多动症并不存在
ADHD Does Not Exist
Richard Saul · 初版 2014 年
1人推荐
6位读者提及
6次提及
在这本开创性且颇具争议的著作中，行为神经学家Richard Saul博士结合自己五十年间治疗数千名被诊断为Attention Deficit and Hyperactivity Disorder（当今增长最快且被广泛诊断的病症之一）患者的经验，指出ADHD实际上是由20多种其他病症与疾患引发的一组综合症状。根据来自Centers for Disease Control and Prevention的近期数据，估计有640万名4至17岁的儿童被诊断出患有attention deficit hyperactivity disor……
Hacker News 上怎么说
正在加载完整评论……
强烈建议了解一下这位医生的观点：他认为 ADD 并不是一种单独存在的病症，而是许多其他潜在病症的一种表象。http://time.com/25370/doctor-adhd-does-not-exist/ 这与我自己接触那些自认为患有 ADD 的人的经历是一致的。他们中有很多人最后发现其实是未经治疗的焦虑和抑郁。同样耐人寻味的是，存在着大量的……
I highly recommend reading about the opinion of this doctor that ADD doesn't exist as a separate condition. It is, instead, a symptom of many other possible conditions. http://time.com/25370/doctor-adhd-does-not-exist/ This is consistent with my own experience with people who believe they have ADD. Many of them turned out to have untreated anxiety and depression. It's also interesting to note that there's a lot of…
……专区，有两本书言之凿凿地说 ADHD 纯粹是捏造出来的病。就是这两本：《戳穿ADHD：停止把孩子的天性当病吃药的10个理由》（Debunking ADHD: 10 Reasons to Stop Drugging Kids for Acting Like Kids）——https://www.amazon.com/dp/1475827377/，《ADHD并不存在：注意力缺失与多动障碍的真相》（ADHD Does Not Exist: The Truth About Attention Deficit and Hyperactivity Disorder）——https://www.amazon.com/ADHD-Does-Not-Exist-Hyperactivity/dp/... 大概是因为现在关乎我的切身利益，我当时感到相当被冒犯……
…section, had two books stating unequivocally that ADHD was a made-up condition. These ones: Debunking ADHD: 10 Reasons to Stop Drugging Kids for Acting Like Kids - https://www.amazon.com/dp/1475827377/ ADHD Does Not Exist: The Truth About Attention Deficit and Hyperactivity Disorder - https://www.amazon.com/ADHD-Does-Not-Exist-Hyperactivity/dp/... And I guess, now that I had a strong personal stake, I felt rather offended…
在《ADHD并不存在》（ADHD Does not Exist）一书中，Richard Saul 描述了神经化学性分心/冲动（也就是我们说的 adhd）的两种类型：低五羟色胺型和高水平肾上腺素/去甲肾上腺素型。“所描述的这两种类型表现出……
In the book "ADHD Does not Exist" Richard Saul describes Neurochemical Diststractibility/Impulsivity(what we call adhd) of two types : low serotoning group and high level epinephrine/norepinephrine group. "The two types described show…
Richard Saul 医学博士的书《ADHD并不存在》（ADHD does not exist）里引用过这个，我找找那本书看能不能扒几个链接出来
It was referenced in the book "ADHD does not exist" from Richard Saul M.D, I'll look for the book to find some links
……克鲁斯说得没错。精神病学很大程度上就是扯淡，那本 DSM 诊断手册几乎就是一帮穿西装的官僚凭空拍脑袋编出来的。在大多数高质量研究中，抗抑郁药的效果并不比安慰剂（placebo）好。还有《ADHD并不存在》（ADHD Does Not Exist），那可是一位曾一手推动其普及、如今却反过来呼吁纠偏的顶级 ADHD 精神病学家的书名。症状是真实存在的，但 ADHD 并不是一种真正的疾病。
…Cruise is right. Psychiatry is largely nonsense and the DSM book is almost arbitrarily made up by a bunch of suits. In most of the higher quality studies, antidepressants are no better than placebo. And “ADHD Does Not Exist”, that’s book title by one of the foremost ADHD psychiatrists who helped popularize it but is now calling for a reversion. The symptoms exist, not ADHD is not a real disease.
……对好几种病毒中任意一种的反应。见鬼，螃蟹或者树都不是单一类别的生物，而是多种生物殊途同归演化出的相同解法。有一位 ADHD 专家兼神经学家写了一本书叫《ADHD并不存在》（ADHD Does Not Exist）。他的核心论点是 ADHD 不是单一疾病，而是由许多不同根本原因汇聚在一起的一组症状群。https://isbn.nu/9780062266743
…reaction to any of several kinds of virus. Hell, a crab or a tree is not one class of things, but many that converged on common solutions. There’s an ADHD specialist, a neurologist, who wrote a book called “ADHD Does Not Exist”. His core argument is that ADHD is not a single disorder but a collection of symptoms that cluster together from many different underlying causes. https://isbn.nu/9780062266743