守望之心
Go Set A Watchman
Harper Lee · 初版 2015 年
1人推荐
14位读者提及
14次提及
为什么值得读
- 有助于理解哈珀·李对美国南方生活的真实洞察
- 作者对自身此前树立的叙事进行了深度审视
阿拉巴马州梅科姆县。26岁的 Jean Louise Finch——“Scout”——从纽约市回到故乡探望年迈的父亲 Atticus。故事以当时重塑美国南方的民权运动紧张局势和政治动荡为背景，当 Jean Louise 得知关于她亲密的家庭、小镇以及她最在乎的人那些令人不安的真相时，这次归乡之旅变得苦乐参半。童年的记忆如潮水般涌来，她的价值观与认知陷入怀疑之中。Go Set a Watchman 汇聚了许多来自 To Kill a Mockingbird 的标志性角色，完美刻画了一个年轻
Hacker News 上怎么说
正在加载完整评论……
Harper Lee 在《设立守望者》（Go Set a Watchman）里亲手把它批得体无完肤。不管你怎么看她的第二部小说，为了理解她对南方生活的看法，它都值得一读。
Harper Lee eviscerates it herself in Go Set a Watchman. However you approach her second novel, it's worth the read to understand her outlook on life in the South.
……重新发售；仅仅因为他们拥有版权，并不代表任天堂随便拼凑出来的东西就能真正代表创作者的本意，就像我认为比如《设立守望者》（Go Set a Watchman）的出版并不代表 Harper Lee 的本意一样。
…re-releases; just because they own the copyright I don't think whatever Nintendo slaps together really represents the intent of the artists themselves, in the same way that I don't think, say, the release of Go Set a Watchman says anything about the intent of Harper Lee.
特别是考虑到《设立守望者》（Go Set a Watchman）极其可疑的出版方式——很可能是违背 Harper Lee 本人意愿的，公道地说，“Atticus Finch”应该专指《杀死一只知更鸟》（To Kill a Mockingbird）里的那个角色。
Especially given the extremely shady way in which "Go Set a Watchman" was released, possibly against Harper Lee's desires, it would be fair to say that "Atticus Finch" should refer to the character in "To Kill a Mockingbird."
……受到了如此充满人性尊严和尊重的对待，以至于 Card 因为这么做不得不面对来自自己教会（以及其他教会）的严厉批评。Orson Scott Card 就像 Atticus Finch，而我们大家都在读《设立守望者》（Go Set A Watchman）。如果我们今天对这两个角色所能剩下的只有仇恨、厌恶和号召去盗版图书，那我们到底是在给自己铺就一个怎样的未来？
…was treated with such human dignity and respect that Card had to fend off scathing criticism from his own church (and others') for doing so. Orson Scott Card is like Atticus Finch and we're all reading Go Set A Watchman. If all we can find for either of these characters today is hate and loathing and calls to pirate books, what kind of a future are we really setting ourselves up for?
你怎么敢去质疑一个女性的亲身经历。更不用提 Harper Lee 因为在《设立守望者》（Go Set a Watchman）里展现了角色们20年后的遭遇而遭到的那些网络暴力了。
How dare you question a woman's lived experience. Not to mention the hate Harper Lee got for Go Set a Watchman showing what happened to the characters 20 years later.
……你传达了一种潜台词，即黑人的命运是由白人来决定的。我们想教给孩子的信息比“种族主义是坏的”要深刻得多。这在本书的伪续作《设立守望者》（Go Set a Watchman）中有隐晦的探讨，书中 Atticus 展现出了反对种族融合的顽固狭隘一面。> 你这是在把自己的观点投射给别人，认为持不同政治观点的人只是对事实无知，而这种想法本身就很无知。这里……
…you convey an undertone that outcomes for blacks are for white people to choose. The message we want to teach kids is deeper than racism is bad. This is vaguely addressed in the book's pseudo sequel, go set a watchman, in which Atticus reveals a bigoted side opposing integration. > You're projecting an opinion that people with different political opinions are just ignorant of the facts, which is itself ignorant. There…