非此即彼
Either/Or
Søren Kierkegaard · 初版 1843 年
10人推荐
21位读者提及
24次提及
为什么值得读
- 收录机智风趣的格言集与多篇经典论述
- 提供审视社会与自我存在的独特哲学视角
- 深入探索生存的本质悖论与心理反应
在 Either/Or 中，Kierkegaard 借助两个角色的声音——第一部分中仅被称为“A”的审美青年，以及第二部分中崇尚伦理的法官 Judge Vilhelm——反思了对有意义存在的探寻，探讨的主题广泛涉及 Mozart、戏剧、无聊，并在著名的 Seducer's Diary 中展现了一场对年轻美丽女性愤世嫉俗的诱惑与最终抛弃。作为一部双重性杰作，Either/Or 精彩地剖析了审美与伦理之间的冲突——既讽刺而具诱惑力地沉思伊壁鸠鲁式的享乐，又雄辩地……
Hacker News 上怎么说
正在加载完整评论……
《理想国》- 柏拉图 - 探讨社会为什么会形成现在的模样；《非此即彼》- 克尔凯郭尔 - 作为存在主义之父，他对社会的见解帮我理清了视角；《It's All About Time》- John Furey - 很惊讶没怎么见人提过这本 - 讲人们如何组织……
The Republic - Plato - why societies form the way they do Either/Or - Kierkegaard - as a father of Existentialism his views on society helped put things in perspective for me It's All About Time - John Furey - surprised I don't see this mentioned more - how people organise…
……对我来说毫无意义。（好吧，我确实经历过一段宗教狂热期，当时我很赞同他的观点，觉得基督徒根本就不够基督徒！）但我很喜欢他的很多其他作品。我最喜欢的可能就是《非此即彼》了——其中的某些部分——比如格言集、《轮作》等等。内容非常幽默。他要么写得极其精炼，要么就极其冗长啰嗦。还有对雷金娜无休止的抱怨，读多了真的很烦人……
…that mean nothing to me. (Well, I did have a religious phase where I could agree with him that christians are nowhere near christian enough!) But I love a lot of his other stuff. Maybe my favourite is Either/Or - some parts of it - the aphorisms, Crop Rotation etc. It's very funny stuff. He's either very compressed or extremely long-winded. And the endless whining about Regine gets very tedious..
……这里推荐几本宗教哲学方面的书，读读应该大有裨益：《道德经》；托马斯·阿奎那的《神学大全》；约翰·亨利·纽曼的《同意的文法》；克尔凯郭尔的《非此即彼》
…here are some books from religious philosophy that you'd probably do well to read: The Tao te Ching The Summa Theologica by Thomas Aquinas An Essay in Aid of a Grammar of Assent by John Henry Newman Either/Or by Kierkegaard
《传道书》。（以及其他智慧书）；克尔凯郭尔的《非此即彼》；梭罗的《瓦尔登湖》；威廉·斯特林费洛的《上帝的伪装者：对心爱偶像的探究》（Impostors of God: Inquiries into Favorite Idols）……以及任何优秀的诗歌。
Ecclesiastes. (and the other Wisdom books) Kierkegaard’s Either/Or Thoreau’s Walden William Stringfellow’s Impostors of God: Inquiries into Favorite Idols ... and any good poetry.
克尔凯郭尔的《恐惧与战栗》和《非此即彼》啃起来很费劲，但如果你喜欢思考核心悖论、对存在主义的心理反应之类的话题，那就绝对值了。
Kierkegaard's "Fear and Trembling" and "Either/Or"are hard slogs, but worth it, if you like thinking about essential paradoxes, psychological responses to existentialism, and the like.
离开学术界之前我教过存在主义。正如另一条评论提到的，克尔凯郭尔的《非此即彼》很值得一读，我也推荐《恐惧与战栗》。与这一流派相关的另外两位必读书目作家我认为是陀思妥耶夫斯基和尼采。前者的《地下室手记》就是其中一……
I used to teach Existentialism before leaving academia. As the other comment mentions Kierkegaard's "Either/Or" is worth a read, I also recommend "Fear and Trembling." The other two writers associated with this term I think are must reads are Dostoevsky and Nietzsche. The former's Notes From Underground is one…