耶路撒冷之前的艾希曼
Eichmann Before Jerusalem
Bettina Stangneth · 初版 2014 年
1人推荐
4位读者提及
4次提及
“对 Adolf Eichmann 生平的全面重新审视，揭示了第三帝国覆灭后他在全球 National Socialists 网络中的活动与恶名，并彻底推翻了 Hannah Arendt 常被引用的‘平庸之恶’（the banality of evil）这一概念。”——
Hacker News 上怎么说
正在加载完整评论……
Eichmann Before Jerusalem
Bettina Stangneth · 初版 2014 年
“对 Adolf Eichmann 生平的全面重新审视，揭示了第三帝国覆灭后他在全球 National Socialists 网络中的活动与恶名，并彻底推翻了 Hannah Arendt 常被引用的‘平庸之恶’（the banality of evil）这一概念。”——
正在加载完整评论……
看来阿伦特看走眼了。她完全被艾希曼给忽悠了。他根本一点都不“平庸”。贝蒂娜·施汤内特（Bettina Stangneth），《耶路撒冷之前的艾希曼》（2014）https://newcriterion.com/article/the-profundity-of-evil/
Seems like Arendt got it wrong. She let herself be fooled by Eichmann. He wasn’t banal at all. Bettina Stangneth, “Eichmann Before Jerusalem” (2014) https://newcriterion.com/article/the-profundity-of-evil/
……埃克托·托巴尔 8. 《恶魔营：一个士兵的驱魔记》，珍妮弗·珀西著 9. 《责任：战时国防部长回忆录》，罗伯特·M·盖茨著 10. 《向死而生：尼禄宫廷中的塞涅卡》，詹姆斯·罗姆著 11. 《耶路撒冷之前的艾希曼：一个大规模杀人犯未被审视的一生》，贝蒂娜·施汤内特著，露丝·马丁英译 12. 《大象连队：一个非凡英雄与助他在二战中拯救生命的动物们…
…Héctor Tobar 8. 'Demon Camp: A Soldier’s Exorcism' by Jennifer Percy 9. 'Duty: Memoirs Of A Secretary At War' by Robert M. Gates 10. 'Dying Every Day: Seneca At The Court Of Nero' by James Romm 11. 'Eichmann Before Jerusalem: The Unexamined Life Of A Mass Murderer' by Bettina Stangneth. Translated by Ruth Martin 12. 'Elephant Company: The Inspiring Story Of An Unlikely Hero And The Animals Who Helped Him Save Lives In World…
我建议大家都去读读对贝蒂娜·施汤内特《耶路撒冷之前的艾希曼》的那篇书评。链接再发一次：http://www.nytimes.com/2014/09/03/books/book-portrays-eichma.... 这本书确实反驳了阿伦特的论点，而且是建立在对大量此前未被审视的一手史料的详尽考证之上的。阿伦特的……
I encourage others to read that review of Bettina Stangneth's "Eichmann Before Jerusalem". Again: http://www.nytimes.com/2014/09/03/books/book-portrays-eichma.... It does contradict Arendt's thesis, and does so with comprehensive grounding in source material that had been unexamined. Arendt's…
……我不同意艾希曼只是个奉命行事的普通人这种说法，因为有大量记录在案的事实表明，他彻头彻尾就是个纳粹人渣，并且全心全意地认同这个角色。> 在《耶路撒冷之前的艾希曼》（2014）中，德国历史学家贝蒂娜·施汤内特揭示了他的另一面，而非那个平庸、看似对政治漠不关心、只是像其他“普通”一心求晋升的官僚一样行事的人。根据……
…disagree with this idea that Einchman was just a simple person who took orders since there are several documented events where it's clear that he was a piece of shit nazi and fully embraced the role. > In Eichmann Before Jerusalem (2014), the German historian Bettina Stangneth reveals another side to him besides the banal, seemingly apolitical man, who was just acting like any other ‘ordinary’ career-oriented bureaucrat. Drawing…