how they (Beren and Lúthien) started loving one another can be a bit fantastic but all their adventure and how they 'are' with themselves feels real and veritable.
……有条理的）记录，展现了他的故事随时间演变的过程。克里斯托弗·托尔金后来根据这些手稿不仅出版了故事，还出版了同一个故事在不同创作阶段的相继版本。《贝伦与露西安》（Beren and Luthien）读起来格外有趣，因为你能看到托尔金犯的错误，比如在现存最早的手稿中，抓走贝伦的居然是“可怕的泰维尔多”（the appalling Tevildo）——猫之王子这类角色。
…organized) records of how his stories evolved over time. Christopher Tolkien later published stories from those notes, but also successive versions of the same story from different stages of it's development. "Beren and Luthien" is especially fun because you can see Tolkien's mistakes, such as characters like "the appalling Tevildo", Prince of Cats who captures Beren in the earliest surviving draft.
《精灵宝钻》（The Silmarillion）绝对是那套书里我最喜欢的一本。单单贝伦与露西安（Beren and Luthien）的故事就能拍成一部精彩绝伦的剧集。我也希望他们能走这条路线。
The Silmarillion is by far my favorite book in that set. The story of Beren and Luthien alone would make a fantastic series. I hope that's the route they go as well.
……对亚马逊来说简直是个巨大的扑街惨案。剧情看起来甚至完全没基于托尔金写过的任何东西，这我简直无法理解，明明托尔金写了那么多精彩的故事都还没搬上荧幕（贝伦与露西安、努曼诺尔的沦陷、精灵宝钻以及第一纪元的精灵战争）。而且就像上一楼提到的那样，令人不安的是演员全是查无此人的生面孔，并且跟之前成功的……毫无关联。
…gigantic flop for amazon. The story looks like its not even based on anything Tolkien written, which is beyond me given there are so many interesting tales Tolkien wrote that have not seen the screen(Beren and Luthien, the fall of Numenor, the silmarils and Elvish wars of the 1st age). And like the parent above mentioned it is alarming that the actors are all unheard of and there are no connections to the successful…
这纯属误解。首先，克里斯托弗在《精灵宝钻》之后出版了海量资料：整套《中洲历史》（History of Middle Earth）系列，加上《未完的传说》（Unfinished Tales）、《胡林的儿女》（Children of Húrin）、《贝伦与露西安》（Beren and Lúthien）、《刚多林的陷落》（The fall of Gondolin）以及其他几本书。 但更重要的是，J.R.R. 托尔金本打算像《指环王》一样，把《精灵宝钻》作为一本拥有正史叙事的正式书籍出版，但他去
This is a misunderstanding. Firstly, Christopher published tons of material after the Silmarillion: the whole History of Middle Earth series, plus Unfinished Tales, Children of Húrin, Beren and Lúthien, The fall of Gondolin, and some other books. But more importantly, JRR Tolkien intended to publish the Silmarillion as an actual book with a canon narrative, just like Lord of the Rings, but he die
……异常连贯一致。考虑到绝大部分出版的内容都是 J.R.R. 本人创作的，克里斯托弗·托尔金在汇编时只是做做编辑校对。比方说，《胡林的儿女》（Children of Hurin）和《贝伦与露西安之歌》（The Lay of Beren and Luthien）在 LOTR 和《精灵宝钻》里都有提及，但很大程度上因为篇幅和未完结而没有收录进去（据说《精灵宝钻》本质上只是整部传说故事集（Legendarium）的简明提纲罢了）……
…exceptionally consistent. Considering the bulk of all work put out was done by JRR, with Christopher Tolkien doing editing passes during compilation. For instance, the Children of Hurin and The Lay of Beren and Luthien were described in LOTR and the Silmarillion, but were not included largely due to length and incompleteness (the Silmarillion is really just a Cliff's Notes version of the full Legendarium, allegedly).…