亚洲大趋势
How Asia Works
Joe Studwell · 初版 2013 年
36人推荐
51位读者提及
85次提及
为什么值得读
- 梳理农业机械化到出口导向工业的步骤
- 对比展现日韩中等成功案例与受挫国家
- 探讨早期阶段中央规划与激励机制的作用
对东亚经济学中奏效与失败经验的大胆审视。它探讨了曾被经济学家嘲讽的政策如何在日本、韩国和中国台湾孕育出商业巨头，并成为如今中国崛起的幕后推手；与此同时，西方所能提供的最佳建议却让其在东南亚的盟友在经济上陷入绝境。
Hacker News 上怎么说
正在加载完整评论……
对于对这个话题感兴趣的人，我强烈推荐乔·斯塔威尔（Joe Studwell）写的《亚洲大趋势》（How Asia Works）。它主要聚焦于亚洲在 20 世纪取得巨大经济成功的一部分国家和地区，并仅仅对比了少数几个国家来说明它们为什么可能没那么成功。……
For people interests in this topic, I really recommend the book How Asia Works by Joe Studwell. It focuses mostly on a subset of Asia that has great economic success in the 20th century, and only looks at a few contrasting countries to show perhaps why they didn't work as well.…
我认为广泛普及实用技术知识这一观点是对的，但我不太确信文字阅读（literature）是否真有那么关键。在关于亚洲工业扩张的佳作《亚洲大趋势》中，斯塔威尔指出，当台湾达到中等繁荣且由工业主导时，有一半的劳动力甚至不识字。真正让东亚受益的是……
I think the notion of proliferation of broadly available technical knowledge is correct, but I'm not entirely convinced whether literature in particular was so relevant. In How Asia Works, a great book on industrial expansion in Asia, Studwell notes that when Taiwan was moderately prosperous and dominated by industry half of the workforce could not even read. What really benefited East-Asia…
有一本类似的书叫《亚洲大趋势》（How Asia Works）。[1] 它对亚洲的产业政策做了很好的梳理，讲了哪些管用、哪些不管用。总结来说：第一步：农业机械化，释放人口形成工业劳动力；第二步：扶持出口导向型……
There's a similar book, "How Asia Works".[1] This has a good survey of industrial policy in Asia, what worked and what didn't. Summary: Step 1: Mechanize agriculture, to free up people for an industrial labor force Step 2: Support export-oriented…
……https://www.goodreads.com/review/show/4708765021 另一本极棒的书是诺兰·格雷（Nolan Gray）写的《Arbitrary Lines》——一本讲区划法规（zoning）以及为什么我们都该成为 YIMBY 的好书。我的书评在：https://www.goodreads.com/review/show/4800787011。乔·斯塔威尔写的《亚洲大趋势》深度剖析了日本、韩国和中国为何能发展得如此出色，非常引人入胜。我的书评在：https://www.goodreads.com/review/show/4806521204。我还非常喜欢的一本书是《Firepower》……
…https://www.goodreads.com/review/show/4708765021 Another excellent book is Arbitrary Lines by Nolan Gray - which is a great book about zoning and why we should all be YIMBYs. My review is at : https://www.goodreads.com/review/show/4800787011 How Asia Works by Joe Studwell is a fascinating look at why Japan, South Korea and China have done so well. My review is at : https://www.goodreads.com/review/show/4806521204 Another book I really enjoyed was Firepower…
……当时地球上最资本主义的组织在艺术和建筑上投入巨大，却没能尽早催生工业革命。换个角度来看，去了解一下东方是如何变富的吧。去读读《亚洲大趋势》[1]。这本书很好地研究了部分东亚国家是如何在几十年内从 18 世纪跨入 21 世纪的。早期阶段需要一定程度的中央规划和特定的激励措施。……
…The most capitalist organizations on Earth at the time did a lot for art and architecture, but didn't start the Industrial Revolution early. For a different view, learn how the East got rich. Read "How Asia Works".[1] This is a good study of how some of the east Asian countries went from the 18th century to the 21st in a few decades. The early stages required some degree of central planning, and specific incentives.…
看到评论区里充斥着很多新自由主义经济学的教条，所以我想推荐这本极棒的书：https://www.amazon.co.uk/How-Asia-Works-Success-Failure/dp/1.... 它极其精彩地阐述了制造业（在国家大力贸易保护主义支持下）几乎是所有国家亚洲奇迹的关键组成部分。在我看来，印度……
Seeing a lot of neo-liberal economics dogma here in the comments, and so would like to recommend this excellent book: https://www.amazon.co.uk/How-Asia-Works-Success-Failure/dp/1.... It has an excellent account of how manufacturing (supported by heavy protectionism from the state) was a crucial component of the Asian miracle in nearly all countries. IMO India…